Lender and Debenture Trustee With Pervasive Control Over the Debtor Are Related Parties: Supreme Court Excludes ECL Finance From CoC
In ECL Finance Ltd. v. Abhinav Mukherjee, 2026 INSC 1159, the Supreme Court upheld the exclusion of ECL Finance, as lender and sole debenture holder, and IDBI Trusteeship as debenture trustee, from the Committee of Creditors of Palm Developers Pvt. Ltd., a corporate guarantor of loans and debentures of about Rs 200 crore taken by Saha Infratech for real estate projects in Greater Noida. A homebuyer objected. The Court corrected the tribunals on two points: a guarantee is a financial debt under Section 5(8), and a claim does not fail because the guarantee was not invoked before CIRP (China Development Bank). But on facts it agreed they were related parties under Section 5(24)(m) because the debenture deed, facility agreement, power of attorney and the debtor’s articles gave ECL pervasive control over management, appointments, sales and revenues. A recent assignment to another entity after CIRP began, against a forensic audit finding of diversion, could not cure the disqualification.
Key Takeaways
- A guarantee for a debt is a financial debt under Section 5(8)(i) IBC; the NCLT misread Anuj Jain.
- A financial creditor’s claim on a guarantee does not fail merely because the guarantee was not invoked before CIRP (China Development Bank v. Doha Bank).
- A person on whose advice, directions or instructions the debtor’s directors or management are accustomed to act is a related party under Section 5(24)(m).
- Contractual rights to nominate directors, veto changes in key managers, appoint agents, control sales and escrowed revenues amount to pervasive, not merely protective, control.
- Related-party financial creditors are barred from the CoC under the first proviso to Section 21(2); a debenture trustee for a related-party sole debenture holder is also barred.
- A post-CIRP assignment by a related party, not ‘long ago’ and in apparent bad faith, does not let the assignee into the CoC (Phoenix ARC).
Case Details at a Glance
| Case title | ECL Finance Ltd. and Anr. v. Abhinav Mukherjee and Ors. (with connected appeal and contempt petitions) |
|---|---|
| Citation | 2026 INSC 1159 (Reportable) |
| Bench | Justice J.B. Pardiwala and Justice K. Vinod Chandran |
| Authored by | Justice K. Vinod Chandran |
| Date of judgment | 27 October 2026 |
| Corporate debtor | Palm Developers Pvt. Ltd. (corporate guarantor of Saha Infratech Pvt. Ltd.) |
| Claims | IDBI Trusteeship: about Rs 131.17 crore; ECL Finance: about Rs 139.03 crore |
| Result | Appeals dismissed; contempt petitions closed |
Facts of the Case
Saha Infratech issued Rs 110 crore of debentures, all held by ECL Finance with IDBI Trusteeship as trustee, and took a Rs 90 crore facility from ECL, both for projects including ‘Project Encore’ in Greater Noida. Palm Developers, the corporate debtor, gave corporate guarantees and its shares were pledged. CIRP against Palm Developers began in January 2020, and both ITSL and ECL were admitted to the CoC.
A homebuyer objected. The NCLT held the claims were not financial debt because the debtor was only a guarantor, and that the appellants were related parties. The NCLAT held the claim failed as the guarantee was not invoked before CIRP and affirmed the related party finding. A forensic audit had found the debtor was used to divert funds to promoter-controlled entities.
Timeline of Proceedings
- 13.05.2016Debenture Trust Deed.
- 22.09.2017Facility Agreement with corporate guarantee.
- 27.01.2020CIRP of Palm Developers admitted.
- NCLT and NCLATAppellants held related parties and excluded from CoC.
- 27.10.2026Supreme Court dismisses appeals.
Issues Before the Supreme Court
- Is a corporate guarantee a financial debt, and must it be invoked before CIRP for the creditor to claim?
- Were ECL and its debenture trustee related parties barred from the CoC?
- Does a later assignment of the debt cure the bar?
Supreme Court’s Ruling
1. Guarantee is financial debt; invocation not needed
Section 5(8) expressly includes liability under a guarantee. Following China Development Bank v. Doha Bank, (2025) 7 SCC 729, no default or invocation is required for a debt to be financial debt and the holder to be a financial creditor. The tribunals erred on these points.
2. Pervasive control makes a related party
The sanction letter gave ECL the right to appoint a director and an observer; the facility agreement barred removal of key managers without its consent and let it require changes in key staff; it could appoint agents for sale of units; a power of attorney gave sweeping powers over construction, approvals and sales with proceeds in escrow; and the debtor’s articles put project revenues under ECL’s control. This was all-pervasive, not merely negative or protective, control.
3. Both ECL and the trustee excluded
As sole debenture holder with such control, ECL is a related party and barred under the first proviso to Section 21(2); this extends to its status as lender. The trustee, protecting ECL’s interest, is also excluded.
4. Assignment does not help
ECL assigned its facility rights to the second appellant long after CIRP began. Under Phoenix ARC, such a recent assignment, against a backdrop of alleged diversion, is not bona fide.
“From the above, it is crystal clear that ECL has an all-pervasive control, insofar as the projects of the principal Borrower are concerned.” – Supreme Court, 2026 INSC 1159, para 23
Result
Finding no question of law and no perversity in the related party finding, the Court dismissed the appeals and closed the contempt petitions.
Analysis and Practical Points
Real estate financiers often take extensive control rights to protect their money. This ruling warns that beyond a point those rights convert a lender into a related party, costing it a vote in the CoC where homebuyers have a stake.
- Lenders and NBFCs: review nominee director, veto, sales and escrow control rights in group and guarantor documents; they can make you a related party.
- Homebuyers: individual homebuyers may raise related party objections to CoC composition.
- Assignees: debt bought from a related party after CIRP starts will be scrutinised for bad faith.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is a corporate guarantee a financial debt under the IBC?
Yes. In 2026 INSC 1159 the Supreme Court confirmed that Section 5(8) includes guarantees and that invocation before CIRP is not required.
When does a lender become a related party of the corporate debtor?
When the debtor's directors or management are accustomed to act on its advice or directions, as shown by pervasive control rights over management, sales and revenues.
Can a related party financial creditor vote in the CoC?
No. The first proviso to Section 21(2) of the IBC bars related-party financial creditors from representation, participation and voting in the CoC.
Can a related party get around the bar by assigning its debt?
Not where the assignment is recent and made in bad faith. Following Phoenix ARC, such an assignee is treated like a related party.
This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Readers should refer to the certified copy of the judgment and consult a qualified professional before acting. See our Editorial Policy and Disclaimer.
