Specific Performance: Supreme Court Holds Earnest Money Refund Clause Does Not Bar Decree, Restores First Appellate Decree Set Aside in Second Appeal
In Jaspal Singh v. Ashwani Kumar, 2026 INSC 700, a buyer agreed in 2003 to purchase a co-owner’s half share of a factory plot in Jalandhar district for Rs 12.5 lakh, paying Rs 9 lakh as earnest money. The agreement said earnest money would be refunded if the sale deed could not be executed. The trial court and first appellate court decreed specific performance, but the High Court reversed in second appeal. The Supreme Court held the refund clause did not bar specific performance and that the High Court exceeded its Section 100 CPC jurisdiction by disturbing concurrent factual findings.
Key Takeaways
- A clause providing refund of earnest money if the sale cannot be executed does not, by itself, bar specific performance.
- Such a clause is not a liquidated alternative that excludes the equitable remedy.
- The High Court cannot reappreciate facts in second appeal without a substantial question of law.
- Findings on execution of the agreement, readiness and willingness, and failure of fraud defence were restored.
- Large earnest payment reflects seriousness of the bargain.
Case Details at a Glance
| Case title | Jaspal Singh v. Ashwani Kumar |
|---|---|
| Citation | 2026 INSC 700 (Reportable) |
| Case number | Civil Appeal Nos. 2448-2449 of 2023 |
| Bench | Justice K.V. Viswanathan and Justice Alok Aradhe |
| Authored by | Justice Alok Aradhe |
| Date of judgment | 14 July 2026 |
| Impugned order | Punjab and Haryana High Court judgment dated 08.02.2019 in RSA No. 3619 of 2012 and review order dated 10.07.2019 |
| Law involved | Specific Relief Act, 1963; Section 100 CPC; earnest money clauses; readiness and willingness |
| Counsel who argued | Shri R.K. Kapoor, Advocate, for the appellant; Ms. Nina R. Nariman, Advocate, for the respondent |
| Result | Appeals allowed; decree for specific performance restored |
Facts of the Case
The agreement dated 22.06.2003 fixed 22.06.2004 for the sale deed, later extended twice. The respondent alleged fraud.
The First Appellate Court decreed specific performance on 01.05.2012; the High Court allowed the respondent’s second appeal on 08.02.2019 and dismissed review on 10.07.2019.
Timeline of Proceedings
- 22.06.2003Agreement to sell; Rs 9 lakh paid.
- 21.06.2004 and 21.07.2004Extensions.
- 01.05.2012First appellate decree.
- 08.02.2019High Court reverses.
- 14.07.2026Supreme Court restores decree.
Issues Before the Supreme Court
- Does an earnest money refund clause bar specific performance?
- Did the High Court exceed Section 100 CPC jurisdiction?
Arguments and Counsel
Appellant (Shri R.K. Kapoor)
The second appeal had become infructuous after execution; the refund clause is no bar.
Respondent (Ms. Nina R. Nariman)
The agreement contemplated refund as the only remedy; execution proceedings were subject to the appeal.
Supreme Court’s Ruling
1. Clause construed
Refund clause does not exclude specific performance.
2. Section 100 limits
Concurrent findings could not be disturbed.
3. Decree restored
First Appellate Court decree revived.
Final Decision
Appeals allowed. The High Court’s second appeal judgment and review order were set aside and the First Appellate Court’s decree dated 01.05.2012 restored.
Precedents Relied On
| Case | Principle applied |
|---|---|
| Section 100, Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 | Second appeal limited to substantial questions of law |
Analysis and Practical Points
Sellers cannot rely on standard refund clauses to escape agreements; buyers should still prove readiness and willingness.
- Buyers: Preserve proof of readiness and willingness.
- Sellers: A refund clause is not an exit option.
- Drafters: Make clear whether refund is the exclusive remedy.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does an earnest money refund clause bar specific performance?
No, as held in 2026 INSC 700.
Can the High Court reverse facts in second appeal?
Not without a substantial question of law.
What was restored?
The First Appellate Court decree of 01.05.2012.
This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Readers should refer to the certified copy of the judgment and consult a qualified professional before acting. See our Editorial Policy and Disclaimer.
