CoC Cannot Back Out of an Approved Resolution Plan Because the Debtor’s Finances Improved: Supreme Court Leaves Approval and OTS Pleas to NCLT
In Bank of India v. S.M. Kamal Pasha, 2026 INSC 1154, the Supreme Court refused to interfere with an NCLAT order holding that a Committee of Creditors cannot withdraw a resolution plan it had approved, even unanimously, on the ground that the corporate debtor’s finances had improved during years of delay. The debtor, a highway toll operator hit by Covid, had about Rs 30 crore in cash when a Rs 172.55 crore plan was approved; by the time litigation ended, cash had grown to about Rs 165 crore. The creditors called it a windfall for the resolution applicant; the applicant called the U-turn opportunism. Following Ebix Singapore and explaining Kalyani Transco, the Court reaffirmed that an approved plan binds both the CoC and the applicant, and directed the NCLT to decide together the pending application for approval of the plan and the promoter’s one-time settlement proposal, checking Section 30(2) compliance against the debtor’s current finances.
Key Takeaways
- A CoC-approved resolution plan binds both the CoC and the successful resolution applicant (Ebix Singapore).
- The CoC does not become functus officio on approval and retains an interest until implementation (Kalyani Transco), but it cannot take decisions that affect a plan already submitted to the Adjudicating Authority.
- Improved profitability of the corporate debtor alone is not a reason to refuse approval if the plan meets Section 30(2).
- Even under Section 12A, withdrawal by the CoC carries consequences; an SRA failing to implement faces forfeiture of guarantee and prosecution under Section 74.
- The NCLT must decide the approval application and the promoter’s OTS application together, after verifying the debtor’s present finances.
- Long delays in approval affect commercial assessments and undermine the IBC’s timelines.
Case Details at a Glance
| Case title | Bank of India & Ors. v. S.M. Kamal Pasha & Ors. |
|---|---|
| Citation | 2026 INSC 1154 (Reportable) |
| Bench | Justice J.B. Pardiwala and Justice K. Vinod Chandran |
| Authored by | Justice K. Vinod Chandran |
| Date of judgment | 26 October 2026 |
| Appellants | Six members of the Committee of Creditors, led by Bank of India |
| Plan value | Rs 172.55 crore; debtor’s cash rose from about Rs 30 crore to Rs 165 crore during delay |
| Result | Appeal disposed of; NCLAT order upheld; NCLT to decide pending applications together |
Facts of the Case
Bank of India initiated CIRP against a toll-collection company on National Highway 45. The CoC approved a resolution plan of Rs 172.55 crore submitted by a consortium, when the debtor had about Rs 30 crore in cash and its business had suffered during Covid. The holding company challenged the process, and a stay by the Supreme Court delayed approval. By the time the SLP was dismissed, the debtor’s cash balance had grown to about Rs 165 crore.
The CoC unanimously sought to withdraw its approval and issue a fresh Form G, and the NCLT allowed this. The holding company sought to end the CIRP through a one-time settlement. The NCLAT held that the CoC had no jurisdiction to withdraw an approved plan and revived the application for approval, directing all contentions to be considered by the NCLT.
Timeline of Proceedings
- CIRPInitiated by Bank of India under Section 7 IBC.
- ApprovalCoC approves Rs 172.55 crore plan; RP files IA No. 1505 of 2021.
- DelaySupreme Court stay on promoter’s challenge; cash builds to Rs 165 crore.
- 2025NCLT allows withdrawal; holding company files OTS application.
- NCLATWithdrawal set aside; approval application revived.
- 26.10.2026Supreme Court upholds NCLAT.
Issues Before the Supreme Court
- Can a CoC withdraw its approval of a resolution plan because the corporate debtor’s financial position improved during delay not attributable to the resolution applicant?
Supreme Court’s Ruling
1. Ebix Singapore: plans are binding
In Ebix, resolution applicants could not withdraw on grounds such as investigations or economic slowdown, as the IBC does not allow common law remedies like frustration to undo an approved plan. The same binding nature applies to the CoC.
2. Kalyani Transco explained
Kalyani Transco held the CoC continues until implementation, but under Regulation 18 its decisions cannot affect a plan already submitted to the Adjudicating Authority. That case did not permit modification or withdrawal and upheld the plan’s binding nature.
3. Competing claims of commercial wisdom
The CoC argued maximisation of value; the applicant argued the improvement was foreseen in the plan and the CoC’s turnaround was opportunism. These are for the NCLT to weigh when deciding approval under Section 31(1), checking Section 30(2) compliance against the present cash position. Improved profitability alone is not a ground to refuse approval.
“The improved profitability alone cannot be a reason to refuse approval if the Resolution Plan meets the requirements under sub-section (2) of Section 30.” – Supreme Court, 2026 INSC 1154, para 25
Result
The appeal was disposed of without interfering with the NCLAT order. The NCLT is requested to take up together the application for approval of the plan and the holding company’s application for implementing the OTS, and decide expeditiously. Except on the binding nature of the plan, the Court’s observations are prima facie.
Analysis and Practical Points
Long delays between CoC approval and NCLT sanction are common, and the debtor’s fortunes can change sharply. This ruling stops creditors from treating an approved plan as an option to be abandoned when values rise, just as Ebix stopped applicants from walking away when values fell.
- Committees of Creditors: build mechanisms into the plan for sharing upside from cash accumulated during CIRP before voting to approve.
- Resolution applicants: an approved plan protects you, but keep performance guarantees alive and press for early approval.
- Promoters: OTS proposals during pending approval will be considered by the NCLT, but face the binding nature of the approved plan.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can the CoC withdraw an approved resolution plan?
Not on the ground that the debtor's finances improved. In 2026 INSC 1154 the Supreme Court reaffirmed that an approved plan binds both the CoC and the resolution applicant.
Does the CoC cease to exist after approving a plan?
No. Following Kalyani Transco, it continues until implementation, but it cannot take decisions that affect a plan already submitted to the NCLT.
Can improved profitability lead the NCLT to reject a plan?
Improved profitability alone is not a reason to refuse approval if the plan meets the requirements of Section 30(2) of the IBC.
What happens to the promoter's one-time settlement offer?
The NCLT will consider it together with the application for approval of the plan.
This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Readers should refer to the certified copy of the judgment and consult a qualified professional before acting. See our Editorial Policy and Disclaimer.
