WhatsApp Message of Uncertain Authorship Only Raises Suspicion: Supreme Court Acquits Murder Accused, Faults Absence of DNA Profiling and Last-Seen Evidence
In Kusumlal Sao v. State of Chhattisgarh, 2026 INSC 1148, the Supreme Court set aside the murder conviction and sentence of the appellant under Sections 302 and 201 IPC and acquitted him. The prosecution case rested largely on a WhatsApp message, sent from one witness’s phone to another, saying the deceased had died in a fight at the appellant’s house. Both witnesses turned hostile and the sender denied sending it. The Court held the message, of uncertain authorship and source, at best raised suspicion, and that recoveries of a rod, screwdriver and blood-stained soil without any DNA link to the deceased could not complete the chain of circumstances.
Key Takeaways
- In a case resting entirely on circumstantial evidence, every circumstance must be fully established and the chain must exclude every hypothesis except guilt (Sharad Birdhichand Sarda).
- There was no last-seen evidence; all witnesses meant to prove the deceased was at the appellant’s house turned hostile.
- The WhatsApp message was not res gestae under Section 6 because the time of death was never fixed.
- Section 8 covers the conduct of parties, the accused or victim, not of third-party witnesses.
- Even if relevant under Section 7, the message proved only that it was sent; its author and source of knowledge remained unknown.
- Blood stains could not be linked to the deceased; no DNA profiling was done, and seizure witnesses contradicted each other.
- The doctor did not rule out injuries from a fall from a motorcycle, and the deceased was habituated to substance abuse, making an accident probable.
Case Details at a Glance
| Case title | Kusumlal Sao v. State of Chhattisgarh |
|---|---|
| Citation | 2026 INSC 1148 (Reportable) |
| Case number | Criminal Appeal No. 4894 of 2026 (arising from SLP (Crl.) No. 11542 of 2026) |
| Bench | Justice Manoj Misra and Justice Vijay Bishnoi |
| Authored by | Justice Manoj Misra |
| Date of judgment | 13 October 2026 |
| Impugned judgment | Chhattisgarh High Court (Bilaspur), Criminal Appeal No. 1482 of 2024 |
| Trial court | S.T. No. 08 of 2019, judgment dated 30 March 2024 |
| Result | Conviction set aside; appellant acquitted |
Facts of the Case
On the morning of 9 February 2019, the body of the deceased was found in an open field with his motorcycle and a yellow rope beside him. It was first reported as an accidental death, but the autopsy suggested homicide. Investigators found a WhatsApp message sent on the night of 7–8 February from the phone of one witness to another, stating that the deceased had died in a fight at the appellant’s house. After arrest, on the basis of the appellant’s disclosure statement, police seized an iron rod, a screwdriver, a blood-stained shirt and blood-stained soil.
At trial, 26 witnesses were examined, but those meant to prove a quarrel or last-seen circumstance, including the appellant’s sons, turned hostile. The deceased’s parents said there was no enmity and that the appellant and the deceased were friends. The trial court convicted the appellant and the High Court affirmed, finding homicide, a quarrel, last seen together, recoveries and unexplained injuries.
Issues Before the Supreme Court
- Did the circumstances proved form a complete chain pointing only to the appellant’s guilt?
- What is the evidentiary value of the WhatsApp message exchanged between two witnesses?
- Did the recoveries and the accused’s injuries establish guilt?
The WhatsApp message
The prosecution relied on Sections 6, 7 and 8 of the Evidence Act. The Court held that Section 6 (res gestae) required the message to be part of the same transaction, which could not be shown because the time of death was never fixed. Section 8 deals with the conduct of parties to the proceeding, the accused or victim, not third parties. At most, under Section 7, the message showed that a message was sent from one phone to another. Since the supposed sender denied sending it and the recipient denied any knowledge, who wrote it and whether it was based on personal knowledge or hearsay remained unanswered.
Recoveries and the absence of DNA
One seizure witness said blood-stained soil was collected only from the field where the body lay, and that the rod was brought to him by police; another said the soil came from the appellant’s house. The forensic report could not link the blood to the deceased because the stains had decomposed, and no DNA profiling was attempted. This cleavage in testimony and lack of forensic linkage did not help the prosecution.
Possibility of accident and the accused’s injuries
The autopsy surgeon did not rule out that the injuries could have resulted from falling off a motorcycle, and the deceased was habituated to substance abuse. The accident theory was therefore probable. The appellant’s unexplained minor abrasions on examination two days after the incident could not lead to an inference of guilt when no witness proved a fight.
The mental distance between “may be” and “must be” is long and divides vague conjectures from sure conclusions.– Shivaji Sahabrao Bobade v. State of Maharashtra, relied on in 2026 INSC 1148
Final Decision
Appeal allowed. The conviction and sentence under Sections 302 and 201 IPC are set aside and the appellant is acquitted of all charges. He is to be released forthwith unless wanted in any other case.
Precedents Relied On
| Case | Principle applied |
|---|---|
| Sharad Birdhichand Sarda v. State of Maharashtra, (1984) 4 SCC 116 | Five principles for conviction on circumstantial evidence |
| Shivaji Sahabrao Bobade v. State of Maharashtra, (1973) 2 SCC 793 | Accused must be, not merely may be, guilty |
Analysis and Practical Points
The ruling is significant for the growing reliance on digital messages in criminal trials:
- Digital evidence: proving that a message was sent is not proof of its contents; prosecutors must establish authorship and the basis of the author’s knowledge.
- Forensics: where blood is recovered, failure to attempt DNA profiling can be fatal in a circumstantial case.
- Defence: contradictions between seizure witnesses and medical evidence consistent with accident can create reasonable doubt.
- Under BSA: the same principles apply to the corresponding provisions of the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can a WhatsApp message alone prove murder?
Not where its author is unproven and the basis of its information is unknown. The Supreme Court held such a message at best raises suspicion.
Was the WhatsApp message admissible as res gestae?
No. Under Section 6 it had to be part of the same transaction, which could not be shown because the time of death was never fixed.
Why did the recoveries not help the prosecution?
The blood could not be linked to the deceased, no DNA profiling was done, and seizure witnesses gave contradictory accounts.
What are the conditions for conviction on circumstantial evidence?
Each circumstance must be fully proved, consistent only with guilt, and form a complete chain excluding every other hypothesis.
Was the accused released?
Yes. He was acquitted and directed to be released forthwith unless required in another case.
This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Readers should refer to the certified copy of the judgment and consult a qualified professional before acting. See our Editorial Policy and Disclaimer.
