Seven-Judge Bench Closes 30-Year Reference on Sales Tax Surcharge: S. Kodar Holds the Field, a Surcharge on Tax Payable Is a Tax on Sale of Goods
In Arjun Flour Mills v. State of Odisha, 2026 INSC 1192, a seven-judge Bench of the Supreme Court led by Chief Justice Surya Kant answered a reference pending for nearly three decades: can a State levy, under Entry 54 of List II, a surcharge computed as a percentage of the sales tax payable by large dealers, or is that an impermissible ‘tax on tax’? The reference arose from a perceived conflict between Hoechst Pharmaceuticals and India Cement, and later the correctness of S. Kodar v. State of Kerala (1974). The majority held the reference academic: India Cement’s premise that royalty is a tax has been overruled by the nine-judge Bench in Mineral Area Development Authority (2024), so no conflict remains; S. Kodar holds that such a surcharge is an enhancement of the sales tax rate on sale of goods; and the sales tax regime has been replaced by VAT and GST. Justice K.V. Viswanathan, concurring, held S. Kodar correctly decided. The individual Odisha and Punjab appeals go to regular Benches.
Key Takeaways
- A surcharge or additional tax computed as a percentage of sales tax payable by dealers above a turnover threshold is a tax on the sale or purchase of goods under Entry 54 of List II, as it then stood (S. Kodar).
- The mode of computing a levy does not change its essential character; measure of tax is a matter of legislative policy with a reasonable nexus.
- India Cement dealt with a cess on royalty, and its premise that royalty is a tax was overruled in MADA (2024); it creates no conflict with S. Kodar.
- S. Kodar and Hoechst are consistent.
- With the old Entry and State sales tax laws replaced by GST, the question has no prospective significance; the reference was answered as infructuous.
- Left open: validity of Section 30-AA of the Punjab Act (surcharge on exempt units) and whether the Punjab Social Security Act cess could bypass the Consolidated Fund under Article 266.
Case Details at a Glance
| Case title | Arjun Flour Mills v. State of Odisha, Finance Department Secretary & Ors. (with connected matters from Punjab) |
|---|---|
| Citation | 2026 INSC 1192 (Reportable) |
| Case number | Civil Appeal No. 8763 of 1994 and connected appeals and SLPs |
| Bench | Chief Justice Surya Kant, Justices S.V.N. Bhatti, Joymalya Bagchi, N.V. Anjaria, Arun Palli, V. Mohana and K.V. Viswanathan |
| Opinions | Chief Justice Surya Kant for six Judges; concurring opinion by Justice K.V. Viswanathan |
| Date of judgment | 4 November 2026 |
| Provisions challenged | Section 5-A Orissa Sales Tax Act, 1947; Sections 5(1-C) and 30-AA Punjab General Sales Tax Act, 1948; Punjab Social Security Act, 2000 |
| Result | Reference answered as infructuous; S. Kodar governs; matters sent to regular Benches |
Facts of the Case
Section 5-A of the Orissa Sales Tax Act, inserted in 1990, required dealers with gross turnover above Rs 10 lakh to pay a surcharge of 10% of the tax payable, which they could not collect from buyers. Dealers argued that because it was measured on tax rather than turnover, it was a tax on tax or on income, outside Entry 54 of List II. Punjab had a similar surcharge under Section 5(1-C), and Section 30-AA extended it even to exempted industrial units. Punjab also levied a cess under the Punjab Social Security Act, 2000 as a percentage of sales tax, which the High Court struck down for bypassing the Consolidated Fund.
The matter travelled from a two-judge Bench to a Constitution Bench and, in 1999, to a seven-judge Bench, because of a perceived conflict between Hoechst Pharmaceuticals v. State of Bihar (1983), which followed S. Kodar, and the seven-judge decision in India Cement v. State of Tamil Nadu (1990).
Timeline of Proceedings
- 17.04.1974S. Kodar upholds additional sales tax computed on tax payable.
