No Textile Cess on Job Work Bleaching and Dyeing of Powerloom Fabrics: Supreme Court Says Processing Is Not ‘Manufacture’ Under Section 5A
In Assessing Officer, Textiles Committee v. M/s Premium Suiting Pvt. Ltd., 2026 INSC 1158, the Supreme Court upheld an Allahabad High Court judgment quashing a textile cess demand of Rs 2,68,293 on a processor that bleached and dyed man-made fabrics received from powerloom and handloom units on job work and returned them. Section 5A of the Textiles Committee Act, 1963 levies cess on textiles ‘manufactured’ in India, but its proviso exempts textiles manufactured out of the handloom or powerloom industry. The Court held that ‘manufacture’, not being defined in the Act, must be given its common meaning and cannot be borrowed from the Central Excise Act. The processor only upgraded the fabric as an extended arm of the exempt powerloom manufacturers; no textile was manufactured in its units.
Key Takeaways
- Section 5A levies textile cess on textiles and textile machinery ‘manufactured’ in India; textiles manufactured out of handloom or powerloom industry are exempt.
- ‘Manufacture’ is not defined in the 1963 Act and must be given its common-parlance meaning.
- Definitions in other statutes, such as the Central Excise Act, cannot be borrowed unless the statutes are in pari materia.
- Bleaching, dyeing and processing on job work, with the fabric returned to the powerloom manufacturer, is an ancillary activity, not manufacture.
- The processor acts as an extended arm of the exempt manufacturer; the upgraded fabric is not a ‘textile manufactured’ by it.
Case Details at a Glance
| Case title | The Assessing Officer, Textiles Committee v. M/s Premium Suiting Pvt. Ltd. & Another |
|---|---|
| Citation | 2026 INSC 1158 (Reportable) |
| Bench | Justice S.V.N. Bhatti and Justice N.V. Anjaria |
| Authored by | Justice N.V. Anjaria |
| Date of judgment | 26 October 2026 |
| Impugned judgment | Allahabad High Court order dated 06.03.2013 in Writ Tax No. 354 of 2006 |
| Demand | Textile cess of Rs 2,68,293 |
| Result | Appeal dismissed; cess demand stays quashed |
Facts of the Case
The respondent bleaches, dyes and processes 100% man-made fabrics supplied by powerloom and handloom units, which use fewer than 50 looms and have no spinning plants. After an audit noted that most independent processors in Uttar Pradesh were not paying textile cess, the Textiles Committee issued a show cause notice in 2001 and assessed cess of Rs 2,68,293, taking the view that the powerloom exemption applied only at the loom stage.
The Textiles Committee Cess Appellate Tribunal, relying on its own earlier decision, held processing to be manufacture and dismissed the appeal. The Allahabad High Court allowed the writ, holding that job work processing did not erase the status of the fabric as a powerloom product.
Timeline of Proceedings
- 20.08.2001Show cause notice for textile cess.
- 21.11.2001Assessment of Rs 2,68,293.
- 2005Appellate Tribunal dismisses the processor’s appeal.
- 06.03.2013Allahabad High Court quashes the demand.
- 26.10.2026Supreme Court dismisses the Committee’s appeal.
Issues Before the Supreme Court
- Is bleaching, dyeing and processing of powerloom and handloom fabrics on job work ‘manufacture’ attracting textile cess under Section 5A?
Supreme Court’s Ruling
1. Common meaning of manufacture
The Act does not define ‘manufacture’. Relying on cases including Maheshwari Fish Seed Farm, the Court held that it is hazardous to import a definition from another statute unless the statutes are in pari materia, as legislatures often give artificial meanings to suit a particular enactment.
2. No manufacture by the processor
The fabric is manufactured by the powerloom and handloom units. The processor receives it, bleaches and dyes it on job work, and returns it. This is a supplementary activity that upgrades the textile; it does not result in a ‘textile manufactured’ by the processor.
3. Exemption applies
Since textiles of powerloom and handloom industry are expressly exempt, and the processor acts as their extended arm, no cess is payable.
“At the best, it is the textile upgraded, not to become manufacture in its sense as could be applied in the context of Section 5A.” – Supreme Court, 2026 INSC 1158, para 6.7
Result
The appeal of the Textiles Committee was dismissed and the High Court’s order quashing the cess demand upheld.
Analysis and Practical Points
Although the textile cess under Section 5A was abolished from 2016, legacy demands remain in litigation, and the ruling’s reasoning on not borrowing the excise definition of ‘manufacture’ is of wider value.
- Job workers and processors: where the principal is exempt, processing on job work that returns goods to the principal may share that exemption.
- Tax practitioners: challenge attempts to import definitions from other fiscal statutes that are not in pari materia.
- Revenue authorities: legacy textile cess demands on processors of powerloom fabrics are unlikely to survive.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is dyeing and bleaching of powerloom fabric manufacture for textile cess?
No. In 2026 INSC 1158 the Supreme Court held that job work processing of powerloom and handloom fabrics is not manufacture under Section 5A of the Textiles Committee Act.
Can the Central Excise definition of manufacture be used for textile cess?
No. The Court held that definitions in other statutes cannot be borrowed unless the laws are in pari materia; common meaning applies.
Are handloom and powerloom textiles exempt from textile cess?
Yes. The proviso to Section 5A exempts textiles manufactured out of the handloom or powerloom industry.
Why was the processor treated as part of the exempt activity?
Because it only processed fabric on job work and returned it to the powerloom manufacturers, acting as their extended arm.
This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Readers should refer to the certified copy of the judgment and consult a qualified professional before acting. See our Editorial Policy and Disclaimer.
