Skip to content
Negotiable Instruments · SARFAESI

Asset Reconstruction Company Can Be Substituted as Complainant in Pending Cheque Bounce Case Under Section 5 SARFAESI, but Must Prove It Is Holder in Due Course

In Kishore Avarsekar v. Assets Care and Reconstruction Enterprises Ltd., 2026 INSC 1217, the Supreme Court decided a question on which, the petitioners said, it had not ruled before: can an asset reconstruction company (ARC) that acquires a bank’s financial assets, including security cheques, be substituted in place of the bank in a pending complaint under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act? Dismissing the accused’s SLP against a Bombay High Court judgment, the Court held that the phrase ‘other proceeding of whatever nature’ in Section 5(4) of the SARFAESI Act is deliberately wide and covers a cheque bounce complaint, so it does not abate on assignment. But it added a caveat: assignment alone does not make the ARC the payee or holder in due course, and the ARC must strictly prove this at trial.

Key Takeaways

  • Under Section 5(2) SARFAESI, an ARC acquiring financial assets is deemed the lender and all the bank’s rights vest in it.
  • Section 5(4) provides procedural continuity: pending proceedings relating to the asset do not abate; Section 5(5) governs substitution, with the originator’s consent.
  • ‘Other proceeding of whatever nature’ is not read ejusdem generis with ‘suit’ and ‘appeal’; it includes a criminal complaint under Section 138 NI Act.
  • The SICA exception built into Section 5(4) shows Parliament intended the phrase to go beyond civil suits and appeals.
  • Caveat: the ARC must prove that the cheque itself was transferred and delivered, that there was an endorsement or assignment making it a holder in due course under Sections 8 and 9 NI Act, that Section 138 ingredients are met, and that it does not improve the original complainant’s case.
  • These are factual questions to be decided on evidence at trial.

Case Details at a Glance

Case titleKishore Avarsekar and Ors. v. Assets Care and Reconstruction Enterprises Ltd. and Ors.
Citation2026 INSC 1217 (Reportable)
Case numberSpecial Leave Petition (Crl.) No. 20619 of 2026
BenchJustice Dipankar Datta and Justice Sheel Nagu
Authored byJustice Dipankar Datta
Date of order4 November 2026
Impugned judgmentBombay High Court judgment dated 03.08.2026 in Criminal Writ Petition No. 2776 of 2023
Law involvedSection 5, SARFAESI Act, 2002; Sections 8, 9, 138, 141 and 142, Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881
ResultSLP dismissed; substitution of ARC upheld, subject to strict proof at trial

Facts of the Case

A bank filed a complaint under Section 138 read with Sections 141 and 142 of the NI Act against the petitioners over dishonoured cheques taken as security. Later, the bank assigned its financial assets, including the cheques, to Assets Care and Reconstruction Enterprises Ltd., an ARC, under a deed of assignment under Section 5 of the SARFAESI Act. The magistrate allowed the ARC to be substituted as complainant; this was upheld by the Sessions Court and then by the Bombay High Court.

The accused argued that there was no Supreme Court ruling on the point, that Section 5(4) and (5) should be read ejusdem generis to cover only civil proceedings (relying on Bombay High Court rulings under the Companies Act, 1956 and the IBC), and that the ARC was not the ‘payee’ and did not satisfy the conditions of a holder in due course under Section 9 NI Act.

Issues Before the Supreme Court

  1. Does ‘other proceeding of whatever nature’ in Section 5(4) SARFAESI include a criminal complaint under Section 138 NI Act?
  2. Can an ARC be substituted as complainant in place of the assignor bank?
  3. Does assignment alone make the ARC the payee or holder in due course?

Supreme Court’s Ruling

1. Scheme of Section 5 SARFAESI

Section 5(1) allows an ARC to acquire a bank’s financial assets. Section 5(2) is the substantive vesting provision: the ARC is deemed the lender and all the bank’s rights vest in it. Section 5(3) keeps contracts and instruments relating to the asset in force for the ARC. Section 5(4) ensures that pending proceedings do not abate and may be continued by or against the ARC, and Section 5(5) lays down the procedure for substitution, with the consent of the originator.

2. Ejusdem generis does not apply

The words ‘suit, appeal or other proceeding’ are not limited to civil or recovery proceedings. The only exception carved out is a reference under SICA before the BIFR, which is neither a suit nor an appeal. That exception shows the phrase was meant to go beyond suits and appeals. A Section 138 complaint, though criminal in form, is covered if it relates to the acquired financial asset and was pending on the date of acquisition. This fits the object of facilitating acquisition of assets with all attached remedies.

3. The caveat: strict proof of holder in due course

The complaint does not abate on assignment, but assignment does not by itself make the ARC the payee or holder in due course. To continue, the ARC must prove:

  • the dishonoured cheque itself, not merely the underlying debt, was transferred and delivered to it;
  • an endorsement or assignment in its favour sufficient to make it a holder in due course under Sections 8 and 9 NI Act;
  • the ingredients of Section 138 are satisfied; and
  • it is not improving upon the case of the original complainant.

These factual questions must be decided on evidence at trial.

“Such width is intentional to ensure that no proceeding relating to the financial asset is lost for want of a party to prosecute it.” – Supreme Court, 2026 INSC 1217, para 15

Result

The special leave petition was dismissed. The substitution of the ARC as complainant stands, but the ARC is put to strict proof at trial that it is the holder in due course of the cheques.

Analysis and Practical Points

ARCs routinely acquire stressed loan books that come with pending cheque bounce cases. This ruling gives them continuity while protecting accused persons through the strict-proof requirement.

  • ARCs: ensure the assignment deed expressly transfers the cheques, obtain physical delivery and endorsements, and secure the originator’s consent for substitution under Section 5(5).
  • Accused persons: substitution cannot be resisted merely because the complaint is criminal, but the ARC’s title to the cheque and holder-in-due-course status can be contested at trial.
  • Banks: keep records of security cheques and their transfer when assigning portfolios.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can an asset reconstruction company continue a cheque bounce case filed by a bank?

Yes. In 2026 INSC 1217 the Supreme Court held that a pending Section 138 NI Act complaint is an 'other proceeding of whatever nature' under Section 5(4) of the SARFAESI Act and does not abate when the bank assigns the asset to an ARC.

Does assignment of the loan make the ARC the holder in due course of the cheque?

Not automatically. The ARC must prove that the cheque itself was transferred and delivered to it and that it qualifies as a holder in due course under Sections 8 and 9 of the NI Act.

Is the bank's consent needed for substitution?

Section 5(5) of the SARFAESI Act allows the ARC to apply for substitution with the consent of the originator, that is the assigning bank or financial institution.

Can the ARC improve the bank's case after substitution?

No. The Court said the ARC must not attempt to improve upon the case of the original complainant.

This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Readers should refer to the certified copy of the judgment and consult a qualified professional before acting. See our Editorial Policy and Disclaimer.