Skip to content
Transfer of Property Act, 1882

Section 46: Transfer for Consideration by Persons Having Distinct Interests

Section 46 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 provides the default rule for dividing the consideration received when persons holding distinct interests in immovable property transfer it together. If the interests have equal value, the transferors share the consideration equally. If the values differ, the consideration is divided in proportion to those values. The parties may agree otherwise by contract.

Section 46 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 - Full text

46. Transfer for consideration by persons having distinct interests. Where immovable property is transferred for consideration by persons having distinct interests therein, the transferors are, in the absence of a contract to the contrary, entitled to share in the consideration equally, where their interests in the property were of equal value, and, where such interests were of unequal value, proportionately to the value of their respective interests.

Illustrations

(a) A, owning a moiety, and B and C, each a quarter share, of mauza Sultanpur, exchange an eighth share of that mauza for a quarter share of mauza Lalpura. There being no agreement to the contrary, A is entitled to an eighth share in Lalpura, and B and C each to a sixteenth share in that mauza.

(b) A, being entitled to a life-interest in mauza Atrali and B and C, to the reversion, sell the mauza for Rs. 1,000. A's life-interest is ascertained to be worth Rs. 600, the reversion Rs. 400. A is entitled to receive Rs. 600 out of the purchase-money. B and C to receive Rs. 400.

Meaning of Section 46

The expression distinct interests means that the transferors have identifiable, potentially different rights or stakes in the same immovable property. These may be fractional ownership shares or interests of different kinds, such as a life interest and a reversion. Consideration is the value received in exchange for the transfer; it need not always be cash, as illustration (a) demonstrates through an exchange of land.

Rules for dividing the consideration

Equal value of interests

Where the interests transferred are of equal value, each transferor receives an equal portion of the consideration, unless the parties have agreed to a different division.

Unequal value of interests

Where the interests are unequal in value, each transferor is entitled to the proportion corresponding to the value of that person's interest. For example, where two interests are worth Rs. 3 lakh and Rs. 2 lakh and the property is sold for Rs. 10 lakh, the default allocation is Rs. 6 lakh and Rs. 4 lakh respectively.

Contract to the contrary

The words in the absence of a contract to the contrary make this a default rule. A valid agreement governing the division of consideration may displace the statutory allocation. The existence and terms of such an agreement should be verified from the transaction documents.

Explanation of the two statutory illustrations

Illustration (a): Exchange involving fractional shares

A holds one-half (a moiety) of mauza Sultanpur, while B and C each hold one-quarter. They collectively exchange an eighth share in Sultanpur for a quarter share in Lalpura. Their relative interests are 2:1:1, so A receives one-eighth of Lalpura and B and C each receive one-sixteenth. The fractions in the illustration refer to their shares in Lalpura, not the whole of Sultanpur.

Illustration (b): Life interest and reversion

A has a life interest, namely an interest lasting for A's lifetime; B and C have the reversion, the interest taking effect after the life interest ends. The property is sold for Rs. 1,000. As A's interest is valued at Rs. 600 and the reversion at Rs. 400, the proceeds are allocated Rs. 600 to A and Rs. 400 collectively to B and C. The illustration does not itself specify how B and C divide their collective Rs. 400.

Practical application

For a joint sale or exchange, identify each transferor's legally transferable interest, determine its value at the relevant time, check for any agreement altering the default allocation and record the agreed distribution clearly. The section addresses the entitlement to consideration among transferors; it does not independently establish title, dispense with registration requirements, or decide tax treatment.

Section 44 concerns a transfer by one co-owner. Section 45 concerns acquisition by two or more persons who contribute the purchase consideration; Section 46, by contrast, governs distribution of consideration among persons transferring their distinct interests. Section 47 addresses a transfer by co-owners of a share in common property.

For the statutory Act and amendments, consult the Government of India's India Code - Transfer of Property Act, 1882.

Frequently asked questions

Must all joint sellers receive the same amount?

No. Equal distribution is the default only where their interests have equal value and no contrary contract applies.

Can a life tenant and reversioner divide sale proceeds differently?

Yes, a valid contract may provide a different allocation. Without one, Section 46 looks to the respective values of their interests.

Is Section 46 the same as Section 45?

No. Section 45 addresses interests of joint purchasers, while Section 46 addresses division of consideration among joint transferors with distinct interests.