Skip to content
Insolvency · Section 7 IBC

Information Utility Record of Default Is Sufficient for Section 7 Admission and Profitability Is Irrelevant: Supreme Court Upholds CIRP Against Owners of JW Marriott Bengaluru and Crowne Plaza Pune

Section 7 IBCInformation UtilityNeSL Record of DefaultOmkara ARCIBC Amendment 2026Section 62 Appeal

In Deepak Raheja & Anr. v. Omkara Assets Reconstruction Pvt. Ltd. & Anr., 2026 INSC 1134, the Supreme Court upheld the admission of insolvency proceedings against GSTAAD Hotels Pvt. Ltd., owner of the JW Marriott Hotel, Bengaluru, and Neo Capricorn Plaza Pvt. Ltd., owner of the Crowne Plaza, Pune, on applications by Omkara ARC claiming about Rs 665 crore. The Court laid down a hierarchy of evidence for proving default under Section 7 of the IBC, holding that a record of default from an Information Utility is by itself sufficient and can be displaced only by clear, cogent and compelling material, not bare denial or bookkeeping disputes. It also held that the debtor’s profitability is irrelevant because the trigger under the Code is default, not balance-sheet insolvency.

Key Takeaways

  • Appeals under Section 62 lie only on questions of law; concurrent findings of the NCLT and NCLAT are not disturbed unless perverse.
  • Omkara’s status as financial creditor was settled by the assignment upheld by the Karnataka High Court and the Supreme Court; a fresh challenge is barred by issue estoppel.
  • Section 7 is a summary jurisdiction: default is judged on preponderance of probabilities, not forensic reconciliation of accounts.
  • Default is a static historical event, while the amount outstanding is dynamic.
  • Tier one evidence: an Information Utility record of default, sufficient by itself and carrying a strong presumption.
  • Tier two evidence: loan agreements, statements of account, balance confirmations, acknowledgements and correspondence listed in Part V of Form 1.
  • Profitability is legally irrelevant; the Code is built on timely intervention, not terminal insolvency.
  • The IBC (Amendment) Act, 2026 changing “may” to “shall” in Section 7(5)(a) and adding Explanations I and II only clarifies the existing position.

Case Details at a Glance

Case titleDeepak Raheja and Another v. Omkara Assets Reconstruction Pvt. Ltd. and Another, with connected appeal
Citation2026 INSC 1134 (Reportable)
Case numberCivil Appeal No. 12195 of 2025 with Civil Appeal arising from Diary No. 58001 of 2025
BenchJustice Dipankar Datta and Justice Augustine George Masih
Authored byJustice Augustine George Masih
Date of judgment15 October 2026
Impugned judgmentNCLAT Principal Bench, 19 August 2025, affirming NCLT Mumbai orders of 8 July 2025
Corporate debtorsGSTAAD Hotels Pvt. Ltd. (JW Marriott, Bengaluru) and Neo Capricorn Plaza Pvt. Ltd. (Crowne Plaza, Pune)
ResultAppeals dismissed; CIRP to proceed

Facts of the Case

Under a 2017 loan agreement, Piramal extended Rs 600 crore to the two hotel companies as co-borrowers, followed by facilities under the Emergency Credit Line Guarantee Scheme. A cash management agreement with the hotel operator split daily revenue between expenses and debt service, and a debt service reserve account was required. In December 2022 the lenders assigned the facilities to Omkara ARC under clauses permitting unilateral assignment. Records of default were filed with NeSL, the Information Utility, in February 2023, the loans were recalled, and Section 7 applications were filed in March 2023 with 15 November 2022 as the date of default.

The debtors’ writ petition challenging the assignment was dismissed by the Karnataka High Court, which recorded that they had not disputed that payments were overdue; the Supreme Court dismissed their SLP in August 2025. The NCLT admitted the applications in January 2024; the NCLAT remanded in January 2025; the NCLT re-admitted them on 8 July 2025 and the NCLAT affirmed on 19 August 2025.

