Skip to content
Labour Law · Industrial Disputes Act

Nine-Judge Bench on the Meaning of “Industry” Under Section 2(j) of the Industrial Disputes Act: Bangalore Water Supply Continues to Govern Pending Cases

In State of U.P. v. Jai Bir Singh, 2026 INSC 897, a nine-Judge Bench of the Supreme Court answered the long-pending reference on whether the 1978 seven-Judge decision in Bangalore Water Supply on the meaning of “industry” under Section 2(j) of the Industrial Disputes Act needed reconsideration. The lead case asked whether U.P.’s Social Forestry Department is an industry. By the time of decision, the ID Act had been replaced by the Industrial Relations Code, 2020. Chief Justice Surya Kant, for four Judges, offered a refined Triple Test but held that pending cases should still be decided under Bangalore Water Supply. Five Judges in three separate opinions held that Bangalore Water Supply correctly interprets Section 2(j). The practical result is that the familiar Triple Test governs all pending ID Act disputes.

Key Takeaways

  • All pending disputes under the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 will be decided by applying the Triple Test and guidelines in Bangalore Water Supply (1978).
  • Concluded judgments, awards and settlements are not reopened.
  • The Industrial Relations Code, 2020 (Section 2(p)) is to be interpreted on its own text; Bangalore Water Supply is not its sheet anchor.
  • Five Judges (Nagarathna, Narasimha, Datta, Bhuyan and Bagchi, JJ.) held that Bangalore Water Supply needs no reconsideration.
  • The plurality (Surya Kant CJI and three Judges) proposed a refined Triple Test requiring a “discernible commercial character” analogous to trade or business, but only as its considered opinion.
  • Welfare activities of the State and its instrumentalities are not excluded merely because of their welfare character; only genuine sovereign functions may be exempt.

Case Details at a Glance

Case titleState of Uttar Pradesh v. Jai Bir Singh (with about 60 connected civil appeals and SLPs)
Citation2026 INSC 897 (Reportable)
Case numberCivil Appeal No. 897 of 2002 and connected matters
BenchChief Justice Surya Kant, Justice B.V. Nagarathna, Justice P.S. Narasimha, Justice Dipankar Datta, Justice Ujjal Bhuyan, Justice Satish Chandra Sharma, Justice Joymalya Bagchi, Justice Alok Aradhe and Justice Vipul M. Pancholi
Authored bySurya Kant, CJI (for himself, Satish Chandra Sharma, Alok Aradhe and Vipul M. Pancholi, JJ.); separate opinions by B.V. Nagarathna, J., P.S. Narasimha, J., Dipankar Datta, J. (for himself and Ujjal Bhuyan, J.) and Joymalya Bagchi, J.
Date of judgment20 August 2026
Impugned orderReference by a seven-Judge Bench in State of U.P. v. Jai Bir Singh to reconsider Bangalore Water Supply and Sewerage Board v. A. Rajappa (1978)
Law involvedSection 2(j), Industrial Disputes Act, 1947; Industrial Disputes (Amendment) Act, 1982 (not notified); Section 2(p), Industrial Relations Code, 2020; Section 6, General Clauses Act, 1897
Counsel who arguedMr. R. Venkataramani, Attorney General for India; Mr. K.M. Nataraj, ASG; Mr. Shadan Farasat and Mr. Sridhar Potaraju, Additional Advocates General; Mr. Shekhar Naphade and Mr. Sanjay Hegde, Senior Advocates, for the Union, States and other entities; Mr. Jaideep Gupta, Senior Advocate, with Mr. Saket Sikri, Mr. Anand Verma and Mr. Krishna Kumar for other appellants; Mr. Alok Sangwan for the State of Haryana; Ms. Indira Jaising, Mr. Bharat Sangal, Mr. C.U. Singh, Mr. Vijay Hansaria, Mr. Gopal Sankaranarayanan, Mr. P.V. Surendranath, Ms. Jayna Kothari and Mr. K.S. Chauhan, Senior Advocates, for workmen and intervenors; Mr. Jamshed P. Cama and Mr. Parthasarathi Sengupta, Senior Advocates, Amici Curiae
ResultReference answered; pending cases under the ID Act to be decided per Bangalore Water Supply; IR Code to be interpreted independently

Facts of the Case

The lead appeal concerned whether the Social Forestry Department of Uttar Pradesh, created as an environmental welfare initiative, is an “industry” under Section 2(j), so that workers engaged by it could raise industrial disputes. In Bangalore Water Supply (1978), a seven-Judge Bench had adopted the broad Triple Test of systematic activity, employer-employee cooperation and production or distribution of goods or services, irrespective of profit motive, subject to a narrow sovereign functions exception.

In 2005 a five-Judge Bench in Jai Bir Singh doubted that test and referred it to a larger Bench; a seven-Judge Bench in 2017 sent it to nine Judges. The Industrial Disputes (Amendment) Act, 1982, which narrowed the definition, was never notified. The Industrial Relations Code, 2020, with a new definition of industry, has since come into force, but these matters arose under the ID Act.

