Supreme Court Sets Aside NCLAT Order That Quashed a Resolution Plan Without Hearing the Successful Resolution Applicant
In Birendra Kumar Agrawal v. S2 Tech.com India Pvt Ltd and another, 2026 INSC 1225, the Supreme Court of India set aside a judgment of the NCLAT, Chennai, that had declared the approved resolution plan of Valentis Laboratories Pvt. Ltd. for Manjeera Constructions Limited invalid – even though Valentis, the successful resolution applicant, was never a party before the Appellate Tribunal. The Court called it a “flagrant violation of the principle of audi alteram partem”.
Key Takeaways
- A tribunal cannot invalidate a resolution plan without hearing the successful resolution applicant (SRA), the party most vitally affected.
- Breach of natural justice alone was enough to set aside the NCLAT judgment; the Court did not examine the merits.
- No remand was ordered, because appeals against the NCLT's approval of the plan are already pending before the NCLAT.
- All issues, including the alleged late payment of the earnest money deposit (EMD), are left open for those pending appeals.
- A dissenting creditor that challenges a plan must implead and pursue impleadment of the SRA, and must challenge the NCLT's approval order itself.
Case Details at a Glance
| Case title | Birendra Kumar Agrawal v. S2 Tech.com India Pvt Ltd and another |
|---|---|
| Connected matter | Civil Appeal No. 4585 of 2026 (Surya Treasure Island Pvt. Ltd., for the VLPL–Surya consortium) |
| Citation | 2026 INSC 1225 (Non-reportable) |
| Case number | Civil Appeal No. 4171 of 2026 |
| Court | Supreme Court of India, Civil Appellate Jurisdiction |
| Bench | Justice Sanjay Kumar and Justice Sanjeev Sachdeva |
| Authored by | Justice Sanjay Kumar |
| Date of judgment | 16 November 2026 |
| Provision | Section 62, Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 (appeal to Supreme Court); Sections 30(6) and 31(1) |
| Impugned order | NCLAT, Chennai, judgment dated 19.03.2026 in Company Appeal (AT) (CH) (Ins) No. 456 of 2024 |
| Corporate debtor | Manjeera Constructions Limited (MCL), corporate guarantor |
| Result | Appeals disposed of; NCLAT judgment set aside; all issues left open |
Background of the Dispute
Catalyst Trusteeship Limited, a financial creditor, initiated the corporate insolvency resolution process (CIRP) under Section 7 of the IBC against Manjeera Retail Holdings Private Limited, the principal borrower, and its corporate guarantor, Manjeera Constructions Limited. The petition against MCL, CP (IB) No. 320/7/HDB/2022, was admitted by the NCLT, Hyderabad Bench-II, on 18.07.2023.
The Resolution Professional, Birendra Kumar Agrawal, invited expressions of interest on 10.01.2024. Four prospective resolution applicants – Vasavi Realty Pvt. Ltd., Valentis Laboratories Pvt. Ltd. (VLPL), Boorugu Infra Projects Pvt. Ltd. and Gajjala Yoganand – submitted plans. At its 12th meeting on 10.06.2024, the Committee of Creditors (CoC) approved VLPL's plan with a 91.64% voting share.
S2 Tech.com India Pvt. Ltd., a financial creditor holding only a 3.3% voting share, then moved IA (IBC) 1565/2024 seeking rejection of VLPL's plan. One of its grounds was that VLPL had not remitted the earnest money deposit within the time fixed by the Request for Resolution Plan (RFRP). The NCLT dismissed the application on 30.07.2024, holding that a creditor which had participated in the CoC meeting had no locus to challenge the majority decision, while noting that it would still examine the plan within the parameters of the IBC.
Timeline of Events
- 18.07.2023NCLT admits Section 7 petition against Manjeera Constructions Limited.
- 10.01.2024RP issues Invitation for Expression of Interest.
- 10.06.2024CoC approves VLPL's resolution plan with 91.64% vote.
- 18.07.2024S2 Tech.com files IA (IBC) 1565/2024 seeking rejection of the plan.
- 30.07.2024NCLT dismisses the IA for want of locus.
- 14.09.2024S2 Tech.com appeals to NCLAT, Chennai – without impleading VLPL.
- 26.03.2025NCLT approves VLPL's plan under Sections 30(6) and 31(1). S2 Tech.com does not challenge this order.
- 19.03.2026NCLAT allows S2 Tech.com's appeal and holds VLPL's plan liable to be declared invalid.
- 13.04.2026Supreme Court stays the NCLAT judgment.
- 16.11.2026Supreme Court sets aside the NCLAT judgment.
What the NCLAT Did
The appeal before the NCLAT was only against the NCLT's order of 30.07.2024 rejecting S2 Tech.com's interlocutory application. When it filed the appeal, S2 Tech.com knew that the CoC had already approved VLPL's plan, yet it did not make VLPL a party. Even after the NCLT approved the plan on 26.03.2025, VLPL was not brought on record. An impleadment application was filed but never pursued, and had not even been numbered when the appeal was decided.
