Skip to content
Arbitration · Interest

Contractual Bar on Interest With the Words “Or Otherwise” Excludes Pre-Reference and Pendente Lite Interest: Supreme Court Upholds Partial Setting Aside of Award in Sharma Enterprises v. NBCC

Section 31(7)(a)Pendente Lite InterestEjusdem GenerisSection 34Post-award InterestNBCC

In MS Sharma Enterprises v. National Building Construction Corporation, 2026 INSC 1135, the Supreme Court held that a contract clause barring interest on balance payments, deposits held up due to disputes, delayed monthly or final payments “or otherwise” operates as a complete contractual prohibition on pre-reference and pendente lite interest. Under Section 31(7)(a) of the Arbitration Act, an arbitrator, being a creature of the contract, cannot override such a clause. The Court, however, confirmed that post-award interest under Section 31(7)(b) is not subject to party autonomy and remains payable.

Key Takeaways

  • Section 31(7)(a) begins with “unless otherwise agreed by the parties”; a contractual bar on interest binds the arbitrator.
  • Ejusdem generis applies only when the preceding words form a genus; items joined disjunctively by “or” must be read independently.
  • “Or otherwise” is a residuary phrase of extension, not limitation, and covers every other circumstance in which interest might be claimed.
  • The phrase stands on the same footing as “any other respect whatsoever” in Sayeed Ahmed and Jaiprakash Associates.
  • A narrow clause limited to delayed payments, as in the ONGC case, would not bar pendente lite interest.
  • Post-award interest under Section 31(7)(b) cannot be contracted out and was rightly preserved.
  • The award on substantive claims for wrongful termination survives.

Case Details at a Glance

Case titleMS Sharma Enterprises v. National Building Construction Corporation
Citation2026 INSC 1135 (Reportable)
Case numberCivil Appeal No. 13782 of 2026 (arising from SLP (C) No. 17072 of 2026)
BenchJustice Aravind Kumar and Justice Vipul M. Pancholi
Authored byJustice Vipul M. Pancholi
Date of judgment15 October 2026
Impugned judgmentDelhi High Court Division Bench, 20 March 2026, in FAO(OS)(COMM) No. 18 of 2026
AwardArbitral award dated 28 July 2016
ResultAppeal dismissed

Facts of the Case

NBCC, which had a contract from IRCON, sub-contracted flooring and cladding works at the Vashi Railway Station-cum-Commercial Complex in Navi Mumbai to the appellant on 11 January 1991 for about Rs 9.51 crore. The work depended on a civil contractor whose delays limited the appellant’s progress. NBCC terminated the contract on 22 September 1992 and encashed the bank guarantees.

After decades of litigation, the Supreme Court appointed an arbitrator in 2011. The 2016 award held the termination wrongful, allowed claims for executed work, extra items, bank guarantee charges, refund of the encashed security and costs, and granted 10 percent interest from 22 September 1992 until payment. On NBCC’s Section 34 petition, the Delhi High Court upheld the substantive claims but set aside pre-reference and pendente lite interest because of Clause 26 of the Special Conditions. The Division Bench affirmed.

Timeline of Proceedings

  • 11.01.1991Sub-contract awarded.
  • 22.09.1992Contract terminated; bank guarantees encashed.
  • 03.08.2011Supreme Court appoints arbitrator.
  • 28.07.2016Arbitral award with 10% interest from 1992.
  • 15.12.2021Supreme Court holds the 1996 Act applies.
  • 19.11.2025Single Judge sets aside pre-award interest.
  • 20.03.2026Division Bench dismisses appeal.
  • 15.10.2026Supreme Court dismisses appeal.

Issues Before the Supreme Court

  1. Does Clause 26, ending with “or otherwise”, bar pre-reference and pendente lite interest?
  2. Can the arbitrator award such interest despite the clause?

Reading Clause 26

Clause 26 barred interest on (i) balance payments or deposits held up due to a dispute, (ii) delays in monthly or final payments, or (iii) “otherwise”. The appellant argued that, applying ejusdem generis and noscitur a sociis, “or otherwise” should be confined to delayed interim bills. The Court disagreed. Following Manraj Enterprises and Larsen & Toubro, items joined by “or” must be read independently, and the preceding words did not form a single narrow genus. Relying on the Constitution Bench in Lilavati Bai v. State of Bombay, “or otherwise” are words of extension; reading them down would make them redundant and rewrite the contract.

Section 31(7): pre-award versus post-award interest

Section 31(7)(a) is expressly subject to the parties’ agreement, so the arbitrator, a creature of the contract, had no power to grant pre-reference or pendente lite interest in the face of Clause 26. Section 31(7)(b), however, mandates interest on the award sum after the award and does not allow parties to contract out of entitlement; the words “unless the award otherwise directs” relate only to the rate. The High Court therefore rightly preserved post-award interest.

Final Decision

Appeal dismissed. The Delhi High Court’s judgments setting aside the award only to the extent of pre-reference and pendente lite interest are upheld. The substantive claims in the appellant’s favour and post-award interest remain.

Precedents Relied On

CasePrinciple applied
Sayeed Ahmed and Co. v. State of U.P., (2009) 12 SCC 26Clause barring interest “in any other respect whatsoever”
Union of India v. Bright Power Projects, (2015) 9 SCC 695Arbitrator bound by contractual bar under Section 31(7)(a)
Lilavati Bai v. State of Bombay“Or otherwise” are words of extension
Manraj EnterprisesDisjunctive phrases read independently
R.P. GargPost-award interest not subject to party autonomy

Analysis and Practical Points

This decision matters for every public sector construction contract carrying a no-interest clause:

  • Contractors: a clause with residuary words like “or otherwise” will likely defeat claims for interest up to the award, even after decades of delay. Price this risk at the bidding stage.
  • Employers and PSUs: broadly drafted clauses will be enforced, but post-award interest remains payable.
  • Arbitrators: check Section 31(7)(a) carefully before awarding pre-award interest where the contract restricts it.
  • Drafting: a narrow clause limited to delayed bills will not bar pendente lite interest.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can an arbitrator award interest if the contract bars it?

Not for the pre-award period. Section 31(7)(a) makes pre-award interest subject to the parties’ agreement, so a contractual bar binds the arbitrator.

Does the phrase or otherwise widen an interest bar?

Yes. The Supreme Court held “or otherwise” is a residuary phrase of extension that covers every other circumstance in which interest may be claimed.

Is post-award interest also barred?

No. Post-award interest under Section 31(7)(b) cannot be contracted out and remains payable.

When does ejusdem generis apply?

Only when general words follow specific words forming a single class or genus; it does not apply to disjunctive, independent phrases.

What happened to the contractor’s other claims?

The awards for wrongful termination, extra items, bank guarantee charges, refund of security and costs were upheld.

This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Readers should refer to the certified copy of the judgment and consult a qualified professional before acting. See our Editorial Policy and Disclaimer.