Skip to content
Insolvency & Bankruptcy Code

Videocon Insolvency: Supreme Court Upholds Remand of Twinstar’s Plan – NCDs Are Not ‘Payment’ to Dissenting Creditors

In Twinstar Technologies Ltd. v. Bank of Maharashtra, 2026 INSC 1214, the Supreme Court dismissed Twinstar’s appeals and upheld the NCLAT’s 2022 decision setting aside approval of its ₹2,962 crore resolution plan for Videocon Industries and 12 group companies and sending it back to the Committee of Creditors. The Court held that a plan paying dissenting financial creditors largely through NCDs redeemable over six years does not provide ‘payment’ under Section 30(2)(b); that the NCLT could not cure this by ordering upfront cash; and that the CoC was not functus officio and could revisit its decision while appeals were pending. In a second group of appeals by former promoter Venugopal Dhoot, the Court held that the foreign oil and gas assets held through subsidiaries are not assets of Videocon and cannot be brought into its CIRP. It also laid down five guardrails for NCLAT remands.

Key Takeaways

  • Following Jaypee Kensington, ‘payment’ to dissenting financial creditors under Section 30(2)(b) means payment in money; NCDs redeemable over six years do not qualify.
  • A general clause promising compliance with Section 30(2)(b) cannot replace a specific provision on how, when and in what form dissenters will be paid.
  • The plan also breached Regulation 38(1)(b) by not giving dissenting creditors priority over assenting creditors.
  • The NCLT cannot modify a plan (e.g., by ordering upfront cash to dissenters); a curable defect must be sent back to the CoC.
  • The NCLAT has an implied power to remand a non-compliant plan to the CoC, supported by Rule 11 of the NCLAT Rules.
  • The CoC is not functus officio after approval; it continues until implementation or liquidation and may reconsider a plan whose approval is under appeal (Kalyani Transco).
  • Assets of Indian or foreign subsidiaries are excluded from the corporate debtor’s estate by the Explanation to Section 18 and Section 36(4)(d).
  • Five guardrails now govern NCLAT remands, including a finding of legal non-compliance and strict timelines.

Case Details at a Glance

Case titleTwinstar Technologies Ltd. v. Bank of Maharashtra and others (with connected appeals by Venugopal Dhoot and VIL Vendors Association)
Citation2026 INSC 1214 (Reportable)
Case numbersCivil Appeal Nos. 894, 512, 509 and 1307 of 2022; 8659–8661 and 8718–8719 of 2026; and Diary Nos. 41234 and 41286 of 2026
BenchJustice Pamidighantam Sri Narasimha and Justice Alok Aradhe
Authored byJustice Alok Aradhe
Date of judgment16 November 2026
Corporate debtorsVideocon Industries Ltd. and 12 group companies (consolidated CIRP); VOVL Ltd.
Impugned ordersNCLAT judgments dated 05.01.2022 and 14.05.2026
ResultAll appeals dismissed; remand to CoC upheld; foreign oil and gas assets kept out of VIL’s CIRP

Background

SBI and other lenders initiated CIRP against 13 Videocon group companies in 2018; the NCLT, Mumbai consolidated them on 08.08.2019. Admitted claims were about ₹64,838 crore. The fair value and liquidation value were ₹4,069.95 crore and ₹2,568.13 crore.

Twinstar Technologies (the SRA) offered ₹2,962.02 crore: ₹200 crore upfront to financial creditors, ₹52 crore to workmen and employees, ₹10 crore to operational creditors, and NCDs of ₹2,700 crore at 6.65% redeemable in instalments from 25 months to the sixth year. The CoC approved it on 11.12.2020 with 95.09%; four creditors with about 3.08% dissented. The promoter’s Section 12A withdrawal proposal was rejected by 98.14%.

The NCLT approved the plan on 08.06.2021 – a haircut of about 95.85% – but directed that dissenting creditors be paid their liquidation value in cash upfront. On appeal by Bank of Maharashtra, IFCI and SIDBI, the NCLAT stayed the approval, and the CoC itself (about 95%) sought to reconsider. On 05.01.2022 the NCLAT set aside the approval and remitted the matter to the CoC, which resolved to invite fresh bids. The Supreme Court had asked the CoC not to proceed pending these appeals.

Part A: Twinstar’s Appeals

Jurisdiction of NCLT and NCLAT

The Code itself defines the limits: the NCLT checks the plan against Section 30(2) under Section 31, and the NCLAT may interfere only on the grounds in Section 61(3).

Power to remand exists

Neither tribunal can modify a plan or substitute its commercial judgment, and outright rejection may lead to liquidation, a last resort. An express appellate power carries the incidental power to remit. Jaypee Kensington recognised it; Rule 11 supports it; and a later amendment to Section 31, allowing notice to the CoC to rectify defects, reflects the same policy.