Despite this, the NCLAT held that the NCLT's order was passed without application of mind, declared that VLPL's plan was liable to be invalidated, and issued various directions to the Resolution Professional. The Supreme Court noted that the NCLAT went “far beyond” the issues actually raised in the IA, and that it acted in ignorance of the NCLT's intervening approval of the plan.
Supreme Court's Ruling
The Court found the core defect to be simple and decisive: the NCLAT passed a judgment against VLPL, visiting it with serious civil consequences, without giving it a hearing.
“This flagrant violation of the principle of audi alteram partem by the NCLAT is sufficient to render its judgment dated 19.03.2026 unsustainable in law.” – Supreme Court, 2026 INSC 1225, para 10
Why there was no remand
Ordinarily, a breach of natural justice leads to a remand for fresh hearing. Here, the Court declined to do so. Three separate appeals against the NCLT's approval order of 26.03.2025 were already pending before the NCLAT – by Gajjala Yoganand (Company Appeal No. 200 of 2025), the homebuyers of MCL (Company Appeal No. 7 of 2026) and Saasa Villa LLP (Company Appeal No. 348 of 2025). The EMD issue had been raised in those appeals too. Since the NCLT's approval was an intervening event that directly affected the appeal, the Court held that it would suffice to set aside the impugned judgment and let all issues be raised in those “duly constituted appeals”.
Final directions
- The NCLAT judgment dated 19.03.2026 in Company Appeal (AT)(CH)(Ins) No. 456/2024 is set aside.
- All issues are left open for the pending appeals challenging the NCLT's order approving VLPL's resolution plan.
- Pending applications disposed of; parties to bear their own costs.
Analysis: Why the SRA Is a Necessary Party
The rule of audi alteram partem – hear the other side – is the core of natural justice. Once the CoC approves a plan, the successful resolution applicant acquires a real stake in the outcome – it has deposited money, made commitments and, after NCLT approval under Section 31, is bound to implement the plan. Any order that declares the plan invalid directly affects its rights. Under the general principle reflected in Order I of the Code of Civil Procedure, a party without whom no effective order can be passed is a necessary party. The Supreme Court applied the more basic rule underneath it: no one should be condemned unheard.
The judgment also highlights a procedural gap in S2 Tech.com's strategy. It appealed against a rejected interlocutory application, but never challenged the NCLT's later order approving the plan. An appeal against an interim refusal cannot be used to undo a final approval order that has not itself been challenged, especially when the beneficiary of that order is absent.
It is worth noting what the Court did not decide. It expressly declined to examine the validity of the NCLAT's reasoning on the EMD or on the scope of the issues. Those questions remain open. The judgment is also marked non-reportable, so its value lies mainly in reaffirming a settled principle rather than laying down new law.
Practical Lessons for Creditors, RPs and Applicants
For dissenting or minority creditors
- Implead the successful resolution applicant at the first opportunity, and press the impleadment application to a decision.
- Challenge the NCLT's approval order under Section 31 directly; an appeal against an interim order may become infructuous.
- Keep the appeal within the scope of the original application.
For successful resolution applicants
- Monitor appeals arising from the CIRP, and apply to intervene if a challenge touches your plan.
- Where an adverse order is passed in your absence, the breach of natural justice is itself a strong ground of appeal under Section 62.
For resolution professionals
- Bring the CoC's approval and the NCLT's approval order to the appellate tribunal's notice promptly.
- Point out non-joinder of the SRA at the earliest stage of any appeal.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can the NCLAT invalidate a resolution plan without hearing the successful resolution applicant?
No. In 2026 INSC 1225 the Supreme Court held that such a judgment, passed without hearing the SRA, is a flagrant violation of audi alteram partem and unsustainable in law.
Why did the Supreme Court not send the matter back to the NCLAT?
Separate appeals against the NCLT's approval order of 26.03.2025 were already pending before the NCLAT, and the EMD issue was raised there too. The Court left all issues open to be decided in those appeals.
Did the Court decide whether the earnest money deposit was paid in time?
No. The judgment was set aside only on the ground of breach of natural justice. The EMD question remains open for the pending appeals.
Does a 3.3% creditor have locus to challenge a plan approved by the CoC?
The NCLT had held it had no locus since it participated in the CoC meeting. The Supreme Court did not rule on this point; it set aside the NCLAT judgment on natural justice grounds alone.
Who must be made a party when a resolution plan is challenged?
The successful resolution applicant, as the party most vitally affected. A creditor challenging the plan should implead it and pursue that impleadment.
This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Readers should refer to the certified copy of the judgment and consult a qualified professional before acting. See our Editorial Policy and Disclaimer.
