Skip to content
Criminal Law · Reversal of Acquittal

Reversal of Acquittal Set Aside: Supreme Court Restores Acquittal of Telephone Cashier in Section 409 IPC Case, Holds Entrustment Not Proved and Burden Wrongly Shifted

Section 409 IPCCriminal Breach of TrustEntrustmentReversal of AcquittalSection 114(g) Evidence ActSection 100(7) CrPC

In Ramkrushna Prahllad Dongardive v. State of Maharashtra, 2026 INSC 1099, the Supreme Court set aside the Bombay High Court’s reversal of acquittal and restored the trial court’s acquittal of a cashier-cum-counter clerk of the Telephone Department, Aurangabad, accused under Section 409 IPC of failing to deposit telephone bill collections in 1993. The Court held that entrustment was never proved, that the department withheld its own registers, that the seizure of documents from his house was doubtful, and that the High Court wrongly shifted the burden to the accused. It also noted that the High Court had sentenced him without hearing him on sentence.

Key Takeaways

  • Entrustment, the foundation of Section 409, was not proved by reliable documents.
  • The department failed to produce its registers despite requests, justifying an adverse inference under Section 114(g).
  • The seizure of 46 documents from the accused’s house was doubtful: both panch witnesses turned hostile and Section 100(7) CrPC was not followed.
  • The onus on the prosecution never shifts; an accused need only offer a probable explanation (Rabindra Kumar Dey).
  • An appellate court reversing an acquittal must give due weight to the trial court’s view, which had the benefit of seeing witnesses.
  • An appellate court convicting for the first time must hear the accused on sentence.

Case Details at a Glance

Case titleRamkrushna Prahllad Dongardive v. State of Maharashtra
Citation2026 INSC 1099 (Reportable)
Case numberCriminal Appeal No. 1432 of 2019
BenchJustice Ujjal Bhuyan and Justice Atul S. Chandurkar
Authored byJustice Atul S. Chandurkar
Date of judgment8 October 2026
Trial courtCJM Aurangabad, RCC No. 80163 of 1996, acquittal dated 20 February 2002
Impugned judgmentBombay High Court (Aurangabad), 12 October 2017: 1 year RI and Rs 5,000 fine
ResultAcquittal restored

Facts of the Case

The prosecution alleged that between 1 July and 9 October 1993 the appellant collected Rs 8,73,737 in telephone charges, deposited Rs 3,88,035 belatedly and failed to deposit Rs 4,75,702. A complaint was lodged on 11 October 1993 and a charge under Section 409 IPC was framed. The trial court acquitted him in 2002. The High Court reversed the acquittal in 2017.

Issues Before the Supreme Court

  1. Was entrustment of the alleged amounts to the appellant proved?
  2. Was the High Court justified in reversing the acquittal?

Entrustment not proved

The Assistant Accounts Officer admitted that the list relied upon bore neither the appellant’s signature nor his handwriting, that the receipt books were not countersigned by any accounts officer, that no audit was done before the complaint, and that no customer complained of disconnection despite having paid. The defence repeatedly applied for the department’s registers, and even the investigating officer could not obtain them. The trial court rightly drew an adverse inference; the High Court instead faulted the appellant for not producing the registers.

Doubtful seizure

Both panch witnesses to the seizure of 46 documents from the appellant’s house turned hostile, saying their signatures were taken at the police station. The officer did not obtain the appellant’s signature, did not give him a copy under Section 100(7) CrPC, and the panchnama was not in his handwriting. The High Court’s reliance on the officer alone could not be sustained.

Burden of proof and sentence

Quoting Rabindra Kumar Dey v. State of Orissa, the Court reiterated that the prosecution cannot benefit from weaknesses in the defence, the accused is presumed innocent and the onus never shifts. The High Court erred in drawing inferences from the appellant’s inability to explain doubtfully seized documents. The Court also noted that an appellate court convicting for the first time must hear the accused on sentence under Section 386(a) CrPC.

Final Decision

Appeal allowed. The High Court judgment dated 12 October 2017 is set aside and the trial court’s acquittal of 20 February 2002 is restored. The appellant’s bail bonds stand cancelled.

Precedents Relied On

CasePrinciple applied
Rabindra Kumar Dey v. State of Orissa, 1976 INSC 204Onus never shifts; accused need only a probable explanation
Chelloor Mankkal Narayan Ittiravi Nambudiri v. State of Travancore-CochinPrinciples on appeals against acquittal

Analysis and Practical Points

Lessons from this 33-year-old prosecution:

  • Departments and employers: preserve and produce the original registers and audit records; without them entrustment may not be proved.
  • Investigating officers: follow Section 100(7) CrPC and secure reliable panch witnesses during searches.
  • Appellate courts: reversing an acquittal requires more than a different view, and the accused must be heard on sentence.

Frequently Asked Questions

What must be proved under Section 409 IPC?

Entrustment of property to the public servant and its dishonest misappropriation. Here entrustment itself was not proved.

Why was an adverse inference drawn against the prosecution?

The Telephone Department did not produce its registers despite repeated requests, so the court could infer the records would not have supported the prosecution.

Why was the seizure of documents doubted?

Both panch witnesses turned hostile, the accused’s signature was not taken, and a copy was not given as required by Section 100(7) CrPC.

Can the burden shift to the accused in a criminal case?

No. The Court reiterated that the onus on the prosecution never shifts; the accused need only offer a probable explanation.

Must an appellate court hear the accused on sentence after reversing acquittal?

Yes. An appellate court convicting for the first time must hear the accused on sentence.

This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Readers should refer to the certified copy of the judgment and consult a qualified professional before acting. See our Editorial Policy and Disclaimer.