Court of Law and Court of Equity: Supreme Court Ends Atibir Industries NPA and ARC Assignment Dispute by Fixing Rs 125 Crore Over Rs 250 Crore Already Paid
In Atibir Industries Co. Ltd. v. State Bank of India, 2026 INSC 1156, a Bench of Chief Justice Surya Kant, Justice Joymalya Bagchi and Justice V. Mohana brought a long-running dispute to an end without deciding the legal questions. A sponge iron manufacturer had challenged SBI’s classification of its account as NPA with effect from 16 October 2020, relying on RBI COVID-19 relief circulars, and the assignment of its debt to an asset reconstruction company for Rs 250 crore. A Calcutta High Court Single Judge set aside both; the Division Bench reversed, holding NPA classification is borrower-wise. During the appeal, the company paid Rs 250 crore and a former Supreme Court Judge, Justice Anil R. Dave, assessed further liability. Taking note of the speed of the assignment, the unrebutted allegation that a business competitor funded the ARC, and the company’s employees, the Court directed payment of Rs 125 crore more as full and final settlement, leaving the legal issues open.
Key Takeaways
- The Supreme Court exercised equitable jurisdiction to do complete justice, fixing a settlement sum instead of ruling on the NPA and assignment questions.
- Validity of the NPA classification, the assignment to the ARC and compliance with Section 5 of the SARFAESI Act were expressly kept open.
- The Court declined to decide whether an ARC’s claim should be based on debt value or acquisition value.
- Rs 125 crore over Rs 250 crore already paid was fixed using the highest 15% rate in the referee’s report, the time elapsed and the ARC’s costs.
- On payment within 12 weeks, title deeds, securities and guarantees must be released, and the NCLT and DRT proceedings stand disposed of.
- Default in the timeline revives all proceedings and the borrower loses the benefit of the judgment.
Case Details at a Glance
| Case title | Atibir Industries Co. Ltd. v. State Bank of India & Anr. |
|---|---|
| Citation | 2026 INSC 1156 (Reportable) |
| Case number | Civil Appeals arising out of SLP (C) Nos. 21029-30 of 2024 |
| Bench | Chief Justice Surya Kant, Justice Joymalya Bagchi and Justice V. Mohana |
| Authored by | Justice V. Mohana |
| Date of judgment | 26 October 2026 |
| Impugned judgment | Calcutta High Court Division Bench, 25.07.2024 in APO No. 180 of 2023 |
| Result | Appeals disposed of; Rs 125 crore more within 12 weeks as full and final settlement |
Facts of the Case
The appellant, a manufacturer of sponge iron and pig iron, borrowed from an SBI-led consortium. After defaults in 2020, SBI classified its account as NPA with effect from 16 October 2020, filed before the DRT and NCLT, issued SARFAESI notices, rejected one-time settlement offers of up to Rs 238 crore, and then put the loan up for e-auction as a stressed asset. It assigned the debt to an ARC for Rs 250 crore on 24 March 2023, the day the company filed a fresh writ petition.
A Single Judge held the NPA classification premature under RBI’s master circular read with the COVID relief circulars, and set aside the assignment. The Division Bench reversed, holding classification is borrower-wise and SBI could sell the asset under Section 5 of the SARFAESI Act. In the Supreme Court the company paid Rs 250 crore, and Justice Anil R. Dave was appointed to assess further liability.
Timeline of Proceedings
- 16.10.2020Date from which account was treated as NPA.
- 08.07.2022SARFAESI Section 13(2) notice.
- 10.02.2023Web notice for e-auction of stressed loan.
- 24.03.2023Loan assigned to ARC for Rs 250 crore.
- 25.07.2024Calcutta High Court Division Bench rules for the banks.
- 09.12.2024Justice Anil R. Dave appointed to assess liability.
- 09.07.2025Report submitted.
- 26.10.2026Supreme Court fixes Rs 125 crore as final settlement.
Issues Before the Supreme Court
- Was the NPA classification valid in light of the RBI COVID-19 relief circulars?
- Was the assignment of debt to the ARC valid, and how should the borrower’s remaining liability be fixed?
Supreme Court’s Ruling
1. Conduct of the parties
The Court noted that the assignment happened in quick succession after SBI had approached the DRT and NCLT and invoked SARFAESI, all of a sudden after rejecting the settlement offer. There was no denial of the allegation that the ARC’s funds came from a business competitor, and the ARC did not produce its financial statements or borrowing cost before the referee.
2. Legal issues kept open
Validity of the NPA classification, the assignment, and Section 5 compliance were not decided, nor whether compensation should be based on debt value or acquisition value.
3. Equitable settlement
Considering the running business, employees’ livelihoods, RBI circulars and the pandemic, the Court fixed Rs 125 crore over Rs 250 crore already paid, describing itself as a court of equity as well as of law.
“This Court is not only the Court of law but also a Court of equity.” – Supreme Court, 2026 INSC 1156, para 43
Result
The appellant must pay Rs 125 crore within 12 weeks as full and final settlement. The respondents must then return title deeds and release all securities and guarantees within four weeks, and the NCLT and DRT proceedings stand disposed of. On default, the respondents may revive proceedings and the judgment’s benefit is lost.
Analysis and Practical Points
Though not a precedent on the legal questions, the case shows how the Supreme Court may intervene where a bank’s sudden assignment of a disputed account to an ARC looks unfair to a running business.
- Borrowers: challenge NPA classification promptly, and document COVID relief entitlements and settlement offers.
- Banks and ARCs: transparency about funding and costs matters when courts assess equitable liability.
- Timelines: equitable relief is conditional; missing deadlines revives full liability.
Frequently Asked Questions
Did the Supreme Court decide whether the NPA classification was valid?
No. In 2026 INSC 1156 the Court kept the NPA classification, assignment and SARFAESI Section 5 issues open.
How much did Atibir Industries have to pay?
Rs 125 crore over the Rs 250 crore already paid, within 12 weeks, as full and final settlement of the assigned debt.
Why did the Court intervene on equitable grounds?
It noted the rapid assignment after rejecting the settlement offer, the unrebutted allegation that a competitor funded the ARC, the running business and its employees.
What happens if the borrower does not pay on time?
The respondents may revive the proceedings and the benefit of the judgment is lost.
This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Readers should refer to the certified copy of the judgment and consult a qualified professional before acting. See our Editorial Policy and Disclaimer.
