Skip to content
Armed Forces · Pension

Soldier Who Developed Rheumatoid Arthritis at Kargil Gets War Injury Pension: Supreme Court Holds Operation Rakshak Falls Under Category E(i)

In Union of India v. Narender Kumar, 2026 INSC 1166, the Supreme Court dismissed the Ministry of Defence’s appeal and upheld the grant of War Injury Pension, instead of ordinary disability pension, to a soldier who developed rheumatoid arthritis while posted at Kargil under Operation Rakshak between 2003 and 2005. The MoD argued that Category E(i) of its 31 January 2001 policy, covering ‘operations specially notified by the Government from time to time’, applies only to operations like Operation Sindoor or Snow Leopard, not ongoing ones like Operation Rakshak. The Court held that the policy draws no such distinction; once an operation is notified, Category E(i) applies, and pension policies must be read liberally. It urged the MoD to issue clear, comprehensive rules and to state expressly in future notifications whether Category E(i) benefits apply.

Key Takeaways

  • Category E covers death or disability in war or war-like situations; sub-category E(i) covers ‘operations specially notified by the Government from time to time’.
  • Once an operation is notified, E(i) applies unless the policy or the notification says otherwise; the MoD’s oral distinction between operations was rejected.
  • Courts do not accept a policymaker’s interpretation that goes beyond the plain language or is arbitrary; ‘What a policy says, it is’.
  • Pension policies are interpreted liberally in favour of personnel.
  • Army Order 1 of 2003 on battle casualties caused more confusion than clarity and was not relied on.
  • Future notifications must state clearly whether Category E(i) benefits apply.

Case Details at a Glance

Case titleUnion of India & Ors. v. Narender Kumar
Citation2026 INSC 1166 (Reportable)
Case numberCivil Appeal arising out of SLP (C) Diary No. 27220 of 2026
BenchJustice Pamidighantam Sri Narasimha and Justice Alok Aradhe
Date of judgment28 October 2026
Impugned ordersAFT order dated 08.04.2024 in OA No. 221 of 2019; Punjab and Haryana High Court order dated 11.08.2025 in CWP No. 23117 of 2025
DisabilityRheumatoid arthritis (seropositive) and spinal disc conditions; assessed at 70%, rounded to 75%
ResultUnion’s appeal dismissed; war injury pension upheld

Facts of the Case

The respondent joined the Army in 1996. Posted at Kargil from July 2003 to July 2005 under Operation Rakshak, he was diagnosed with rheumatoid arthritis, and later with spinal disc conditions while posted in West Bengal. Discharged on 31 January 2013 after over 16 years of service, he was granted disability pension, with the Release Medical Board assessing his disabilities as aggravated by service at 70%, rounded to 75%.

About six years later he sought War Injury Pension for the rheumatoid arthritis under Category E(i), Para 4.1 of the MoD policy of 31 January 2001. The Armed Forces Tribunal allowed his claim, holding that the disease originated in Kargil, an operational area. The High Court dismissed the MoD’s writ petition.

Timeline of Proceedings

  • 30.12.1996Enrolled in the Army.
  • 2003 to 2005Posted at Kargil under Operation Rakshak; rheumatoid arthritis diagnosed.
  • 31.01.2013Discharged with disability pension.
  • 08.04.2024AFT grants war injury pension.
  • 11.08.2025High Court dismisses MoD’s writ.
  • 28.10.2026Supreme Court dismisses MoD’s appeal.

Issues Before the Supreme Court

  1. Does disability arising during posting under Operation Rakshak qualify for war injury pension under Category E(i) of the MoD policy dated 31.01.2001?

Supreme Court’s Ruling

1. Uncertainty in the rules

The Court remarked on the continuing uncertainty over which MoD rules and policies apply and urged comprehensive, clearly identifiable subordinate legislation. Para 4.1 of the 2001 policy is now reflected in Regulation 82 of the Pension Regulations for the Army, 2008.

2. Category E and sub-category (i)

Sub-categories (a) to (h) describe war or extreme violence. Sub-category (i) gives flexibility to add specially notified operations. Its plain language does not distinguish between ‘special’ operations and ongoing ones; only the ASG’s oral submission did.

3. Limits on the policymaker’s interpretation

The defence administration controls policy, but must articulate its scope clearly. Courts disregard interpretations that go against plain language, are arbitrary or discriminatory, or defeat the policy’s purpose. E(i) is enabling and, as a pension provision, must be read liberally.

“While interpreting the plain language of the policy, Courts will simply declare, What a policy says, it is and not what is in the imagination of the policymaker.” – Supreme Court, 2026 INSC 1166, para 18

Result

The appeal was dismissed and the war injury pension upheld. The Court directed that, when notifying operations in future, the Government must state in clear terms whether Category E(i) pensionary benefits apply.

Analysis and Practical Points

The ruling opens the door for other personnel disabled during notified ongoing operations, such as in Jammu and Kashmir, to claim war injury pension, which is more generous than disability pension. The MoD’s concern that every soldier posted under Operation Rakshak may claim it was answered by placing the burden on the Government to draft clearly.

  • Veterans: check whether your disability arose during a notified operation and whether the Release Medical Board linked it to that posting.
  • MoD: future notifications must specify whether Category E(i) benefits apply.
  • AFT practice: policies are read by plain language, liberally in favour of the pensioner.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is a soldier posted under Operation Rakshak entitled to war injury pension?

In 2026 INSC 1166 the Supreme Court upheld war injury pension for a soldier whose rheumatoid arthritis originated during his Kargil posting under Operation Rakshak, holding Category E(i) applies to notified operations.

What is Category E in the MoD pension policy?

It covers death or disability in war or war-like situations, such as enemy action, border skirmishes, mine operations, extremist violence and operations specially notified by the Government.

Can the Ministry of Defence narrow its policy through interpretation?

Not beyond the policy's plain language. The Court said what a policy says is what it means, not what the policymaker imagines.

What must the Government do in future?

When notifying operations, it must declare clearly whether Category E(i) pensionary benefits apply.

This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Readers should refer to the certified copy of the judgment and consult a qualified professional before acting. See our Editorial Policy and Disclaimer.