Skip to content
Civil Law · Mesne Profits

Supreme Court Upholds Mesne Profits Against Goodyear India: Rate Fixed on Tenant’s Own Admission, Interest Is Integral to Mesne Profits

In Bharat Bhushan Jain (Dead) through LRs. v. M/s Goodyear India Ltd., 2026 INSC 1240, the Supreme Court dismissed the landlords’ appeals and upheld the Delhi High Court’s assessment of mesne profits at Rs 7 per sq ft per month (ground floor) and Rs 5 per sq ft per month (mezzanine) for Goodyear India’s continued occupation of premises at Ansari Road, Daryaganj, after its tenancy ended on 31 December 1989. The Court held that mesne profits are compensatory and follow no rigid formula, that overlooking the tenant’s own witness’s admission on prevailing rent was a substantial question of law, and that interest is an integral part of mesne profits. Citing more than three decades of litigation, the Court gave the case finality.

Key Takeaways

  • Mesne profits compensate the owner for wrongful occupation; there is no rigid formula, only a fair and reasonable estimate based on location, rental value, evidence and circumstances.
  • Assessment of mesne profits is a finding on evidence and is not ordinarily disturbed in appeal unless arbitrary, unsupported by the record or legally erroneous (Martin and Harris Pvt. Ltd. v. Rajendra Mehta, (2022) 8 SCC 527).
  • Omitting a material admission of the defendant’s own witness on prevailing rent raises a substantial question of law under Section 100 CPC.
  • A rental instance is a valid comparable only if the premises are similar in age, use, construction and value.
  • Interest is an integral component of mesne profits; simple interest at 7.5% (6% if paid in two months) was upheld.
  • Long-pending disputes based on unchanged evidence deserve finality.

Case Details at a Glance

Case titleBharat Bhushan Jain (Dead) through LRs. and Others etc. v. M/s Goodyear India Ltd. and Another
Citation2026 INSC 1240 (Reportable)
Case numberCivil Appeal Nos. 9668–9669 of 2013
BenchJustice Prashant Kumar Mishra and Justice N.V. Anjaria
Authored byJustice Prashant Kumar Mishra
Date of judgment18 November 2026
PropertyXI/4239-A/2 (Plot No. 3A), 1, Ansari Road, Daryaganj, New Delhi
Impugned judgmentDelhi High Court judgment dated 11.08.2011 in RSA No. 186 of 2010 and RSA No. 187 of 2010
Mesne profits upheldRs 7 per sq ft per month (ground floor) and Rs 5 per sq ft per month (mezzanine), simple interest at 7.5% p.a. (6% if paid within two months)
ResultAppeals dismissed

Facts of the Case

The landlords let out premises at 1, Ansari Road, Daryaganj, New Delhi, to Goodyear India Ltd. The tenancy was terminated with effect from midnight of 31 December 1989. In 1990 the owners sued for possession and claimed damages for use and occupation at Rs 1,47,500 per month with 15% interest.

On 22 December 1998 the trial court decreed possession but declined damages for the single day before the suit, as the evidence did not show that the property could be let at that rate. It passed a preliminary decree under Order XX Rule 12 CPC for a separate inquiry into mesne profits. The decree for possession became final when the High Court dismissed Goodyear’s first appeal in 2000 and the Supreme Court dismissed its SLP in limine on 19 March 2001.

In the mesne profits inquiry the trial court fixed Rs 22 per sq ft (ground floor) and Rs 11 per sq ft (mezzanine) on carpet area, with 15% interest, relying on premises let to Vijaya Bank at 2/10, Ansari Road. The first appellate court set this aside as speculative and allowed only the admitted rent. In second appeal the Delhi High Court found that the first appellate court had ignored the admission of Goodyear’s own officer (DW-1) that prevailing rents in the locality were Rs 5 to Rs 8 per sq ft per month, and fixed Rs 7 and Rs 5 with 7.5% simple interest. This was more than the admitted rent but well below the trial court’s figures, and the landlords appealed seeking restoration of the trial court’s rate and enhancement to Rs 30 and Rs 15 per sq ft on covered area.

Timeline of Proceedings

  • 31.12.1989Tenancy of Goodyear India terminated.
  • 1990Suit for possession and damages filed (Suit No. 41/1990, later Suit No. 78/1996).
  • 22.12.1998Trial court decrees possession; preliminary decree for mesne profits inquiry under Order XX Rule 12 CPC.
  • 19.03.2001Supreme Court dismisses Goodyear’s SLP; decree for possession becomes final.
  • 30.04.2004Trial court fixes Rs 22 / Rs 11 per sq ft with 15% interest.
  • 12.07.2010First appellate court reverses and allows only the admitted rent.
  • 11.08.2011Delhi High Court fixes Rs 7 / Rs 5 per sq ft with 7.5% simple interest.
  • 18.11.2026Supreme Court dismisses the landlords’ appeals.

