Two Life Sentences Awarded in a Single Trial Cannot Run Consecutively: Supreme Court Applies Muthuramalingam, Orders Superimposition
In Raju Shantaram Koli v. State of Maharashtra, 2026 INSC 1161, the Supreme Court set aside the direction of the Thane Sessions Court, affirmed by the Bombay High Court, that a man’s two life sentences for the 2010 rape and murder of a 12-year-old girl would run consecutively. Applying the Constitution Bench ruling in Muthuramalingam v. State (2016), the Court held that because life imprisonment means imprisonment for the rest of a convict’s natural life, two life sentences cannot run one after the other. They are instead superimposed, so that remission or commutation of one does not automatically remit the other. The convictions and both life sentences stand.
Key Takeaways
- Life imprisonment means imprisonment for the remainder of the convict’s natural life, unless remitted or commuted.
- Multiple life sentences may be awarded for multiple offences, but cannot be directed to run consecutively (Muthuramalingam, Constitution Bench).
- Section 31 CrPC (now Section 25 BNSS) allows consecutive sentences only where they are not life sentences.
- Life sentences are superimposed: remission or commutation of one does not by itself remit the other.
- A direction for consecutive life sentences is illegal even if affirmed in appeal, and can be corrected by the Supreme Court.
Case Details at a Glance
| Case title | Raju Shantaram Koli v. The State of Maharashtra (with connected appeal) |
|---|---|
| Citation | 2026 INSC 1161 (Reportable) |
| Case number | Criminal Appeals arising out of SLP (Crl.) No. 8535 of 2025 and Diary No. 49371 of 2026 |
| Bench | Justice K.V. Viswanathan and Justice Arun Palli |
| Authored by | Justice K.V. Viswanathan |
| Date of judgment | 27 October 2026 |
| Trial | Sessions Trial No. 282 of 2010, Additional Sessions Judge, Thane; judgment dated 27.09.2013 |
| Offences | Sections 302, 376 and 342 IPC; life imprisonment on each |
| Result | Consecutive direction set aside; life sentences superimposed |
Facts of the Case
The appellant was arrested on 30 April 2010 for the rape and murder of a 12-year-old girl the previous day. In 2013 the Thane Sessions Court convicted him under Section 302 IPC and Section 376 read with 342 IPC, imposing life imprisonment on each, and directed the sentences to run consecutively. The Bombay High Court affirmed in 2016, expressly declining to interfere with the consecutive direction.
The appellant later filed a writ petition seeking concurrent running of sentences, which the High Court declined as it could not review a coordinate Bench. He then challenged the 2016 appellate judgment itself before the Supreme Court; delay was condoned since he had been in jail throughout.
Timeline of Proceedings
- 29.04.2010Rape and murder of 12-year-old.
- 30.04.2010Appellant arrested.
- 27.09.2013Thane Sessions Court: two life sentences, consecutive.
- 10.06.2016Bombay High Court affirms.
- 13.01.2025High Court declines writ for concurrent sentences.
- 27.10.2026Supreme Court sets aside consecutive direction.
Issues Before the Supreme Court
- Can two life sentences imposed in a single trial for offences under Sections 302 and 376 IPC be directed to run consecutively?
Supreme Court’s Ruling
1. Muthuramalingam governs
The Constitution Bench held that since life imprisonment lasts for the convict’s whole life, directing a prisoner to undergo life imprisonment twice over would be anomalous and irrational; humans have only one life. Section 31(1) CrPC must be read to permit consecutive sentences only where they are not life sentences, consistent with Section 427(2) CrPC.
2. Superimposition
Multiple life sentences may be awarded, but they are superimposed on each other, so that remission or commutation of one does not ipso facto remit the other.
3. Order rewritten
The consecutive direction was set aside. The conviction, the two life sentences, fines and set-off under Section 428 CrPC were maintained, and the Court rewrote the operative order accordingly. The writ-based appeal became infructuous.
“The correct legal position, as set out by this Court in Muthuramalingam (supra) is, life sentences awarded for multiple offences in a single Trial, cannot be directed to run consecutively.” – Supreme Court, 2026 INSC 1161, para 15
Result
The appeal against the High Court’s 2016 judgment was partly allowed: the direction for consecutive life sentences was set aside, and the two life sentences are to be superimposed. The other appeal was disposed of as infructuous.
Analysis and Practical Points
Trial courts still sometimes order life sentences to run consecutively in grave cases. This ruling is a reminder that the proper tool is superimposition, which protects against remission of one sentence automatically freeing the convict, rather than an impossible consecutive term.
- Trial courts: where more than one life sentence is imposed, direct superimposition; consecutive terms are permissible only for fixed-term sentences.
- Convicts: an illegal consecutive direction can be challenged even years later, with delay condoned where custody continues.
- Remission authorities: remission must be considered separately for each superimposed life sentence.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can two life sentences run one after the other?
No. In 2026 INSC 1161 the Supreme Court, following Muthuramalingam, held that life sentences awarded in a single trial cannot run consecutively.
What does superimposition of life sentences mean?
The life sentences run together, but remission or commutation of one does not automatically remit the other.
Can fixed-term sentences run consecutively?
Yes. Section 31 CrPC, now Section 25 BNSS, allows consecutive running of fixed-term sentences; the bar applies to life sentences.
Does this reduce the conviction?
No. The convictions for murder and rape and both life sentences remain; only the consecutive direction was removed.
This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Readers should refer to the certified copy of the judgment and consult a qualified professional before acting. See our Editorial Policy and Disclaimer.
