A Collusive Applicant Does Not Automatically End the CIRP: Supreme Court Lets NCLT Decide Whether Greenopolis Insolvency Should Continue
In Orris Infrastructure Pvt. Ltd. v. Rakesh Kumar Gupta, 2026 INSC 1070, the Supreme Court answered two questions under the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code. Both the NCLT and the NCLAT had found that the operational creditor which started the insolvency of Three C Shelters, developer of the 1,862-flat Greenopolis project in Gurgaon, was acting fraudulently and in collusion with the developer’s suspended directors. The NCLT said it had no power to recall the admission. The NCLAT said it did, and then simply ended the whole insolvency. The Supreme Court held that the Adjudicating Authority can recall an admission obtained through fraud on jurisdictional facts. But because the process becomes in rem once admitted, it need not end. The NCLT must decide, after hearing the RP, the CoC and homebuyers, whether to continue without the collusive applicant.
Key Takeaways
- Admission under Sections 7, 9 or 10 rests on jurisdictional facts. If those facts turn out to be fraudulent and collusive, the NCLT may recall the admission. Applicants have a public law duty not to mislead on jurisdictional facts.
- Once admitted, the CIRP is no longer the applicant’s case. It becomes a proceeding in rem in which all creditors are stakeholders and the RP manages the debtor.
- The original applicant cannot withdraw after admission, a rule now reflected in Section 12A.
- On a finding of fraud, the NCLT shall exclude the collusive applicant and may start proceedings under Section 65.
- The NCLT may continue the CIRP for the wider body of creditors, guided by the CoC’s commercial wisdom and the RP’s views, or may give reasons for ending it.
- Both the NCLT and the NCLAT erred by not taking this consequential decision.
Case Details at a Glance
| Case title | Orris Infrastructure Pvt. Ltd. v. Rakesh Kumar Gupta & Ors., with appeals by Greenopolis Welfare Association and Safalta Goel |
|---|---|
| Citation | 2026 INSC 1070 (Reportable) |
| Case numbers | Civil Appeal Nos. 6792-6806 of 2023; Contempt Petition (C) Nos. 249-253 of 2025 |
| Bench | Justice P.S. Narasimha and Justice Alok Aradhe |
| Date of judgment | 30 September 2026 |
| Impugned | NCLAT judgment in Comp. App. (AT) (Ins) No. 444 of 2022 and connected appeals |
| Result | Appeals partly allowed; CIRP No. IB-2721/ND/2019 restored; NCLT to decide on continuation |
Facts of the Case
Orris owns 47.218 acres in Sector 89, Gurgaon. In 2011 it entered into a development agreement with Three C Shelters (the corporate debtor) to build Greenopolis, with flats shared 65:35. Tripartite buyer agreements in 2012-13 promised completion in 36 months plus a 6-month grace period. The project stalled. Straight Edge Contracts Pvt. Ltd., claiming to be an operational creditor, filed a Section 9 petition, which was admitted (CIRP No. IB-2721/ND/2019). The NCLT later found the initiation to be collusive and motivated by the interests of the developer’s suspended directors, and the NCLAT agreed. The disagreement was about what should follow from that finding.
Issue I: Power to Recall
The NCLT held there was no power to recall once the CIRP had started. The Supreme Court disagreed. Admission depends on jurisdictional facts set out in the application. A party invoking a statutory jurisdiction must not deceive the forum on those facts, because that would defeat the purpose of the Code. If such facts are later shown to be fraudulent and collusive, the Adjudicating Authority may recall the admission.
Issue II: Recall Does Not Mean Ending the CIRP
The NCLAT treated rejecting the Section 9 application as automatically ending the whole CIRP. The Supreme Court held this was wrong. Proceedings have two stages. Before admission, the applicant controls the case. After admission, the proceedings are in rem: control of the debtor vests in the RP and decisions rest with the RP and the CoC, subject to the Adjudicating Authority’s approval. The Code’s text and purpose allow the resolution process to continue even after a finding that the original application was fraudulent and collusive. The NCLT must weigh whether future proceedings can be conducted with integrity and confidence. It may also decide, for stated reasons, that continuation is not appropriate.
Principles Restated
- Fraud and collusion on jurisdictional facts allow the NCLT to recall admission of an application under Sections 7, 9 or 10.
- After admission, proceedings are in rem and all creditors are stakeholders.
- The original applicant cannot withdraw after admission (see Section 12A).
- A collusive applicant shall be excluded from participating, and Section 65 proceedings may be initiated.
- The NCLT may continue the CIRP in the larger interest after hearing the RP, the CoC and other stakeholders, and must ensure integrity and transparency.
Final Decision
Appeals partly allowed. The NCLAT judgment is set aside and CIRP No. IB-2721/ND/2019 is restored. The NCLT must decide whether to continue the CIRP in light of the finding of fraud and collusion, considering ownership of the Greenopolis project and hearing the RP, the CoC and other stakeholders, including homebuyers who have pursued other remedies. If it continues, it must conclude the process expeditiously. The contempt petitions are closed.
Analysis and Practical Points
- Homebuyers and genuine creditors: a collusive trigger no longer automatically wipes out a CIRP in which they have filed claims. They can argue for continuation.
- Promoters: a friendly operational creditor used to start insolvency risks Section 65 penalties without guaranteeing a favourable outcome.
- Landowners in joint developments: ownership of project land is a relevant factor in the NCLT’s decision on continuation.
- NCLTs: a finding of collusion is not the end of the inquiry. A reasoned decision on continuation must follow.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can the NCLT recall admission of a Section 9 petition?
Yes, if the jurisdictional facts on which it was admitted are proved to be fraudulent and collusive.
Does recall of admission end the CIRP automatically?
No. Since the CIRP is in rem after admission, the NCLT may continue it for other stakeholders after hearing the RP and the CoC, or end it for recorded reasons.
What happens to the collusive applicant?
It shall be excluded from the process, and proceedings under Section 65 IBC may be initiated against it.
What is the next step in the Greenopolis case?
The NCLT will decide whether to continue CIRP No. IB-2721/ND/2019 after hearing the RP, the CoC and homebuyers, and must act expeditiously.
This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Readers should refer to the certified copy of the judgment and consult a qualified professional before acting. See our Editorial Policy and Disclaimer.