Timeline of Proceedings

  • 26.12.2017Loan agreement for Rs 600 crore.
  • 27.12.2022Assignment to Omkara ARC.
  • 09.02.2023Records of default filed with NeSL.
  • 09.03.2023Section 7 applications filed.
  • 08.01.2025NCLAT remands first admission orders.
  • 08.07.2025NCLT re-admits both applications.
  • 19.08.2025NCLAT dismisses appeals.
  • 15.10.2026Supreme Court dismisses appeals.

Issues Before the Supreme Court

  1. What is the scope of a Section 62 appeal against concurrent findings?
  2. Can the assignment to the ARC be reopened?
  3. What evidence suffices to prove default under Section 7, and what weight does an Information Utility record carry?
  4. Is the profitability of the debtor relevant to admission?

A hierarchy of evidence for default

The Court held that the Adjudicating Authority’s role at admission is confined to ascertaining debt and default on documentary material, judged on preponderance of probabilities. At the first tier stands an Information Utility record of default, authenticated through the debtor’s own participation or acquiescence; it is sufficient on its own and can be displaced only by clear, cogent, credible and compelling material. At the second tier are documents listed in Part V of Form 1, such as loan agreements, statements of account, balance confirmations and acknowledgements, which together can establish default.

Why profitability does not matter

The appellants relied on the hotels’ profitability and cash-management arrangements. The Court held that profitability is neither legally relevant nor economically probative of the capacity to service debt. The Code adopts default under Section 3(12), not commercial or balance-sheet insolvency, as the trigger, because it is designed for timely intervention.

The 2026 amendment to Section 7(5)

The IBC (Amendment) Act, 2026, notified in April 2026, substituted “shall” for “may” in Section 7(5)(a), added Explanation I (no other ground to reject once the conditions are met) and Explanation II (an IU record of default furnished by a financial institution is sufficient). The Court held these are clarificatory and its reasoning would have been the same without them. It noted that Information Utilities are an Indian innovation and that, nearly ten years on, the transitional period has passed.

A note on fabricated case citations

Before parting, the Court recorded that the respondents had objected to a compilation of judgments filed for the appellants, alleging it contained non-existent judgments. The Advocate-on-Record sought to blame the clients, and senior counsel took responsibility and apologised. The Court had proposed exemplary costs but, on learning of the first appellant’s death, made no order as to costs.

Final Decision

Appeals dismissed. The NCLT orders of 8 July 2025 admitting CP (IB) Nos. 291 and 290 of 2023, as affirmed by the NCLAT on 19 August 2025, are upheld, and the CIRP against both corporate debtors will proceed. No order as to costs; under Order XXII Rule 6 CPC, the appeal did not abate on the first appellant’s death.

Analysis and Practical Points

The ruling is likely to be cited in almost every contested Section 7 admission:

  • Financial creditors: file a properly authenticated IU record of default; it shifts the burden decisively.
  • Corporate debtors: disputes about reconciliation, cash-management mechanics or profitability will not defeat admission; only compelling evidence that there was no default will.
  • Assignments to ARCs: once upheld in other proceedings, they cannot be relitigated before the NCLT.
  • Practitioners: the Court’s remarks on the compilation are a reminder to verify every authority cited.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is an Information Utility record of default enough to admit a Section 7 application?

Yes. The Supreme Court held it is sufficient by itself and creates a strong presumption that can be displaced only by clear, cogent and compelling material.

Does the profitability of a company prevent insolvency?

No. The trigger under the IBC is default, not balance-sheet insolvency, so profitability is irrelevant at the admission stage.

What did the IBC Amendment Act 2026 change in Section 7?

It made admission mandatory once conditions are met by replacing “may” with “shall”, and added explanations barring other grounds of rejection and declaring IU records sufficient. The Court held these changes are clarificatory.

Can a corporate debtor challenge the ARC’s assignment again before the NCLT?

Not where the assignment has already been upheld by the High Court and Supreme Court; issue estoppel bars it.

What is the scope of a Section 62 appeal?

Only questions of law. Concurrent findings of fact are not disturbed unless perverse, based on no evidence or on an erroneous legal standard.

This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Readers should refer to the certified copy of the judgment and consult a qualified professional before acting. See our Editorial Policy and Disclaimer.