Public Authority May Cancel Highest Bid Before Conveyance Deed to Maximise Price of Public Property: Supreme Court Orders Fresh E-Auction of Chandigarh Nursing Home Site
In Satinder Pal Singh & Ors. v. Bedi Hospital & Ors., 2026 INSC 1142, the Supreme Court set aside a Punjab and Haryana High Court judgment that had restored a Rs 12.58 crore bid by Bedi Hospital for a nursing home site in Sector 33C, Chandigarh. The adjacent identical site had fetched Rs 18.25 crore on the same day, and the Chandigarh Administration cancelled the bid, refunded the full amount and re-auctioned the site. The Court held that until the conveyance deed is executed there is no enforceable contract, and that recalling an auction to maximise the price of public property is neither illegal nor arbitrary. Because the High Court’s interim order had created a second round of litigation, the Court directed a fresh e-auction within three months.
Key Takeaways
- Under Rule 5 of the Chandigarh Estate Rules, 2007 and the auction terms, the Estate Officer may withdraw a site or reject the highest bid without assigning reasons.
- An agreement to sell under Rule 5(iv) is not an enforceable contract under Section 2(h) of the Contract Act; the contract is concluded only on execution of the conveyance deed.
- Before conveyance, the only limit is the public-law duty not to act arbitrarily.
- Recalling an auction to maximise price of public property is a legitimate reason, as held in SIPCOT v. Contromix.
- CIDCO v. Shishir Realty and Golden Food Products were distinguished: here reasons were given, the full amount was refunded and the bidder was invited to rebid.
- The High Court erred by allowing a fresh auction as an interim measure and then ignoring its consequences in the final judgment.
- The Court ordered a fresh e-auction within three months rather than confirming either bidder.
Case Details at a Glance
| Case title | Satinder Pal Singh & Ors. v. Bedi Hospital & Ors., with appeal by the Chandigarh Administration |
|---|---|
| Citation | 2026 INSC 1142 (Reportable) |
| Case numbers | Civil Appeals arising from SLP Nos. 33791 and 33793 of 2025 |
| Bench | Justice P.S. Narasimha and Justice Alok Aradhe |
| Date of judgment | 16 October 2026 |
| Impugned judgment | Punjab and Haryana High Court, 1 April 2025, in CWP No. 2811 of 2023 |
| Property | Nursing Home Site No. 4, Sector 33C, Chandigarh (744.44 sq. yards) |
| Result | Appeals allowed; fresh e-auction ordered |
Facts of the Case
The Chandigarh Administration auctioned two adjacent nursing home sites of identical size in October 2022 with a reserve price of Rs 6.91 crore each. The appellant won Site No. 3 for Rs 18.25 crore; Bedi Hospital won Site No. 4 for Rs 12.58 crore. Bedi Hospital paid 25 percent, signed an agreement to sell and paid the balance 75 percent by November 2022, but no allotment letter was issued.
On 27 January 2023 the Administration cancelled the bid, citing the Rs 6 crore gap between identical adjacent sites as not reflecting market trends, refunded the entire amount and invited Bedi Hospital to rebid. It cancelled the agreement to sell on 9 February 2023. The High Court, while issuing notice, allowed a fresh auction but barred its finalisation. In the re-auction on 6 September 2023, in which Bedi Hospital did not participate, the appellant bid Rs 18.30 crore. The High Court later quashed the cancellations.
Timeline of Proceedings
- 20.10.2022Site No. 4 bid of Rs 12.58 crore approved.
- 16.11.2022Bedi Hospital pays balance 75 percent.
- 27.01.2023Bid contract cancelled; full refund.
- 10.02.2023High Court permits fresh auction without finalisation.
- 06.09.2023Re-auction: appellant bids Rs 18.30 crore.
- 01.04.2025High Court quashes cancellation.
- 16.10.2026Supreme Court orders fresh e-auction.
Issues Before the Supreme Court
- Could the Administration cancel the highest bid after receipt of full consideration but before the conveyance deed?
- What should follow when a re-auction was held under the High Court’s interim order?
No concluded contract before conveyance
The Court traced the Rules and auction terms: 25 percent on the fall of the hammer, an agreement to sell, payment of 75 percent within 90 days, then an allotment letter and a conveyance deed within 30 days. Explanation I to Rule 5 and Clause VI(5) reserve the Estate Officer’s right to withdraw a site and reject the highest bid without reasons. Execution of the conveyance deed is the culmination of the process; until then the agreement to sell is not an enforceable contract, and the Administration could exercise its power to cancel.
Price maximisation is a valid reason
The only restraint before conveyance is the public-law duty of fairness and non-arbitrariness. Recalling an auction to maximise the price of public property is justified, as the dominant consideration in selling public property is securing the best price. A substantially lower price than an identical adjacent plot fetched on the same day is a relevant consideration. The Administration gave reasons, refunded the whole amount and invited a rebid, so there was no breach of natural justice or transparency.
The problem with the interim order
The Court observed that the High Court should either have dismissed the writ petition at admission or stayed the cancellations. Instead it permitted a fresh auction, opening a second phase of litigation lasting over two years, and then decided the writ petition without considering the rights created by the re-auction, which had fetched about Rs 6 crore more. Bedi Hospital offered before the Supreme Court to match Rs 18.30 crore; the appellant objected. Given the inconclusive situation created by the interim arrangement, a fresh auction was found to best serve justice and public purpose.
Final Decision
Appeals allowed. The High Court judgment dated 1 April 2025 is set aside. The Chandigarh Administration must hold a fresh e-auction of Site No. 4, Sector 33C, under the Chandigarh Estate Rules, 2007, commencing and concluding within three months. No order as to costs.
Precedents Relied On
| Case | Principle applied |
|---|---|
| Chairman and MD, SIPCOT v. Contromix Pvt. Ltd., (1995) 4 SCC 595 | Best price is the dominant consideration in sale of public property |
| CIDCO v. Shishir Realty Pvt. Ltd., (2022) 16 SCC 527 | Distinguished: cancellation of concluded lease without basis |
| Golden Food Products India v. State of U.P., 2026 SCC OnLine SC 24 | Distinguished: lack of transparency and intimation |
Analysis and Practical Points
The ruling balances bidders’ expectations with the State’s duty to get the best price:
- Bidders: paying the full price does not guarantee title; until the conveyance deed is executed, a reasoned cancellation with full refund is likely to be upheld.
- Authorities: cancellations should record reasons, refund promptly and allow rebidding, to avoid arbitrariness.
- Courts: interim orders permitting re-auction must be followed by final orders that address the rights created in the meantime.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can a government cancel the highest bid after full payment?
Yes, if the conveyance deed has not been executed and the decision is reasoned and not arbitrary, for example to secure a better price for public property.
Is an agreement to sell in a public auction a binding contract?
The Court held that the agreement to sell under Rule 5(iv) of the Chandigarh Estate Rules is not an enforceable contract; the contract is concluded only on execution of the conveyance deed.
Why did the Supreme Court order a fresh auction instead of confirming the re-auction?
Because the High Court’s interim order had created conflicting claims, with Bedi Hospital offering to match the re-auction price, and a fresh auction best served justice and public purpose.
Was natural justice followed in cancelling the bid?
Yes. The cancellation letter gave reasons, the full amount was refunded the same day, and the bidder was invited to participate in the re-auction.
What cases did the Court distinguish?
CIDCO v. Shishir Realty and Golden Food Products India v. State of U.P., where the cancellations lacked basis or transparency.
This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Readers should refer to the certified copy of the judgment and consult a qualified professional before acting. See our Editorial Policy and Disclaimer.