- 1983Hoechst Pharmaceuticals follows S. Kodar.
- 1990India Cement holds royalty is a tax; Orissa surcharge introduced.
- 06.10.1999Reference enlarged to a seven-judge Bench.
- 2024Nine-judge Bench in MADA overrules India Cement on royalty.
- 04.11.2026Seven-judge Bench answers reference as infructuous.
Issues Before the Supreme Court
- Is a surcharge computed as a percentage of sales tax payable within the State’s competence under Entry 54 of List II?
- Does S. Kodar require reconsideration in light of India Cement?
- Does the reference survive after MADA and the move to VAT and GST?
Supreme Court’s Ruling
1. The conflict has disappeared
India Cement concerned a cess on royalty under a field covered by the MMDR Act and did not hold that a levy computed as a percentage of another tax is beyond legislative competence. Its premise that royalty is a tax was overruled by the nine-judge Bench in MADA. No subsisting decision conflicts with S. Kodar.
2. S. Kodar holds the field
S. Kodar held that an additional tax or surcharge computed as a percentage of sales tax payable is an enhancement of the rate of sales tax and a tax on sale or purchase of goods within Entry 54. That the dealer cannot pass it on does not change its character. MADA also recognised that the measure of a tax is for the legislature, if it has a nexus with the nature of the levy.
3. Reference academic
The constitutional entry and State sales tax laws have since been replaced, first by VAT and then by GST. The question has no prospective significance, so the reference does not survive for a seven-judge Bench.
4. Concurring opinion
Justice Viswanathan held that S. Kodar was correctly decided and needs no reconsideration, and that neither the curative petition against MADA nor the 2026 amendment inserting Section 9-D in the MMDR Act affects this.
5. Issues left open
The validity of Section 30-AA of the Punjab Act, and the Article 266 question on the Punjab social security cess, were left for regular Benches, along with individual assessment issues.
“S. Kodar (supra) has been correctly decided, continues to be a good law and needs no reconsideration.” – Supreme Court, 2026 INSC 1192, concurring opinion, para 65
Result
The reference was answered as rendered infructuous, with the question of legislative competence to be governed by S. Kodar. The Odisha and Punjab sales tax appeals, and the Punjab Social Security Act matters, are to be listed before appropriate regular Benches on the directions of the Chief Justice.
Analysis and Practical Points
Although the sales tax era is over, many legacy assessments and refund claims depend on the validity of such surcharges. Dealers who hoped for a ruling against ‘tax on tax’ levies will now have their appeals decided under S. Kodar, which upholds them.
- Dealers with pending legacy disputes: challenges based solely on the tax-on-tax argument are unlikely to succeed; focus on Section 30-AA type issues and assessment-specific points left open.
- States: surcharges measured on tax payable remain defensible as rate enhancements.
- GST era: the reasoning on measure of tax and the character of levies remains relevant to cesses and surcharges generally.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is a surcharge calculated on sales tax payable a tax on tax?
No. Following S. Kodar, the seven-judge Bench in 2026 INSC 1192 confirmed that such a surcharge is an enhancement of the sales tax rate and a tax on the sale of goods under Entry 54 of List II.
Why did the seven-judge Bench not decide the reference on merits?
Because the conflict with India Cement disappeared after the nine-judge MADA judgment, S. Kodar continues to hold the field, and the sales tax regime has been replaced by GST, making the question academic.
Is S. Kodar v. State of Kerala still good law?
Yes. The majority held that it continues to hold the field, and Justice Viswanathan's concurring opinion held it was correctly decided.
What happens to the Punjab Social Security Act cess cases?
The question whether its proceeds could bypass the Consolidated Fund under Article 266 was left open and the matters were sent to a regular Bench.
Is the Punjab surcharge on exempted units valid?
The validity of Section 30-AA of the Punjab General Sales Tax Act was left open for decision by the regular Bench.
This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Readers should refer to the certified copy of the judgment and consult a qualified professional before acting. See our Editorial Policy and Disclaimer.