NCDs are not ‘payment’

“Compliance with Section 30(2) of the Code is to be found in the terms of the plan, and not in an undertaking to comply.” – Supreme Court, 2026 INSC 1214, para 27.4

Dissenting creditors were not carved out for payment in money; they were left within the same NCD structure. That breaches Section 30(2)(b) and Regulation 38(1)(b), and amounts to contravention of law under Section 61(3)(i).

NCLT could not cure the defect

Ordering upfront cash to dissenters changed the payment structure and the order of distribution among financial creditors – an impermissible modification, even though CoC’s counsel had made a statement to that effect.

CCI approval was obtained

Correcting the NCLAT, the Court found from a CCI communication dated 08.12.2020 that approval preceded the close of voting, satisfying the proviso to Section 31(4) as explained in Independent Sugar Corporation.

CoC not functus officio; may revisit

The CoC is a commercial body, not an adjudicator, and continues until implementation or liquidation (Kalyani Transco). Since approval was stayed with status quo ante and never became final, the CoC could reconsider. Ebix and Amtek Auto concerned resolution applicants trying to walk away, and S.M. Kamal Pasha concerned a CoC withdrawing from a compliant plan; none protects a non-compliant plan.

Part B: The Foreign Oil and Gas Assets

The Brazilian and Indonesian oil and gas interests are held through a chain of subsidiaries (VOVL, VHHL, VEBL, VINI and the Brazilian JV IBV with BPRL). The promoter argued they should be included in VIL’s CIRP. The Court disagreed:

  • A holding company does not own its subsidiary’s assets (Vodafone International Holdings). The Explanation to Section 18 and Section 36(4)(d) expressly exclude assets of Indian or foreign subsidiaries.
  • The promoter himself had asked SBI to shift facilities to VOVL alone and had acquiesced in the consolidated CIRP excluding VOVL; he could not approbate and reprobate.
  • Complaints about the haircut, liquidation value and rejection of his Section 12A proposal fall within the CoC’s non-justiciable commercial wisdom (K. Sashidhar, Essar Steel).
  • Allegations of fraud and collusion against SBI, the RP and the CoC lacked particulars.
  • The VOVL CIRP transaction – transfer of pledged quotas to BPRL under its right of first refusal, approved by 99.96% – was not disturbed.

The VIL Vendors Association’s appeal was dismissed, with liberty to pursue remedies such as avoidance applications under Sections 43–51 and 66 before the Adjudicating Authority.

Guardrails for NCLAT Remand

Noting that remands carry costs – delay, uncertainty, expense and erosion of asset value – the Court set out five considerations:

  1. Remand must advance the Code’s objectives: keeping the debtor a going concern, fair recovery for all creditors, and value maximisation.
  2. It must rest on a finding of legal non-compliance, under Section 30(2) or any other law within Section 61(3)(i).
  3. It must be used sparingly and must not depart from any express procedure in the Code.
  4. It may serve a corrective function where the NCLT modified a plan instead of remitting it to the CoC.
  5. Every remand must carry a strict direction to adhere to the Code’s timelines.

All appeals were dismissed. GAIL’s claim and the Union of India’s contentions on oil and gas blocks under production sharing contracts were left open for the RP and the Adjudicating Authority.

Practical Significance

  • Resolution applicants: provide a distinct, cash-based payment mechanism for dissenting financial creditors, with priority over assenting creditors. Compliance boilerplate will not save a plan.
  • CoCs: the CoC retains the power to reconsider while approval is under challenge, but should act through its commercial wisdom and record reasons.
  • Promoters and operational creditors: subsidiaries’ assets cannot be pulled into the parent’s CIRP; consider a separate CIRP or avoidance remedies.
  • NCLAT practice: remand orders must now be justified against the five guardrails and must set strict timelines.

For Videocon’s creditors, the ruling means the resolution process resumes before the CoC, more than eight years after the CIRP began.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can a resolution plan pay dissenting financial creditors in NCDs?

No. In 2026 INSC 1214 the Supreme Court held that NCDs redeemable over six years are not ‘payment’ under Section 30(2)(b) of the IBC, which requires payment in money.

Can the NCLT fix a defective plan by changing payment terms?

No. The NCLT cannot modify a plan. It must send a curable defect back to the CoC for reconsideration.

Is the CoC functus officio after approving a resolution plan?

No. The CoC continues until the plan is implemented or liquidation is ordered, and can reconsider where approval has not attained finality.

Are assets of a subsidiary part of the parent company’s CIRP?

No. The Explanation to Section 18 and Section 36(4)(d) exclude assets of Indian or foreign subsidiaries of the corporate debtor.

When can the NCLAT remand a resolution plan?

Only on a finding of legal non-compliance, sparingly, in furtherance of the Code’s objectives, and with strict directions to follow the timelines.

This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Readers should refer to the certified copy of the judgment and consult a qualified professional before acting. See our Editorial Policy and Disclaimer.