Supreme Court Restores CERC Order: Generator That Delayed Its Dedicated Transmission Line Must Pay Charges for PGCIL’s Tuticorin LILOs
In Power Grid Corporation of India Ltd. v. Tamil Nadu Generation and Distribution Corporation Ltd. (TANGEDCO), 2026 INSC 1237, the Supreme Court allowed PGCIL’s appeals, set aside two APTEL orders and restored the CERC order of 29 July 2016. It held that the two Line-In Line-Out (LILO) arrangements of the Tuticorin JV–Madurai 400 kV line at the Tuticorin Pooling Station were in regular service from 4 and 8 January 2015, that power from Coastal Energen (now Moxie Power Generation Ltd.) necessarily flowed through them, and that because the generator had not built its own dedicated transmission line (DTL), it must bear the non-PoC transmission charges for the LILOs until the DTL was commissioned on 27 October 2016. APTEL’s ‘beneficial use’ theory and its direction to re-examine the COD were rejected.
Key Takeaways
- Building and operating the dedicated transmission line is the generating company’s statutory duty under Section 10 read with Section 2(16) of the Electricity Act, 2003.
- Upstream transmission means the inter-State system built by the CTU; downstream means the distribution licensee’s system within the State.
- Once LILOs intercept a line at a pooling station, power is necessarily routed through them; the ‘path of least resistance’ argument supported PGCIL, not the generator.
- Delay in the Tuticorin–Salem upstream line did not affect evacuation, since the LILOs served as the upstream path; the generator’s DTL delay was the relevant default.
- Regulation 4(3)(ii) of the 2014 Tariff Regulations applies only when an element is prevented from regular service; COD based on RLDC trial operation and CEA certificates needed no re-determination.
- CERC may place liability on the defaulting party even without a specific regulation (PGCIL v. MPPTCL, Energy Watchdog, PTC India).
- Standing Committee decisions under Section 29(4) of the Electricity Act bind participants.
Case Details at a Glance
| Case title | Power Grid Corporation of India Limited v. Tamil Nadu Generation and Distribution Corporation Limited (TANGEDCO) & Ors. |
|---|---|
| Citation | 2026 INSC 1237 (Reportable) |
| Case number | Civil Appeal Nos. 14780–14781 of 2025 with Civil Appeal No. 13153 of 2026 |
| Bench | Justice J.B. Pardiwala and Justice K. Vinod Chandran |
| Authored by | Justice K. Vinod Chandran |
| Date of judgment | 18 November 2026 |
| Generating company | Moxie Power Generation Limited (formerly Coastal Energen Private Limited), Tuticorin |
| Amount in dispute | Non-PoC transmission charges of Rs 15,43,26,909 for 04.01.2015 to 27.10.2016 |
| Impugned orders | APTEL order setting aside CERC’s tariff findings, and APTEL review order remanding COD to CERC |
| Result | Appeals allowed; APTEL orders set aside; CERC order dated 29.07.2016 restored |
Facts of the Case
Coastal Energen and Ind-Barath set up thermal power projects in the Tuticorin area of Tamil Nadu. The 29th meeting of the Southern Region Standing Committee on power system planning (August 2009) planned their evacuation through a Tuticorin Pooling Station and 765 kV lines onward to Salem and Madhugiri. Each generator was to build its own DTL to the Tuticorin Pooling Station. As a temporary measure, Coastal Energen was allowed to LILO one circuit of the Tuticorin JV–Madurai line near its plant for start-up power and evacuation.
Because NLC’s Tuticorin JV station could spare only one bay, the 30th Standing Committee meeting (May 2010) agreed that both circuits of the Tuticorin JV–Madurai 400 kV line would be LILOed at the Tuticorin Pooling Station. The Bulk Power Transmission Agreement, as amended on 8 September 2011, included these LILOs in Part A of the common system (scheduled for July 2014), with the Salem and Madhugiri lines in Part B.
Coastal Energen began generation on 23 December 2014 and supplied power to TANGEDCO under short-term and then medium-term open access. PGCIL commissioned the two LILOs on 4 and 8 January 2015. The generator’s DTL was commissioned only on 27 October 2016; the Tuticorin–Salem line came on 13 November 2016, and long-term access was operationalised on 1 December 2016.
CERC approved the COD of the LILOs and held that, since the generator had delayed its DTL and was using PGCIL’s LILOs, it must bear their transmission charges until the DTL was in regular use. The generator did not appear before CERC. APTEL reversed, holding that the LILOs were permanent but were not used (no ‘beneficial use’) because the upstream lines were not ready, and that COD should have been decided under Regulation 4(3)(ii). In review, it remanded the COD issue to CERC.
Timeline of Proceedings
- 27.08.200929th Standing Committee meeting plans Tuticorin evacuation system and temporary LILO for Coastal Energen.
- 24.02.2010Bulk Power Transmission Agreement signed; generator to build DTL.
- 05.05.201030th Standing Committee meeting approves LILO of both circuits at Tuticorin Pooling Station.
- 08.09.2011BPTA annexures amended into Part A (LILOs) and Part B (Salem/Madhugiri lines).
- 23.12.2014Coastal Energen starts generation.
- 04.01.2015 and 08.01.2015COD of the two PGCIL LILOs.
- 29.07.2016CERC tariff order fixes generator liability for LILO charges.
- 27.10.2016Generator’s DTL commissioned; bilateral billing ends.
- 13.11.2016Tuticorin–Salem upstream line commissioned.
- 18.11.2026Supreme Court restores the CERC order.
Issues Before the Supreme Court
- Is PGCIL entitled to transmission tariff for the two LILOs, which formed part of statutory planning under Section 29(4) of the Electricity Act and the BPTA?
