Specific Performance: Supreme Court Refuses Decree for Ooty Property, Citing Buyers’ Inconsistent Conduct, Secret Onward Sale and Two Decades of Delay
In V.N.A.S. Chandran v. S. Venila, 2026 INSC 776, the owner of 1.33 acres with a building on Church Hill Road, Udhagamandalam agreed in April 2004 to sell it for Rs 2.25 crore and gave the buyer’s husband a power of attorney. While the agreement was alive, the husband agreed to sell the same property to a third person for Rs 1.5 crore, who then sued the owner using the buyers’ arrangement. The trial court refused specific performance, but the Madras High Court decreed it. The Supreme Court restored the refusal, holding that the buyers took contradictory positions, created third-party rights behind the owner’s back, and that after 22 years, with the owner aged and the buyer’s husband dead, compelling transfer would be inequitable.
Key Takeaways
- Under the pre-2018 Specific Relief Act, specific performance is discretionary and depends on the plaintiff’s bona fide conduct.
- Contradictory stands in different proceedings on whether rights were assigned defeat equitable relief.
- Using a power of attorney to agree an onward sale before title passes, without the owner’s knowledge, is conduct the court can weigh against the buyer.
- Long delay and hardship to an aged defendant are relevant factors under Section 20 (Saradamani Kandappan, Kamal Kumar).
- Even slight doubt about bona fides can justify refusal (Muddam Raju Yadav, 2026).
Case Details at a Glance
| Case title | V.N.A.S. Chandran v. S. Venila and Others |
|---|---|
| Citation | 2026 INSC 776 (Reportable) |
| Case number | Civil Appeal Nos. 7825-7828 of 2013 |
| Bench | Justice Prashant Kumar Mishra and Justice N.V. Anjaria |
| Authored by | Justice Prashant Kumar Mishra |
| Date of judgment | 31 July 2026 |
| Impugned order | Madras High Court Division Bench judgment dated 11.10.2011 in A.S. No. 443 of 2008 |
| Law involved | Sections 16 and 20, Specific Relief Act, 1963 (pre-2018 amendment); readiness and willingness; equitable discretion |
| Counsel who argued | Learned counsel for the appellant (vendor); Learned counsel for the respondent buyers and their legal representatives; Names of counsel are not recorded in the judgment |
| Result | Appeals allowed; High Court decree for specific performance set aside; trial court decree restored; buyers may withdraw Rs 1.4 crore deposit |
Facts of the Case
On 1 April 2004 the owner agreed to sell the Ooty property to the first plaintiff for Rs 2.25 crore and executed a GPA in favour of her husband, who undertook to pass all sale money to the owner. The parties disputed the true price and the advance paid, Rs 85 lakh or Rs 60 lakh.
During the agreement, the husband agreed to sell the property to a fifth defendant for Rs 1.5 crore; that person sued the owner in 2005 and briefly got an injunction, the court calling him a name-lender. The buyers’ suit for specific performance was dismissed by the trial court in 2007 but decreed by the High Court in 2011.
Timeline of Proceedings
- 01.04.2004Agreement to sell and GPA.
- 2005Suit by onward purchaser; injunction later vacated.
- 22.11.2007Trial court refuses specific performance.
- 11.10.2011High Court decrees specific performance.
- 12.11.2011Buyers deposit Rs 1.4 crore.
- 31.07.2026Supreme Court restores trial court decree.
Issues Before the Supreme Court
- Were the buyers entitled to the discretionary relief of specific performance?
Arguments and Counsel
Vendor
The buyers created third-party rights through the GPA, took contradictory stands, and two decades have passed; specific performance would be inequitable.
Buyers
They were always ready and willing, paid substantial advance, and no assignment of rights had taken place.
Supreme Court’s Ruling
1. Irreconcilable positions
In the third party’s suit the buyers said rights were assigned; in their own suit they denied it.
2. Onward sale behind owner’s back
Agreeing to sell for Rs 1.5 crore before title passed showed lack of bona fides, whether done as attorney or for the wife.
3. Delay and hardship
Over 22 years had passed; the vendor is aged and the buyer’s husband has died.
4. Restoration
Parties left where they stood; the buyers may withdraw their deposit with interest.
Final Decision
Appeals allowed. The High Court decree of specific performance was set aside and the trial court decree restored. The buyers may withdraw the Rs 1.40 crore deposited in 2011 with accrued interest. No costs.
Precedents Relied On
| Case | Principle applied |
|---|---|
| Muddam Raju Yadav v. B. Raja Shanker, 2026 INSC 214 | Conduct and bona fides in specific performance |
| Saradamani Kandappan v. S. Rajalakshmi, (2011) 12 SCC 18 | Delay and escalation of prices |
| Kamal Kumar v. Premlata Joshi, (2019) 3 SCC 704 | Hardship to defendant under Section 20 |
Analysis and Practical Points
For agreements governed by the pre-2018 law, buyers seeking specific performance must keep their conduct clean and consistent. Using a power of attorney to trade the property before completing the purchase can cost the buyer the decree.
- Buyers: Avoid onward deals before completing title; keep positions consistent across litigation.
- Sellers: Document undertakings attached to powers of attorney and object promptly to third-party deals.
- Lawyers: Note that post-2018 amendments make specific performance more readily available, but conduct still matters.
Frequently Asked Questions
What did the Supreme Court decide in V.N.A.S. Chandran v S. Venila?
In 2026 INSC 776 it refused specific performance of a 2004 agreement for property in Ooty.
Why was relief refused?
Because of the buyers’ contradictory stands, a secret onward sale and over two decades of delay.
What happens to the buyers’ deposit?
They may withdraw the Rs 1.4 crore with accrued interest.
This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Readers should refer to the certified copy of the judgment and consult a qualified professional before acting. See our Editorial Policy and Disclaimer.
