24 Years After the Award, Still No Recovery: Supreme Court Asks Law Commission to Study Execution of Arbitral Awards, Refuses to Supervise Execution
In Royal Construction Company Pvt. Ltd. v. National Projects Construction Corporation, 2026 INSC 1167, a three-judge Bench of the Supreme Court refused the Delhi High Court’s invitation to clarify, in execution, whether amounts NPCC paid in rupees in 2009 should be adjusted against a 2002 arbitral award (denominated in Iraqi Dinars) that the Court had restored in 2015. Its 2023 judgment had only answered a certified question on the conversion date; it cannot be asked to supervise ongoing execution. Those issues are for the executing court. Expressing concern that the award-holder is still litigating 24 years later, the Court requested the Law Commission of India to study the framework for enforcement and execution of arbitral awards, including asset disclosure and dilatory objections.
Key Takeaways
- When the Supreme Court decides an appeal on a certified substantial question of law under Articles 134-A and 133(1)(a), its jurisdiction is confined to that question.
- Once answered, that appellate scope is exhausted; it cannot be enlarged by seeking ‘clarifications’ on unrelated factual issues.
- Questions of adjustment or set-off of amounts paid must be raised before the executing court.
- The efficacy of arbitration depends on the award-holder realising the award within reasonable time, not just on a quick award.
- The Law Commission is requested to study execution of arbitral awards, including asset disclosure, coordinated modes of execution, and repetitive objections.
- A miscellaneous application in the disposed 2019 appeal seeking modification was dismissed.
Case Details at a Glance
| Case title | M/s Royal Construction Company Pvt. Ltd. v. M/s National Projects Construction Corporation |
|---|---|
| Citation | 2026 INSC 1167 (Reportable) |
| Case number | Civil Appeal arising out of SLP (C) No. 14005 of 2026, with M.A. Diary No. 48152 of 2026 in C.A. No. 1991 of 2019 |
| Bench | Justice Vikram Nath, Justice Sandeep Mehta and Justice Aparesh Kumar Singh |
| Authored by | Justice Vikram Nath |
| Date of judgment | 28 October 2026 |
| Award | Arbitral award dated 10.08.2002, amounts in Iraqi Dinars |
| Impugned order | Delhi High Court interim order dated 16.02.2026 in EFA (OS) No. 17 of 2018 |
| Result | Appeal disposed of; MA dismissed; Law Commission requested to study execution |
Facts of the Case
An international arbitration produced an award on 10 August 2002 in favour of Royal Construction against NPCC. After challenges, the Supreme Court restored the award in 2015, stressing minimal interference. In execution, a Single Judge allowed payment in rupees at the 1982 exchange rate; the Division Bench set this aside in 2019 and certified a question on the date for converting the awarded sum to rupees. In October 2023, the Supreme Court held no conversion date needed to be fixed and payment was in foreign currency.
In continuing execution, NPCC said it had already paid the principal in rupees in 2009, which the award-holder withdrew. The High Court, by an interim order of February 2026, gave liberty to seek clarification from the Supreme Court on why this was not raised earlier. NPCC also filed an application to modify the 2023 judgment.
Timeline of Proceedings
- 10.08.2002Arbitral award in Iraqi Dinars.
- 2009Amounts deposited in rupees and withdrawn.
- 24.02.2015Supreme Court restores the award.
- 17.12.2019High Court certifies question on conversion date.
- 10.10.2023Supreme Court answers: no conversion date to be fixed.
- 16.02.2026High Court grants liberty to seek clarification.
- 28.10.2026Supreme Court refuses; requests Law Commission study.
Issues Before the Supreme Court
- Can the Supreme Court, after answering a certified question, clarify factual issues arising in execution?
- Should its 2023 judgment be modified to account for amounts paid in 2009?
Supreme Court’s Ruling
1. Scope of the earlier appeal was limited
In 2023 the Court only answered the certified question on the conversion date. It had no occasion to decide questions about amounts deposited and withdrawn.
2. No supervisory role over execution
The Court cannot be called upon, under the guise of clarification, to supervise continuing execution or decide every issue in it. That is for the executing court and its appellate court. Once the question was answered, the earlier appellate scope was exhausted.
3. Concern over delay
Arbitration began under the 1940 Act; nearly three decades after the 1996 Act, the parties still litigate over enforcement of a 2002 award. Section 36 enforces awards as decrees through the CPC, and cases like this call for closer examination of whether that framework serves arbitration’s objectives.
“The promise of arbitration remains unfulfilled if a party, having traversed the arbitral process, is compelled to embark upon another protracted course of litigation to secure the benefit of the award.” – Supreme Court, 2026 INSC 1167, para 12
Result
The appeal was disposed of and the miscellaneous application dismissed, with liberty to raise adjustment and set-off objections before the executing court. The Law Commission of India is requested to study the enforcement and execution of arbitral awards, including whether domestic and foreign awards need distinct procedures, and a copy is sent to its Chairman.
Analysis and Practical Points
India’s arbitration reforms have focused on speeding up awards and limiting challenges. This judgment shifts attention to the weakest link: execution under the CPC.
- Award-holders: seek early disclosure of the debtor’s assets and use multiple modes of execution together.
- Award-debtors: claims of prior payment must be raised promptly in the executing court, not through clarification applications to the Supreme Court.
- Policy: watch for the Law Commission’s recommendations on a dedicated enforcement regime.
Frequently Asked Questions
How is an arbitral award enforced in India?
Under Section 36 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, an award is enforced in the same manner as a decree of court, using execution procedures under the Code of Civil Procedure.
Why did the Supreme Court refer the issue to the Law Commission?
In 2026 INSC 1167, the Court was concerned that a 2002 award was still unexecuted after 24 years and asked the Law Commission to study practical impediments and recommend reforms.
Can the Supreme Court clarify issues in pending execution proceedings?
Not where its earlier judgment answered only a certified question of law. Execution issues belong to the executing court.
Where should a debtor claim credit for earlier payments?
Before the executing court, which can examine adjustment or set-off in accordance with law.
This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Readers should refer to the certified copy of the judgment and consult a qualified professional before acting. See our Editorial Policy and Disclaimer.
