Insured Who Makes False Declarations Forfeits the Fire Claim: Supreme Court Sets Aside NCDRC’s Rs 2.40 Crore Award Against New India Assurance
In New India Assurance Co. Ltd. v. Hemkund Duplex and Board Pvt. Ltd., 2026 INSC 1023, the Supreme Court upheld an insurer’s rejection of a Rs 7.31 crore fire claim by a paper board maker. The National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission (NCDRC) had awarded Rs 2.40 crore with interest. The Supreme Court held that the insured’s Vice President and General Manager had falsely claimed that usable raw material was stored in the tin shed that burned. Workers and accountants said the shed held only old, unusable waste kept there since before 2005. That breached Policy Conditions 6 and 8, which require full and honest disclosure and forfeit all benefits for a false declaration. The insurer could therefore reject the whole claim.
Key Takeaways
- An insurer may reject a claim outright if the insured makes false statements to support it, in breach of the policy conditions on disclosure and false declarations.
- The NCDRC was wrong to disregard two surveyor reports without basis and to give the insured a clean chit on the delay in calling the fire brigade.
- Workers’ statements, which the insured never challenged, together with cobwebs on the burnt material, showed the shed held old scrap, not usable stock.
- Accounting irregularities pointed to inflated book stock: no stock register, arbitrary consumption figures, and a raw material to sales ratio that fell from 32.30% to 19.29%.
- The fire station was 6 to 7 km away but was told about the fire only an hour after it broke out.
- The insurer’s deposit of Rs 50 lakh and the amount in the suitors’ fund are to be returned with accrued interest.
Case Details at a Glance
| Case title | M/s. New India Assurance Company Ltd. v. M/s. Hemkund Duplex and Board Pvt. Ltd. |
|---|---|
| Citation | 2026 INSC 1023 (Reportable) |
| Case number | Civil Appeal No. 7221 of 2025 with Civil Appeal No. 11416 of 2025 |
| Bench | Justice Sanjay Kumar and Justice Sanjeev Sachdeva |
| Authored by | Justice Sanjay Kumar |
| Date of judgment | 21 September 2026 |
| Impugned order | NCDRC, Consumer Complaint No. 66 of 2011, 19 November 2024 |
| Result | Insurer’s appeal allowed; insured’s appeal for enhancement dismissed |
Facts of the Case
The insured took over a sick paper board unit at Najibabad in 2005. It had two fire policies with the appellant: Rs 13 crore for stock and Rs 14 crore for buildings, plant and machinery. On 7 May 2009 a fire broke out in the waste paper yard and damaged a tin shed and the material stored in it. The preliminary surveyor wanted a careful investigation to rule out a deliberate fire and tentatively assessed the loss at about Rs 56.47 lakh. An investigation agency could not find a cause for the fire. It noted that the shed was isolated, smoking was banned, the factory had a high boundary wall, there seemed to be no usable stock in the shed, and the fire station was called an hour late. The insurer rejected the claim on 28 June 2010, alleging manipulated accounts and false declarations.
What the NCDRC Held
The NCDRC held that because the cause of the fire was unknown, the insured did not have to prove the cause or that the fire was genuine. It found no deliberate delay in calling the fire brigade. It then assessed the loss itself and awarded Rs 2.40 crore with interest, Rs 3 lakh compensation for delay and Rs 1 lakh costs. Both sides appealed, the insured seeking more.
False Declarations Defeat the Claim
Policy Condition 6 required honest and full disclosure. Condition 8 forfeits all benefits if a claim is fraudulent or supported by a false declaration. The Court found clear breaches:
| Insured’s version | What the evidence showed |
|---|---|
| The Vice President and General Manager said unloaded raw material was stored in the tin shed | A supervisor said raw material went to the two pucca godowns and directly to the pulp section, never to the tin shed |
| The burnt stock was usable raw material | Workers and accountants said only segregated, unusable waste lay there, from before the 2005 takeover; the surveyor found the burnt material old and covered in cobwebs |
| Book stock reflected actual stock | No stock register, arbitrary consumption entries, “imaginary” yield, and a raw material to sales ratio that fell from 32.30% to 19.29% |
The insured did not challenge the workers’ evidence in its complaint. The Court said that, quite apart from the strong possibility that the fire was not accidental or was not genuinely fought, the rejection under Conditions 6 and 8 was clearly sustainable. The NCDRC had no basis to set aside the surveyors’ findings or to assess the loss at far more than the surveyors had.
Final Decision
Insurer’s appeal allowed. The NCDRC order of 19 November 2024 is set aside and the complaint fails. The insured’s appeal for higher compensation is dismissed. The Registry will return the insurer’s Rs 50 lakh deposit and the suitors’ fund amount with accrued interest. Parties bear their own costs.
Analysis and Practical Points
- Policyholders: every statement made to surveyors becomes evidence. One false statement about where stock was kept can forfeit the entire claim.
- Stock records: keep proper stock and stock-movement registers. Without them, book stock cannot support a loss claim.
- Consumer forums: surveyor reports are important evidence and need reasons to be set aside. An unknown cause of fire does not relieve the insured of proving a genuine loss.
- Insurers: independent statements from workers recorded during the survey can be decisive.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can an insurer reject a fire claim for false statements?
Yes. Where the insured makes false declarations to support the claim, in breach of the policy conditions, the insurer can reject it outright.
Why did the Supreme Court set aside the NCDRC award?
The NCDRC ignored two surveyor reports without basis, excused the delay in calling the fire brigade, and assessed the loss far above the surveyors’ figures.
What evidence showed the claim was false?
Unchallenged statements of workers and accountants that the burnt shed held only old unusable waste, the cobwebs on the material, and irregular stock records.
What happens to money deposited by the insurer?
The Rs 50 lakh deposit and the suitors’ fund amount are to be returned to the insurer with accrued interest.
This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Readers should refer to the certified copy of the judgment and consult a qualified professional before acting. See our Editorial Policy and Disclaimer.
