Skip to content
Labour Law · Working Journalists

Journalists’ Wage Claims: Supreme Court Holds Section 17(2) Reference Power Cannot Be Delegated, but Uses Article 142 to Save Pending References

In Sudhir v. Dainik Bhaskar Group, 2026 INSC 834, the Supreme Court held that the power of a State Government under Section 17(2) of the Working Journalists Act, 1955 to refer disputes over amounts due to newspaper employees to a Labour Court could not be delegated to labour commissioners. Section 17(1) expressly allows the State to authorise another authority for recovery certificates; Section 17(2) contains no such power. Maharashtra’s 2016 notification was therefore invalid. Recognising that hundreds of Majithia wage board claims depended on such references and that the Act has since been repealed by the OSH Code, the Court invoked Article 142 to save pending proceedings through fresh State satisfaction.

Key Takeaways

  • Only the State Government can refer a question of amount due under Section 17(2) of the Working Journalists Act; it cannot delegate that power.
  • Express delegation in Section 17(1) and its absence in Section 17(2) is decisive.
  • The Allahabad High Court’s contrary view in Amar Ujala was disapproved; the Punjab and Haryana High Court’s Jagran Prakashan view was affirmed.
  • Principles akin to ratification were applied to save references made in good faith under the notification.
  • Maharashtra must re-examine each reference within six months; proceedings resume from where they stood.
  • Employers cannot reopen concluded proceedings where the reference was never challenged.

Case Details at a Glance

Case titleSudhir and Others v. Head of Human Resource, Dainik Bhaskar Group (D.B. Corp. Ltd.) and Others (with connected appeals)
Citation2026 INSC 834 (Reportable)
Case numberCivil Appeals arising out of SLP (C) Nos. 2824-2839 of 2023, 4964 of 2023, 17104-17119 of 2023 and 6643 of 2025
BenchJustice Dipankar Datta and Justice Sheel Nagu
Authored byJustice Dipankar Datta
Date of judgment11 August 2026
Impugned orderBombay High Court judgments dated 22.12.2022 (Aurangabad Bench) and 17.11.2022 (Nagpur Bench)
Law involvedSection 17, Working Journalists and Other Newspaper Employees (Conditions of Service) and Miscellaneous Provisions Act, 1955; delegation of statutory power; Article 142
Counsel who arguedLearned counsel for the appellant employees, Brihanmumbai Union of Journalists and All India Reporter Karmachari Sangh; Learned counsel for Dainik Bhaskar Group (D.B. Corp. Ltd.) and All India Reporter Pvt. Ltd.; Learned counsel for the State of Maharashtra; Names of counsel are not recorded in the judgment
ResultAppeals disposed of; delegation held invalid but pending references saved; Maharashtra to record fresh satisfaction within six months

Facts of the Case

By a notification of 11 May 2016, Maharashtra delegated its Section 17(2) reference power to Additional and Deputy Commissioners of Labour. Many references on wage dues were made, including claims by employees of Dainik Bhaskar and All India Reporter.

The Nagpur Bench of the Bombay High Court upheld AIR’s objection that the delegation was invalid and set aside a reference; following it, the Aurangabad Bench set aside a Labour Court award in favour of Dainik Bhaskar employees. Employees and journalists’ unions appealed. The Act was repealed by the OSH Code with effect from 21 November 2025.

Timeline of Proceedings

  • 11.05.2016Maharashtra notification delegating Section 17(2) power.
  • 04.01.2019Labour Court, Aurangabad award.
  • 17.11.2022Nagpur Bench holds delegation invalid.
  • 22.12.2022Aurangabad Bench sets aside awards.
  • 21.11.2025Working Journalists Act repealed by OSH Code.
  • 11.08.2026Supreme Court decision.

Issues Before the Supreme Court

  1. Could the State Government delegate its power under Section 17(2) to refer disputes to the Labour Court?
  2. What relief should follow for references already made?

Arguments and Counsel

Employees and unions

The reference power is administrative and can be exercised through officers; invalidating references would defeat long-pending wage claims.

Employers

Section 17(2) confers the power on the State Government alone, unlike Section 17(1); references by delegates are without jurisdiction.

Supreme Court’s Ruling

1. No power to delegate

Express power of delegation is given in Section 17(1) but not Section 17(2); the State fell into grave error in delegating the reference power.

2. Precedents

Amar Ujala (Allahabad) disapproved; Jagran Prakashan (Punjab and Haryana) and the impugned judgments affirmed.

3. Ratification-like solution

Marathwada University was distinguished since the delegates acted under a then-valid notification; what matters is whether a dispute existed that the State could refer.

4. Article 142 directions

The State must record fresh satisfaction in each case within six months; proceedings stay meanwhile and then continue from the stage reached.

Result

The High Court’s view that the reference power under Section 17(2) could not be delegated was affirmed, but pending Labour Court proceedings will not terminate. Under Article 142, the Government of Maharashtra must revisit every reference within six months and, where satisfied, make a fresh reference; proceedings continue from the stage reached. Where it is not satisfied, employees may pursue other recovery remedies with limitation running from the communication of that decision.

Analysis and Practical Points

The judgment balances strict statutory interpretation with practical justice for journalists who have waited years for wage board dues. Employers win the legal point but cannot use it to wipe out pending claims. Similar delegation issues in other States may now be resolved along these lines.

  • Journalists and unions: Track the State’s fresh satisfaction in each case and apply for restoration of disposed writ petitions where references are confirmed.
  • Newspaper employers: Concluded proceedings cannot be reopened where the reference was not challenged in further proceedings.
  • State Government: Complete the review of all references within six months and communicate decisions to parties and Labour Courts.

Frequently Asked Questions

What did the Supreme Court decide in Sudhir v Dainik Bhaskar?

In 2026 INSC 834 it held that Section 17(2) reference power under the Working Journalists Act cannot be delegated, but saved pending references through fresh State satisfaction.

What happens to pending Labour Court cases?

They stay until the State records fresh satisfaction within six months, then continue from the stage reached.

What if the State refuses to refer?

The employee may pursue other recovery remedies, with limitation running from receipt of the State’s decision.

This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Readers should refer to the certified copy of the judgment and consult a qualified professional before acting. See our Editorial Policy and Disclaimer.