Seat or Venue? Where an Arbitration Clause Names Two Places, the Exclusive Jurisdiction Clause Decides the Seat: Supreme Court Sets Aside Delhi High Court’s Section 11 Appointment
In Arcis Clean Energy Pvt. Ltd. v. Parshva Innovation, 2026 INSC 1109, the Supreme Court held that where an arbitration clause mentions two places, one as the “precise location” of arbitration and another where proceedings “will be held”, the place cannot automatically be treated as the seat. Reading the clause with the agreement’s exclusive jurisdiction clause in favour of courts at Goa, the Court held that Goa was the juridical seat and Delhi only a venue, so the Delhi High Court had no jurisdiction to appoint an arbitrator under Section 11(6).
Key Takeaways
- Under the BGS SGS SOMA test, affirmed in Arif Azim v. Micromax, a venue becomes the seat only if the clause names one place, the proceedings are anchored there, and there is no contrary indicium.
- Where the arbitration clause itself names two places, the venue is not automatically the seat.
- In such cases the governing law and exclusive jurisdiction clause helps identify the seat.
- Clauses 32.4 (location within Delhi) and 32.5 (proceedings held in Goa) were read harmoniously with Clause 38 (exclusive jurisdiction of Goa courts): Goa is the seat, Delhi a venue.
- Separability of the arbitration agreement does not bar reference to other clauses where the arbitration clause is itself ambiguous.
- Courts of the seat have exclusive supervisory jurisdiction, including under Section 11(6).
Case Details at a Glance
| Case title | Arcis Clean Energy Pvt. Ltd. v. Parshva Innovation |
|---|---|
| Citation | 2026 INSC 1109 (Reportable) |
| Case number | Civil Appeal arising from SLP (Civil) No. 35915 of 2025 |
| Bench | Justice Manoj Misra and Justice Vijay Bishnoi |
| Authored by | Justice Manoj Misra |
| Date of judgment | 12 October 2026 |
| Impugned order | Delhi High Court, 11 November 2025, under Section 11(6) |
| Agreement | Franchise Agreement dated 3 August 2023 |
| Result | Appeal allowed; appointment order set aside |
Facts of the Case
The parties’ franchise agreement provided in Clause 32.4 that the “precise location of the arbitration shall be within Delhi”, and in Clause 32.5 that “the arbitration proceedings will be held in Goa”. Clause 38 stated that the agreement is governed by Indian law and that the parties submit to the exclusive jurisdiction of competent courts in Goa.
The respondent proposed a sole arbitrator by notice dated 25 March 2025; the appellant rejected it on 19 April 2025. The respondent then moved the Delhi High Court under Section 11(6), which appointed an arbitrator and left the venue to be fixed in consultation with the parties. The appellant argued that Goa was the seat and the Delhi High Court lacked jurisdiction.
Issues Before the Supreme Court
- Where an arbitration clause names two places, how is the juridical seat to be identified?
- Did the Delhi High Court have jurisdiction under Section 11(6)?
Seat, venue and exclusive jurisdiction
The Court revisited Indus Mobile (seat is akin to an exclusive jurisdiction clause), Swastik Gases and Brahmani River Pellets (absence of words like “exclusive” is not decisive), and Activitas Management (an exclusive jurisdiction clause read in the context of arbitration can identify the seat). It then applied the three conditions in BGS SGS SOMA as affirmed in Arif Azim: one designated place, proceedings anchored there, and no significant contrary indicia.
Applying the test to two places
Because the arbitration clause mentioned both Delhi and Goa, the first condition failed and the venue could not automatically be treated as the seat. Relying on Mankastu Impex v. Airvisual, the Court held that the intention as to the seat must then be gathered from other clauses and the parties’ conduct. Reading Clauses 32.4 and 32.5 harmoniously so that neither is redundant, together with Clause 38 conferring exclusive jurisdiction on Goa courts, the seat was Goa and Delhi only a venue.
The respondent’s reliance on separability (Sasan Power) and on High Court decisions involving clauses that named a single place was rejected as distinguishable.
Final Decision
Appeal allowed. The juridical seat of arbitration is Goa. The Delhi High Court lacked jurisdiction to entertain the Section 11(6) application, and its order appointing the arbitrator is set aside. The parties may approach the jurisdictional High Court.
Precedents Relied On
| Case | Principle applied |
|---|---|
| BGS SGS SOMA JV v. NHPC Ltd., (2020) 4 SCC 234 | Three-condition test for venue as seat |
| Arif Azim Co. Ltd. v. Micromax Informatics FZE, (2025) 9 SCC 750 | Affirmation of BGS SGS SOMA test |
| Indus Mobile Distribution v. Datawind Innovations, (2017) 7 SCC 678 | Seat confers exclusive jurisdiction |
| Mankastu Impex (P) Ltd. v. Airvisual Ltd., (2020) 5 SCC 399 | Intention as to seat from other clauses and conduct |
| Brahmani River Pellets v. Kamachi Industries, (2020) 5 SCC 462 | Exclusion of other courts |
Analysis and Practical Points
Poorly drafted dispute resolution clauses remain a major source of satellite litigation. Practical lessons from this ruling:
- Drafting: name one seat expressly, use the word “seat”, and keep venue language separate.
- Consistency: align the exclusive jurisdiction clause with the arbitration seat; a mismatch invites a challenge.
- Section 11 filings: before approaching a High Court, check whether the clause names more than one place and whether any jurisdiction clause points elsewhere.
- Respondents: lack of seat jurisdiction can defeat an appointment order even after the arbitrator is named.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the difference between seat and venue in arbitration?
The seat is the juridical home of the arbitration whose courts have supervisory jurisdiction; the venue is merely the physical place where hearings are held.
When can a venue be treated as the seat?
Under the BGS SGS SOMA test, when the clause names only one place, the proceedings are anchored there, and nothing significant indicates otherwise.
What if the clause names two places?
The venue is not automatically the seat; the court looks at other clauses, such as the exclusive jurisdiction clause, and the parties’ conduct.
Why did the Delhi High Court lack jurisdiction here?
Because the seat was Goa, and only the High Court with jurisdiction over the seat could appoint an arbitrator under Section 11(6).
Does separability of the arbitration clause prevent reading other clauses?
Not where the arbitration clause itself is ambiguous by naming two places; the agreement must then be read as a whole.
This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Readers should refer to the certified copy of the judgment and consult a qualified professional before acting. See our Editorial Policy and Disclaimer.
