Yes Bank AT-1 Bonds: Supreme Court Holds Administrator Had No Power to Write Down Bonds After Reconstruction Scheme Dropped the Clause; Bombay High Court Verdict Upheld
In Yes Bank Limited & Anr. v. Axis Trustee Services Limited & Ors., 2026 INSC 1132, the Supreme Court dismissed appeals filed by Yes Bank, the Reserve Bank of India and the Union of India and upheld the Bombay High Court’s 2023 ruling that set aside the write-down of Yes Bank’s Basel III Additional Tier 1 (AT-1) bonds. In what the Court described as possibly its first interpretation of the RBI’s Master Circular on Basel III Capital Regulations, it held that the Central Government had consciously dropped the write-down clause from the final Yes Bank Reconstruction Scheme, 2020, and that only the bank (on the CET1 trigger) or the RBI (on the point of non-viability trigger) could write down the bonds, not an Administrator appointed under Section 36ACA of the Banking Regulation Act.
Key Takeaways
- The validity of the 14 March 2020 write-down had to be tested as on that date; Yes Bank’s later recovery and SBI’s profitable exit were irrelevant.
- The Draft Scheme of 6 March 2020 provided for writing down AT-1 bonds, but the final Reconstruction Scheme notified on 13 March 2020 consciously dropped that clause.
- A general savings clause in the Scheme could not confer the specific power to write down the bonds.
- Under the Information Memoranda and the Master Circular, the CET1 trigger is the bank’s option, while the PONV trigger is exercisable at the option of the RBI.
- An Administrator under Section 36ACA only steps into the shoes of the Board and cannot exercise the RBI’s regulatory power; the write-down was illegal and void.
- Coupon payments on the bonds must be made as per the Information Memoranda.
- The Court criticised the RBI, the Administrator and Yes Bank, and noted that high-risk AT-1 bonds were sold directly to individual investors in breach of the Master Circular.
Case Details at a Glance
| Case title | Yes Bank Limited & Anr. v. Axis Trustee Services Limited & Ors., with connected appeals by Yes Bank, RBI and Union of India |
|---|---|
| Citation | 2026 INSC 1132 (Reportable) |
| Case numbers | Civil Appeal No. 3182 of 2025 with Civil Appeal Nos. 3183–3212 of 2025 |
| Bench | Justice Dipankar Datta and Justice Augustine George Masih |
| Authored by | Justice Dipankar Datta |
| Date of judgment | 15 October 2026 |
| Impugned judgment | Bombay High Court, 20 January 2023 |
| Bonds | AT-1 bonds of Rs 3,000 crore (2016) and Rs 5,415 crore (2017); trustee Axis Trustee Services Ltd. |
| Result | Appeals dismissed; High Court judgment upheld |
Facts of the Case
Yes Bank issued Basel III compliant AT-1 bonds in the form of non-convertible debentures for Rs 3,000 crore on 23 December 2016 and Rs 5,415 crore on 18 October 2017, with Axis Trustee as trustee. As its finances deteriorated, the Central Government imposed a moratorium on 5 March 2020 and the RBI superseded the board and appointed an Administrator under Section 36ACA. A Draft Reconstruction Scheme published on 6 March 2020 contemplated writing down the AT-1 bonds. Axis Trustee objected and filed a writ petition, and an RBI note recorded that most investors had agreed to conversion into equity instead.
The final Yes Bank Limited Reconstruction Scheme, 2020, notified on 13 March 2020, contained no clause on the bonds. The next day the Administrator wrote the bonds down and informed BSE and NSE. The Bombay High Court allowed the bondholders’ writ petitions and set the write-down aside.
Timeline of Proceedings
- 23.12.2016Rs 3,000 crore AT-1 bonds issued.
- 18.10.2017Rs 5,415 crore AT-1 bonds issued.
- 05.03.2020Moratorium under Section 45 BR Act; Administrator appointed under Section 36ACA.
- 06.03.2020Draft Reconstruction Scheme with write-down clause published.
- 13.03.2020Final Reconstruction Scheme notified without the clause.
- 14.03.2020Administrator writes down AT-1 bonds.
- 20.01.2023Bombay High Court quashes the write-down.
- 15.10.2026Supreme Court dismisses appeals.
Issues Before the Supreme Court
- Do developments after the write-down make a decision on merits unnecessary?
- Could the Administrator write down the AT-1 bonds when the Reconstruction Scheme did not provide for it?
