Skip to content
Arbitration · Section 37

Appellate Power Under Section 37 Cannot Be Handed to the Arbitral Tribunal: Supreme Court Sets Aside Direction Converting an Appeal Into a Section 17 Application

Section 37Section 9Section 17Arbitral TribunalInterim MeasuresJurisdiction

In Union of India v. Hariom Projects Pvt. Ltd., 2026 INSC 1044, the Supreme Court held that a High Court hearing an appeal under Section 37(1)(b) against the rejection of a Section 9 application cannot send those appellate proceedings to a later-constituted arbitral tribunal to be treated as a Section 17 application, even with the parties’ consent. Appellate jurisdiction belongs only to the “Court” defined in Section 2(1)(e). A tribunal acting under Section 17 has no appellate power over a court’s Section 9 order. At most, the High Court could have given the claimant liberty to approach the tribunal separately under Section 17.

Key Takeaways

  • The powers of an appellate court under Section 37 and of a tribunal under Section 17 differ in nature and source, and cannot be swapped by remitting the case.
  • Consent of the parties cannot give a tribunal appellate jurisdiction that the statute gives only to courts.
  • The correct course was to give liberty to apply afresh under Section 17 once the tribunal was constituted.
  • The prayer to stop termination had become infructuous once the work order was terminated on 3 January 2026. Further relief must be considered in light of later events.
  • The appointment of the arbitrator was not challenged and stands. The tribunal will decide all other disputes.

Case Details at a Glance

Case titleUnion of India & Others v. Hariom Projects Pvt. Ltd.
Citation2026 INSC 1044 (Reportable)
Case numberCivil Appeal arising out of SLP (C) No. 33087 of 2026
BenchJustice Aravind Kumar and Justice Prasanna B. Varale
Date of order18 September 2026
ImpugnedBombay High Court order of 13 January 2026
Advocates who arguedFor the Union of India: Shri Kanakamedala Ravindra Kumar, Additional Solicitor General
For the respondent: Shri Aditya Sondhi, Senior Advocate
ResultRemand direction set aside; appeal disposed of

Background

Hariom Projects held a contract for Phase-I administrative and training infrastructure at NDA Khadakwasla. After the Dispute Resolution Board rejected its claims, it invoked arbitration. The Union demanded recovery of about Rs 1.46 crore for alleged overpayment. The District Judge, Pune, dismissed the Section 9 application on 15 October 2025, and Hariom appealed under Section 37. The Union terminated the work order on 3 January 2026, and the High Court stayed the termination. On 13 January 2026, with the parties’ agreement, the High Court appointed a sole arbitrator and remitted the Section 37 proceedings to be treated as a Section 17 application.

Why the Remand Was Impermissible

The Union challenged only the remand, not the appointment. Counsel for Hariom fairly accepted that the remand could not be sustained. The Court held that the effect of the direction was to make the tribunal examine the subject matter of a statutory appeal, which is outside its jurisdiction.

Final Decision

Appeal disposed of. The direction remitting the Section 37 proceedings to the arbitral tribunal as a Section 17 application is set aside. As the tribunal is already handling the dispute and the parties signed a Supplementary Agreement on 24 April 2026, all other issues will be decided by the tribunal.

Analysis and Practical Points

  • Parties: once a tribunal is constituted, file a fresh Section 17 application rather than seeking transfer of the court proceedings.
  • Courts: a pending Section 37 appeal can be disposed of with liberty to approach the tribunal, but not converted.
  • Infructuous relief: an injunction against termination ends once termination happens. Seek fresh relief based on later events.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can a Section 37 appeal be transferred to the arbitral tribunal?

No. Appellate jurisdiction under Section 37 belongs only to the court.

Does consent of the parties make a difference?

No. Consent cannot give the tribunal appellate power over a court’s Section 9 order.

What could the High Court have done?

Given the claimant liberty to apply to the tribunal separately under Section 17.

Was the arbitrator’s appointment affected?

No. The appointment stands and the tribunal will decide all other disputes.

This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Readers should refer to the certified copy of the judgment and consult a qualified professional before acting. See our Editorial Policy and Disclaimer.