- Was APTEL right in directing CERC to re-determine the COD of the LILOs under Regulation 4(3)(ii) of the 2014 Tariff Regulations?
- Does the generator’s delay in building its DTL make it liable for the LILO charges from January 2015 to 27 October 2016?
Supreme Court’s Ruling
1. The LILOs were in fact used
The Court rejected the generator’s argument that electricity flows by the path of least resistance and so bypassed the LILOs. Once the LILOs intercepted both circuits, the path of least resistance was through the Tuticorin Pooling Station and back to the line. The generator had itself told APTEL that it was using the Tuticorin Pooling Station to evacuate power and had 558 MW of medium-term access over these assets; its only grievance was about sharing the charges.
2. The statutory scheme of transmission
Under the Electricity Act, the generator must establish and maintain its DTL (Sections 2(16) and 10). Transmission has three stages: the generator’s DTL, the CTU’s inter-State lines (including LILOs and pooling stations), and the distribution licensee’s network. The Court read ‘upstream’ as the CTU’s inter-State system and ‘downstream’ as the distribution licensee’s system. A pooling station, as defined in the Grid Code of 2023, aggregates power from several generators for evacuation at a higher voltage.
3. Upstream delay was irrelevant; DTL delay was decisive
Generation, transmission, supply and consumption were all admitted. The delay in the Salem and Madhugiri lines did not hamper evacuation, as the LILOs functioned as the upstream path. In the absence of the generator’s DTL, power went through its temporary LILO, then PGCIL’s LILOs, to TANGEDCO. The claim was confined to the period between the LILOs’ COD and the DTL’s commissioning.
4. COD needed no re-determination
‘Regular service’ under Regulation 3(53) means use after successful trial operation certified by the RLDC. Regulation 4(3)(ii) applies only when an element is prevented from regular service because of delay by the generator or in the upstream or downstream system. Here there was no such prevention. CERC had accepted the COD on the RLDC trial operation certificate, the CEA certificate under Regulation 43 of the 2010 Safety Regulations and the Standing Committee approvals.
5. Precedents support liability of the defaulter
Following PGCIL v. Madhya Pradesh Power Transmission Co. Ltd., (2025) 8 SCC 705, PTC India Ltd. v. CERC, (2010) 4 SCC 603 and Energy Watchdog v. CERC, (2017) 14 SCC 80, the Court held that CERC’s regulatory power under Section 79 allows it to impose liability on a defaulting party even where no specific regulation exists. Charging the generator for the period of its DTL default was perfectly in order.
6. APTEL’s errors
APTEL accepted that the LILOs were a permanent part of the plan yet found them unused, despite the generator’s admission. It treated paragraph 72 of the CERC order, which merely recorded TANGEDCO’s contention, as a finding, and coined the ‘beneficial use’ test from it. Its reading of the network diagram was factually wrong. Standing Committee decisions under Section 29(4) bind all participants, and the generator had neither objected there nor appeared before CERC.
“The LILOs being an integral part of the system, the delay in implementation of the upstream transmission to Salem does not affect the evacuation arrangement at all.” – Supreme Court, 2026 INSC 1237, para 36
Result
All three questions were answered in PGCIL’s favour. The two LILOs are includable in transmission tariff on a non-PoC basis from 04.01.2015 / 08.01.2015 until the DTL was established on 27.10.2016; APTEL’s interpretation on COD was wrong; and the generator is liable because of its delay in building the DTL. Both APTEL orders were set aside, the CERC order was restored and the appeals were allowed.
Analysis and Practical Points
The decision matters for every generator connected through interim arrangements while its own evacuation line is pending. A generator cannot use the CTU’s network, avoid building its DTL on time, and then argue that the assets it used should be socialised in the PoC pool or that their COD is premature because some other upstream line was late.
- Generators: build and commission the DTL to the schedule in your connectivity and transmission agreements. Until you do, expect bilateral liability for CTU assets you actually use. Appear before CERC in tariff proceedings, as silence there weakened the generator’s case.
- Transmission licensees: keep RLDC trial operation certificates, CEA energisation approvals and Standing Committee minutes in order; they establish regular service and COD.
- Distribution licensees: pleas that an asset was never used while also disputing liability for its use were described by PGCIL, and noted by APTEL, as mutually destructive.
- Open access charges: PGCIL argued that STOA and MTOA payments did not cover the LILOs, as their tariff had not yet been determined or included in the PoC pool during the period. With the CERC order restored, those payments did not relieve the generator of the non-PoC charges.
Frequently Asked Questions
Who must build the dedicated transmission line from a power plant?
The generating company. Under Section 10 read with Section 2(16) of the Electricity Act, 2003, establishing and maintaining the dedicated transmission line is the generator's duty.
Is a generator liable for transmission charges if its dedicated line is delayed?
Yes. In 2026 INSC 1237 the Supreme Court restored CERC's order making the generator pay non-PoC transmission charges for PGCIL's LILOs used in the interim, until its own dedicated line was commissioned.
When does Regulation 4(3)(ii) of the 2014 Tariff Regulations apply?
Only when a transmission element is prevented from regular service for reasons not attributable to the transmission licensee, such as delay by the generator or in upstream or downstream systems. It did not apply because the LILOs were in regular service.
What is a LILO in power transmission?
A Line-In Line-Out or Loop-In Loop-Out arrangement cuts into an existing transmission line and routes it through a substation or pooling station before returning it to the line.
Are Standing Committee decisions on transmission planning binding?
Yes. The Court noted that decisions taken under Section 29(4) of the Electricity Act in furtherance of grid planning have legal sanctity and bind the participating parties.
This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Readers should refer to the certified copy of the judgment and consult a qualified professional before acting. See our Editorial Policy and Disclaimer.