- Was the write-down consistent with the Master Circular and the Information Memoranda?
Issue A: Validity is tested as on the date of action
The respondents pointed to Yes Bank’s recovery and SBI’s sale of its stake at a profit, while the appellants warned of a financial avalanche. The Court declined to decide on either basis. Relying on Nawabkhan Abbaskhan v. State of Gujarat, it held that an administrative action must be tested as it stood on the date it was taken, here 14 March 2020, under the law then in force.
Issue B: The Reconstruction Scheme consciously left the bonds untouched
The Court traced the deliberative process between the draft and final Schemes, including objections from bondholders and the RBI note recording agreement to conversion. The proposal to write down or convert the bonds was abandoned when the Central Government finalised the Scheme. Allowing the Administrator to write the bonds down the day after notification would make the Scheme a “half-baked pie” and expose the Government to criticism of acting clandestinely. Clause 6 of the Scheme, a general savings clause, could not confer a specific power not otherwise vested.
Issue C: Only the bank or the RBI could trigger the write-down
Reading the Information Memoranda with Annex 16 of the Master Circular, the Court identified two triggers. At the pre-specified CET1 trigger, the bank may choose to write off, write down or convert. At the point of non-viability (PONV), the instruments must be written off or converted at the option of the RBI, which also determines the amount. Yes Bank never exercised the first; the RBI did not exercise the second and had in fact dropped the clause. An Administrator under Section 36ACA acts only as a substitute for the board and must stay within statutory limits, so his write-down was wholly illegal and void.
The question is not whether the AT-1 Bonds could have been or ought to have been written down. The question is the manner in which it was done.– Supreme Court, 2026 INSC 1132 (paraphrased)
Observations on the RBI, the Administrator and Yes Bank
The Court described the handling of the bonds by the “triumvirate” of the RBI, the Administrator and Yes Bank as questionable, remarked that the RBI had been a mere bystander while the bank’s CET1 ratio fell to 0.6 percent, and noted that AT-1 bonds, meant for institutional investors under the Master Circular, had been offered directly to individual investors. SEBI had penalised a wealth management firm and the bank’s then managing director for facilitating such sales, but direct sales by the bank fell outside SEBI’s regulations.
Final Decision
Appeals dismissed. The Bombay High Court judgment setting aside the write-down is upheld and interim orders are vacated. Annual coupon payments must be made as per the Information Memoranda. Parties bear their own costs, and pending proceedings are to be decided uninfluenced by these observations.
Precedents Relied On
| Case | Principle applied |
|---|---|
| Nawabkhan Abbaskhan v. State of Gujarat, (1974) 2 SCC 121 | Administrative action tested on the facts and law as on its date |
| Yash Deep Trexim Pvt. Ltd. v. Namokar Vinimay Pvt. Ltd. | Noted on deciding questions left open |
Analysis and Practical Points
The ruling restores the claims of AT-1 bondholders and sets important limits on bank resolution by administrators:
- Regulators: loss absorption at PONV is an RBI decision that must follow the Master Circular; it cannot be delegated by implication to an administrator.
- Drafting schemes: what is left out of a notified scheme after public consultation will be read as a deliberate choice.
- Investors and distributors: the Court’s remarks on mis-selling high-risk instruments to retail investors strengthen claims about disclosure and suitability.
- Banks: AT-1 documentation and trigger mechanics will be read strictly in favour of investors where the prescribed route is not followed.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why did the Supreme Court hold the Yes Bank AT-1 write-down illegal?
Because the final Reconstruction Scheme consciously dropped the write-down clause, and under the Master Circular only the bank (on the CET1 trigger) or the RBI (on the PONV trigger) could write down the bonds, not the Administrator.
What is the PONV trigger?
The point of non-viability trigger requires non-equity capital instruments to be written off or converted into equity at the option of the RBI when the bank is approaching non-viability.
Does the later recovery of Yes Bank matter?
No. The Court held that the write-down had to be judged as on 14 March 2020, the date it was made.
Will AT-1 bondholders receive coupon payments?
The Court directed that annual coupon payments remain unaffected and must be made in terms of the Information Memoranda.
Can an Administrator under Section 36ACA exercise RBI’s powers?
No. The Administrator only performs the functions of the superseded board and cannot assume the RBI’s regulatory role.
This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Readers should refer to the certified copy of the judgment and consult a qualified professional before acting. See our Editorial Policy and Disclaimer.