Timeline of Proceedings

  • 1978Bangalore Water Supply lays down the Triple Test (seven Judges).
  • 1982Amendment narrowing the definition enacted but never notified.
  • 2005Five-Judge Bench in Jai Bir Singh doubts the test and refers.
  • 2017Seven-Judge Bench refers to nine Judges.
  • 2020Industrial Relations Code enacted, later brought into force.
  • 16.02.2026Three-Judge Bench frames questions for the nine-Judge Bench.
  • 20.08.2026Nine-Judge Bench answers the reference.

Issues Before the Supreme Court

  1. Was the reference to the nine-Judge Bench validly made?
  2. Does Bangalore Water Supply correctly interpret “industry” in Section 2(j), and what is the impact of the 1982 Amendment and the IR Code?
  3. Are welfare activities and schemes of Government departments industrial activities, and what are sovereign functions?

Arguments and Counsel

Union, States and appellants (Attorney General R. Venkataramani and others)

Section 2(j) should be reinterpreted in light of modern constitutional realities; Bangalore Water Supply went beyond the text and amounted to judicial rewriting; the decisive factor should be whether the activity has commercial objectives akin to trade or business.

Workmen and intervenors (Ms. Indira Jaising and others)

The reference was unnecessary; the seven-Judge majority binds; the ID Act is beneficial legislation rightly given an expansive reading, protecting job security and remedies for workmen.

Amici Curiae (Mr. Jamshed P. Cama and Mr. Parthasarathi Sengupta)

Mr. Cama argued the Triple Test is too wide and an industry must have commercial underpinnings; Mr. Sengupta took a substantially different position supporting the settled approach.

Supreme Court’s Ruling

1. Plurality (Surya Kant CJI, Sharma, Aradhe and Pancholi, JJ.)

The reference was valid. The Triple Test could have been better articulated, requiring goods or services with a discernible commercial character analogous to trade or business. But this reformulation is only an opinion: pending cases are to be decided under Bangalore Water Supply, concluded cases are not reopened, and Bangalore Water Supply is not the sheet anchor for the IR Code.

2. Nagarathna, J.

Bangalore Water Supply lays down the correct law; the 1982 Amendment and the IR Code have no impact on interpreting Section 2(j); welfare activities of Government are not excluded per se and the dominant nature of the activity is relevant.

3. Narasimha, J.

The reference was valid, but an authoritative reinterpretation is now unnecessary after repeal. Creating a third set of principles for pending cases would push long-pending disputes to civil courts; pending cases should be decided under Bangalore Water Supply.

4. Datta, J. (with Bhuyan, J.)

The reference was not necessary and disturbs a quietus of nearly half a century; Bangalore Water Supply does not require reconsideration and pending references must be concluded under it.

5. Bagchi, J.

Sovereignty is confined to core inalienable functions; welfare activities, charities, temples and educational institutions with organised employer-employee relations satisfy the Triple Test; under stare decisis the ratio should be retained for legacy matters.

“Institutional credibility lies in respecting finality, not in perpetuating doubt.” – Supreme Court, 2026 INSC 897, Datta, J., para 76

Result

All opinions agree that pending matters under the Industrial Disputes Act are to be decided in accordance with the test in Bangalore Water Supply, that concluded matters are not reopened, and that the Industrial Relations Code, 2020 must be interpreted on its own terms. The plurality of four Judges offered a refined, hypothetical reformulation of the Triple Test as its opinion only; five Judges held that Bangalore Water Supply correctly states the law under Section 2(j) and needs no reconsideration. The matters are to be placed before appropriate Benches.

Analysis and Practical Points

Despite the differing reasoning, the outcome is clear for practitioners: every pending industrial dispute under the ID Act continues to be governed by the Bangalore Water Supply Triple Test, including its narrow sovereign functions exception and dominant nature test. Hospitals, educational institutions, clubs, research bodies and Government welfare departments with organised employer-employee relations remain within “industry” for legacy disputes. For new disputes under the IR Code, the field is open, and the plurality’s reformulation and the separate opinions will be cited on both sides.

  • Workmen and unions: Pending ID Act claims against Government welfare departments, hospitals or educational institutions continue to be assessed under the Bangalore Water Supply test.
  • Employers and Government departments: Arguments that welfare or non-profit activities fall outside “industry” will not succeed in pending ID Act cases unless they fall within genuine sovereign functions.
  • Advisers on the IR Code: Interpret Section 2(p) of the IR Code on its own text; Bangalore Water Supply is not to be treated as controlling it.

Frequently Asked Questions

Was Bangalore Water Supply overruled?

No. In 2026 INSC 897 five Judges held it needs no reconsideration, and the plurality of four directed that pending cases still be decided under it.

Which test applies to pending industrial disputes?

The Triple Test and guidelines laid down in Bangalore Water Supply (1978).

Does the ruling apply to the Industrial Relations Code, 2020?

No. The Code’s definition of industry is to be interpreted independently; Bangalore Water Supply is not its sheet anchor.

What did the plurality propose?

A refined Triple Test requiring goods or services of a discernible commercial character analogous to trade or business, offered as its considered opinion without displacing the governing position for pending cases.

Who sat on the Bench?

Surya Kant CJI with Justices B.V. Nagarathna, P.S. Narasimha, Dipankar Datta, Ujjal Bhuyan, Satish Chandra Sharma, Joymalya Bagchi, Alok Aradhe and Vipul M. Pancholi.

This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Readers should refer to the certified copy of the judgment and consult a qualified professional before acting. See our Editorial Policy and Disclaimer.