Issues Before the Supreme Court

  1. Was the High Court’s rate of mesne profits supported by evidence?
  2. Was the Vijaya Bank tenancy a proper comparable for fixing rental value?
  3. Could the High Court interfere in second appeal because a material admission had been overlooked?
  4. Was the rate of interest on mesne profits liable to be enhanced?

Supreme Court’s Ruling

1. Nature of mesne profits

The Court said mesne profits are compensatory and intended to recompense the true owner for the loss caused by continued wrongful occupation. The court must reach a fair and reasonable estimate having regard to the nature and location of the property, prevailing rental value, the evidence and the circumstances. Such findings are not ordinarily disturbed unless manifestly arbitrary, unsupported by the record or based on a wrong application of law, as held in Martin and Harris Pvt. Ltd. v. Rajendra Mehta, (2022) 8 SCC 527.

2. The Vijaya Bank comparison failed

The first appellate court rightly refused to treat the Vijaya Bank premises as comparable. The suit premises were old buildings from the 1950s used as a godown (ground floor and mezzanine), while the bank premises were built in 1972 and used for banking (ground floor and basement). There was no valuation or municipal assessment showing similarity, and no evidence on construction quality.

3. Overlooking the tenant’s admission was a substantial question of law

Goodyear’s own witness had admitted in his examination-in-chief that at the time the tenancy ended, prevailing rent in the locality was Rs 5 to Rs 8 per sq ft per month. The first appellate court ignored this. The Supreme Court agreed with the High Court that omitting such material evidence gave rise to a substantial question of law under Section 100 CPC.

4. A balanced assessment, not a mechanical one

The High Court did not simply adopt the lowest admitted figure, nor did it revive the Vijaya Bank comparison. It assessed the whole record and fixed rates within the range admitted by the tenant. This could not be called arbitrary or speculative.

5. Interest is part of mesne profits

Interest is an integral component of mesne profits, compensating the owner for being deprived of the property (Mahant Narayana Dasjee Varu v. Board of Trustees, Tirumalai Tirupathi Devasthanam, 1964). Simple interest at 7.5%, reduced to 6% on payment within two months, called for no interference.

“Their assessment is not governed by any rigid or inflexible formula.” – Supreme Court, 2026 INSC 1240, para 10

Result

The appeals were dismissed. The Delhi High Court’s determination of mesne profits at Rs 7 per sq ft per month for the ground floor and Rs 5 per sq ft per month for the mezzanine, with simple interest at 7.5% per annum from the month each instalment fell due, stands. The Court noted that the tenancy ended in 1989, possession became final in 2001, and the appeals had been pending for nearly fifteen years, so finality was in the interests of justice.

Analysis and Practical Points

For landlords, the case shows how hard it is to prove a high market rent with a single rental instance. The trial court’s rate fell because the comparable property was different in age, use and type. The landlords finally obtained more than the admitted rent only because the tenant’s own witness gave a range of prevailing rents.

  • Landlords: prove rental value with several comparable lettings of similar age, floor, use and construction, supported by valuation reports or municipal records. Use cross-examination to obtain admissions on prevailing rent from the tenant’s witnesses.
  • Tenants: statements by your own officers on market rent can be used against you; they set the floor for mesne profits.
  • Interest: claim interest month by month from the date each instalment of mesne profits fell due. Section 2(12) CPC treats interest as part of mesne profits, and the Court confirmed it is integral to them.
  • Second appeals: ignoring material evidence that bears directly on the outcome can be a substantial question of law under Section 100 CPC.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are mesne profits?

Mesne profits are the profits a person in wrongful possession actually received or might reasonably have received from the property. In 2026 INSC 1240 the Supreme Court described them as compensatory, meant to make good the owner's loss from continued wrongful occupation.

Is interest part of mesne profits?

Yes. The Supreme Court held that interest is an integral component of mesne profits because it compensates the owner for being deprived of the beneficial enjoyment of the property.

How do courts decide the rate of mesne profits?

There is no rigid formula. The court makes a fair and reasonable estimate based on the nature and location of the property, prevailing rent, the evidence led and the circumstances of the case.

Can a rent paid by a bank for a nearby building be used as a comparable?

Only if the properties are truly similar. Here the bank premises were newer, used for banking and differently configured, and there was no valuation evidence, so they were rejected as a comparable.

What is a preliminary decree under Order XX Rule 12 CPC?

In a suit for possession and mesne profits, the court may decree possession and direct a separate inquiry into mesne profits. The final decree for the amount is then passed after that inquiry.

This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Readers should refer to the certified copy of the judgment and consult a qualified professional before acting. See our Editorial Policy and Disclaimer.