Skip to content
Criminal Law · Compensation

Six Years Erased From a Man’s Life: Supreme Court Orders Rs 6 Lakh Compensation to Undertrial Acquitted After Slipshod Investigation

In Arun @ Deepak v. State of U.P., 2026 INSC 1150, the Supreme Court directed the State of Uttar Pradesh to pay Rs 6 lakh to a man who spent six years in jail as an undertrial in a 2019 kidnapping and murder case from Agra, before being acquitted. He had approached the Court for bail; the Court instead ordered the trial completed in three months, and on reading the 100-page acquittal judgment found the investigation appalling: he was not named in the FIR or Section 161 statements, the CCTV footage and call records were never proved with a Section 65B certificate, the charred bones were never identified by DNA, no disclosure statement was recorded under Section 27, and the alleged ransom demand was never reported to police. Calling him a victim of the system, the Court sent its order to the UP DGP and Home Secretary.

Key Takeaways

  • The State must compensate an accused who suffers prolonged incarceration on a case built on surmises; Rs 6 lakh was ordered within one month, with 18% interest on delay.
  • CCTV footage and call detail records are inadmissible without a Section 65B certificate.
  • Recovered remains must be identified, for example by DNA matching with a parent, to prove the corpus delicti.
  • A recovery is not proved under Section 27 unless a disclosure statement is recorded and the accused is shown to have led police to the place.
  • A ransom demand never reported to police, mentioned first in court, is not an extra-judicial confession.
  • Investigating and prosecuting agencies must ensure justice to the accused as well, not just pursue convictions.

Case Details at a Glance

Case titleArun @ Deepak v. State of U.P.
Citation2026 INSC 1150 (Reportable)
Case numberSpecial Leave Petition (Crl.) No. 4859 of 2026
BenchJustice J.B. Pardiwala and Justice K. Vinod Chandran
Authored byJustice K. Vinod Chandran
Date of judgment26 October 2026
FIRFIR No. 367 of 2019, P.S. Achhnera, District Agra; Sections 364, 302 and 201 IPC
CustodySince 14.11.2019 (about six years)
ResultRs 6,00,000 compensation within one month; order sent to UP DGP and Home Secretary

Facts of the Case

A young man went missing in October 2019 while riding home from work in Kiraoli Tehsil, Agra. On the basis of CCTV footage and a co-accused’s confession, the petitioner and one Lalit Kishore were arrested in November 2019. Charred bones, a motorcycle and personal belongings of the missing man were recovered, mostly from the co-accused’s house. The co-accused later died and his mother absconded, leaving the petitioner as the sole accused at trial.

The petitioner sought bail after six years in custody. On 23 March 2026 the Supreme Court directed the trial court to finish the trial in three months. He was acquitted, and the Court called for the Hindi judgment, had it translated, and examined how the case had been investigated.

Timeline of Proceedings

  • 18.10.2019Victim goes missing.
  • 14.11.2019Petitioner taken into custody.
  • 22.01.2020Cognizance on charge-sheet.
  • 23.03.2026Supreme Court directs trial to finish in three months.
  • 2026Petitioner acquitted by trial court.
  • 26.10.2026Supreme Court orders Rs 6 lakh compensation.

Issues Before the Supreme Court

  1. Having been acquitted after six years in custody on a defective investigation, is the petitioner entitled to compensation from the State?

Supreme Court’s Ruling

1. Only six witnesses, no real proof

The prosecution examined only the informant, a doctor, three police officers and an independent witness who said nothing about the crime. The trial court found none of the four circumstances proved: the ransom demand, the confessions, last seen and electronic evidence.

2. Basic investigative failures

  • The ransom demand was never reported to police and was first mentioned in court.
  • Confessions to police are inadmissible; last seen was not proved, as the CCTV footage was unclear.
  • CCTV and CDRs lacked Section 65B certificates; SIM owners were never identified.
  • The bones were never identified; no DNA sample from the father was taken despite the doctor saying it was needed.
  • No Section 27 disclosure was recorded and recoveries were from the co-accused’s house.
  • The motorcycle was not produced, the cremation site was not identified, and the petrol purchase was not proved.

3. A victim of the system

The Court said six years were erased from the man’s life on a concocted story, without even a rudimentary investigation, and the agency took no steps to expedite trial. The State cannot shirk responsibility to protect its citizens, who are presumed innocent.

“Be that as it may, six years have been erased from the life of a man on the strength of a concocted story built on mere surmises and conjectures.” – Supreme Court, 2026 INSC 1150, para 15

Result

The State of Uttar Pradesh must pay Rs 6,00,000 to the petitioner within one month, failing which interest at 18% a year applies. A copy of the order is to go to the UP Director General of Police and Home Secretary, with the Court urging training of officers in investigation.

Analysis and Practical Points

This is a significant addition to the growing line of Supreme Court orders granting compensation to undertrials acquitted after long custody. It also lists the investigative basics that, if skipped, will doom a circumstantial case.

  • Investigators: obtain Section 65B (now Section 63 BSA) certificates for CCTV and CDRs, conduct DNA identification of remains, record disclosure statements, and prove recoveries through the accused’s own pointing out.
  • Undertrials: seek directions for time-bound trial where custody is prolonged; compensation may follow if the case is shown to be baseless.
  • Prosecutors: review evidence quality before trial; examining only formal witnesses invites acquittal.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can an acquitted undertrial get compensation for years in jail?

Yes, in appropriate cases. In 2026 INSC 1150 the Supreme Court ordered Rs 6 lakh to a man who spent six years as an undertrial on a case built on surmises.

Is CCTV footage admissible without a Section 65B certificate?

No. The Court noted that CCTV footage and call records were not proved because they lacked the certificate required under Section 65B of the Evidence Act, now Section 63 of the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam.

Must remains be identified in a murder case?

Yes. The Court criticised the failure to identify recovered bones through DNA, which the doctor said was necessary to establish identity.

Is a ransom demand an extra-judicial confession?

Not when it was never reported to police and is mentioned for the first time in court, as in this case.

This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Readers should refer to the certified copy of the judgment and consult a qualified professional before acting. See our Editorial Policy and Disclaimer.