Skip to content
Insolvency & Bankruptcy Code

Supreme Court: Creditor Bound by a Sanctioned SICA Scheme Cannot Revive a Section 9 IBC Petition for Full Dues

In Ganesh Benzoplast Ltd. v. State Trading Corporation of India, 2026 INSC 1223, the Supreme Court set aside an NCLAT judgment that had revived STC’s Section 9 insolvency petition against Ganesh Benzoplast. Since STC appeared only as a ‘contingent liability’ in the rehabilitation scheme sanctioned under SICA, it could at most be treated as an unsecured creditor entitled to 25% of its principal dues – which it had already been paid under the NCLT’s order. With nothing left to adjudicate, the Court restored the NCLT’s 2020 order closing the petition.

Key Takeaways

  • A rehabilitation scheme sanctioned under SICA binds all creditors, including unsecured creditors and ‘unsecured creditors in waiting’ (contingent claimants).
  • Following Modi Rubber Ltd. v. Continental Carbon India Ltd., (2023) 17 SCC 263, unsecured creditors have no valid option to reject the scaled-down value and wait to claim full dues later.
  • A contingent claimant becomes an unsecured creditor only on crystallisation of its claim, and then ranks on par with other unsecured creditors – 25% of principal here.
  • The IBC does not provide for determination or quantification of liability; a contingent claim cannot be crystallised through a Section 9 petition.
  • A creditor that accepted its classification in a published scheme and never objected cannot dispute it years later.
  • Once the maximum realisable amount (₹2,18,88,421) was paid, nothing remained to adjudicate in the Section 9 petition.

Case Details at a Glance

Case titleM/s. Ganesh Benzoplast Ltd. v. The State Trading Corporation of India
Citation2026 INSC 1223 (Reportable)
Case numberCivil Appeal No. 3097 of 2026
BenchJustice Sanjay Kumar and Justice Sanjeev Sachdeva
Authored byJustice Sanjay Kumar
Date of judgment16 November 2026
ProvisionsSections 8, 9 and 62, IBC; Sections 3(1)(o) and 15(1), SICA
Impugned orderNCLAT, Principal Bench, judgment dated 21.01.2026 in Company Appeal (AT)(Ins) No. 753 of 2021
ResultAppeal allowed; NCLT Mumbai order dated 13.02.2020 restored

Background

Ganesh Benzoplast, a Maharashtra chemicals and storage-terminal company, traded with STC in 2003–2006. After erosion of its net worth, it was declared a sick industrial company by BIFR on 06.05.2010. A Draft Rehabilitation Scheme, with cut-off date 31.03.2011, was circulated in 2013 and published in newspapers. When BIFR stopped functioning, the Delhi High Court approved the scheme on 04.12.2015. An SLP by another creditor against that approval was dismissed on 10.04.2018.

Clause 11.11 of the scheme provided that unsecured creditors would be paid 25% of principal dues in five annual instalments, with an option not to accept the scaled-down value and wait until the scheme worked out or seven years. STC was not in the list of 191 unsecured creditors; it appeared in the list of contingent liabilities, with a claim of ₹11.35 crore. STC never objected.

On 20.03.2018, STC issued a Section 8 demand notice for ₹24.26 crore and filed a Section 9 petition. During its pendency, the company supplied the ‘C’ Forms, which removed the sales-tax component. On 13.02.2020, the NCLT, noting STC’s own rejoinder that it was entitled to 25% under the scheme, directed payment of ₹2,18,88,421 and disposed of the petition. STC accepted the payment without prejudice on 20.03.2020.

Timeline

  1. 06.05.2010BIFR declares the company sick.
  2. 18.04.2013Draft Rehabilitation Scheme circulated; STC shown as contingent liability.
  3. 04.12.2015Delhi High Court approves the scheme.
  4. 20.03.2018STC issues Section 8 demand notice for ₹24.26 crore.
  5. 13.02.2020NCLT directs payment of 25% of principal and disposes of the petition.
  6. 02.04.2025Supreme Court holds STC’s NCLAT appeal within time and remands it.
  7. 21.01.2026NCLAT restores the Section 9 petition.
  8. 16.11.2026Supreme Court sets aside the NCLAT judgment.

Supreme Court’s Ruling

STC never acted under Clause 11.11

The NCLAT accepted STC’s argument that it could choose the second option – wait and claim full dues. The Court held that the options were available only to unsecured creditors, not to contingent claimants. STC’s claim had never crystallised. In any case, its demand notice came within the seven-year waiting period, so it was not acting under the scheme at all. Having accepted its classification and never challenged it, it was too late to dispute it.

The ‘wait and claim full dues’ option is invalid

Applying Modi Rubber Ltd. v. Continental Carbon India Ltd. and Fertilizer Corporation of India Ltd. v. Coromandel Sacks Pvt. Ltd., (2024) 8 SCC 172, the Court held that once a scheme is sanctioned, it binds all creditors. Unsecured creditors cannot refuse the scaled-down value, because that would make revival unworkable and expose a rehabilitated company to sickness again.

“...the approved RS was binding on all concerned, i.e., the unsecured creditors and the unsecured creditors in waiting...” – Supreme Court, 2026 INSC 1223, para 14

A contingent claimant cannot rank higher than an unsecured creditor

The NCLAT’s attempt to distinguish Modi Rubber because STC was only a contingent liability ‘defies logic’. At best, on crystallisation, STC would join the unsecured creditors and get 25% of principal – never more.

No instalments from 2015 either

STC’s complaint that it was not paid in five instalments from 2015 was misconceived: it became entitled only on crystallisation, which it never sought. The IBC does not provide for determining or quantifying liability, so it could not use Section 9 to crystallise its claim.

Nothing left to decide

STC had already received the maximum it could realise under the scheme. Restoring the petition served no purpose. The NCLAT judgment was set aside and the NCLT’s order of 13.02.2020 restored.

Analysis and Practical Lessons

Although SICA was repealed in 2016, many companies still operate under schemes sanctioned during the BIFR era, and creditors sometimes try to use the IBC to recover dues those schemes scaled down. This judgment shuts that door firmly: the IBC cannot be used to obtain more than the sanctioned scheme allows, and it is not a forum to crystallise disputed or contingent claims.

  • Creditors: object to your classification when a draft scheme is published. Silence will bind you.
  • Corporate debtors: where a creditor seeks full dues despite a sanctioned scheme, rely on Modi Rubber and this judgment; an offer of the scheme amount can bring closure.
  • Adjudicating authorities: a Section 9 petition is not a recovery suit; where the scheme entitlement is paid, there is nothing to adjudicate.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is a SICA rehabilitation scheme binding on unsecured creditors?

Yes. Following Modi Rubber, the Supreme Court in 2026 INSC 1223 held that a sanctioned scheme binds all creditors, including unsecured creditors and contingent claimants.

Can an unsecured creditor reject the scaled-down amount and claim full dues later?

No. The Court held that such an option in the scheme was not valid, as it would make rehabilitation unworkable.

Can a creditor use Section 9 of the IBC to crystallise a contingent claim?

No. The Court noted that the IBC regime does not provide for determination or quantification of liability.

Why was the Section 9 petition not restored?

Because STC had already received 25% of its principal dues, the maximum it could get under the scheme, so nothing remained to be adjudicated.

This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Readers should refer to the certified copy of the judgment and consult a qualified professional before acting. See our Editorial Policy and Disclaimer.