Skip to content
Criminal Law · Cognate Offences

Robbery Not Proved but Knocking Out a Tooth Is Grievous Hurt: Supreme Court Alters 1993 Conviction From Section 394 to Section 325 IPC, Limits Sentence to Period Undergone

Section 394 IPCSection 325 IPCGrievous HurtSection 222 CrPCCognate OffenceIdentification

In Appa v. State of Maharashtra, 2026 INSC 1091, the Supreme Court set aside a conviction for robbery with hurt under Section 394 IPC arising from a 1993 night attack on a farmhouse in Nashik district, because the gold ornaments allegedly snatched were never recovered or proved. The Court upheld the identification of the accused, and using the principle of cognate offences under Section 222 CrPC, converted the conviction to Section 325 IPC (voluntarily causing grievous hurt), since he had knocked out the complainant’s tooth. As the 63-year-old appellant had spent about ten months in custody, his sentence was reduced to the period already undergone.

Key Takeaways

  • Identification was reliable: the FIR was lodged within four hours, the complainant named the accused, knew him, and the porch light was on during an hour-long incident.
  • Absence of a Test Identification Parade was not fatal where the witness already knew the accused.
  • Robbery was not proved: the mangalsutra and ornaments were never recovered and their value not established.
  • Under Section 222 CrPC (now Section 245 BNSS), an accused can be convicted of a minor offence proved by the evidence even if not separately charged.
  • A shallow hand wound with no weapon recovered did not establish Section 326.
  • Knocking out a tooth is grievous hurt under Section 320 IPC (fracture or dislocation of a tooth), so Section 325 applied.
  • Considering age and ten months in custody, the sentence was limited to the period undergone, with the Rs 1,000 fine retained.

Case Details at a Glance

Case titleAppa v. State of Maharashtra
Citation2026 INSC 1091 (Reportable)
Case numberCriminal Appeal No. 4766 of 2026
BenchJustice Prashant Kumar Mishra and Justice Shree Chandrashekhar
Authored byJustice Prashant Kumar Mishra
Date of judgment7 October 2026
Impugned judgmentBombay High Court, 16 January 2026, in Criminal Appeal No. 690 of 1998
Trial courtAdditional Sessions Judge, Malegaon: 7 years RI under Section 394 IPC
ResultAppeal partly allowed; conviction altered to Section 325 IPC

Facts of the Case

On the night of 23 January 1993, four men came to a farmhouse near Manmad. The complainant woke to find the appellant sitting on her cot. He held a knife to her neck, and when she tried to grab it her hand was cut. He then punched her, knocking out an upper tooth, and allegedly removed her mangalsutra and other ornaments. Another accused assaulted her daughter, and others tied up her husband. The FIR was lodged at 1:50 a.m. The trial court convicted the appellant under Section 394 IPC and sentenced him to seven years’ rigorous imprisonment; the High Court affirmed in 2026.

Issues Before the Supreme Court

  1. Was the identification of the appellant proved?
  2. Was the offence of robbery under Section 394 IPC established?
  3. Could the appellant be convicted of a lesser offence?

Identification upheld

The appellant argued that the assailants were masked, the incident was at night, no TIP was held and he was shown to witnesses after arrest. The Court rejected this. The complainant named him and his village in the prompt FIR, explained their acquaintance, and was corroborated by her injured daughter and husband. The porch bulb was on and the incident lasted about an hour.

Why robbery failed

The ornaments were never recovered from the appellant, their value rested only on the complainant’s word, and beads found on the porch were never linked to the mangalsutra. The conviction under Section 394 could not be sustained.

Conviction for the cognate offence

Relying on Rafiq Ahmed @ Rafi v. State of U.P., the Court applied Section 222 CrPC to convict for the lesser offence proved. The 7 x ½ x ½ cm hand wound was relatively shallow and the knife was never recovered, so Section 326 was not made out. But the tooth knocked out by the punch was proved by witnesses and medical evidence and falls within “fracture or dislocation of a bone or tooth” in Section 320, attracting Section 325.

Final Decision

Appeal partly allowed. The appellant is convicted under Section 325 IPC. Following Mathai v. State of Kerala, his sentence is reduced to the period already undergone (about ten months), with the fine of Rs 1,000 maintained. He is to be released forthwith unless required in another case.

Precedents Relied On

CasePrinciple applied
Rafiq Ahmed @ Rafi v. State of U.P., 2011 INSC 546Conviction for cognate minor offence
Mathai v. State of Kerala, 2005 INSC 30Conviction altered to Section 325; sentence limited to period undergone

Analysis and Practical Points

Practical takeaways from this decades-old case:

  • Prosecution: in robbery cases, prove the property taken through recovery or reliable evidence of value; otherwise the robbery limb may fail.
  • Defence: even where identification stands, courts may scale down the offence to what the evidence proves.
  • Grievous hurt: loss of a tooth is expressly grievous hurt under Section 320 IPC and the corresponding BNS provision.
  • Sentencing: age and time spent in custody can justify limiting sentence to the period undergone for old incidents.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is knocking out a tooth grievous hurt?

Yes. Section 320 IPC lists fracture or dislocation of a bone or tooth as grievous hurt, so the Court applied Section 325.

Why was the robbery conviction set aside?

The ornaments were never recovered and their value was not proved, so robbery under Section 394 IPC was not established.

Can a court convict for an offence not charged?

Under Section 222 CrPC (Section 245 BNSS), a court can convict for a minor offence whose ingredients are proved, even if it was not separately charged.

Was the lack of a test identification parade fatal?

No. The complainant knew the accused, named him in the prompt FIR, and the incident took place under light for about an hour.

What sentence did the appellant finally get?

The period already undergone, about ten months, with a fine of Rs 1,000.

This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Readers should refer to the certified copy of the judgment and consult a qualified professional before acting. See our Editorial Policy and Disclaimer.