Section 96 CPC: Supreme Court Restores First Appeal in Will Dispute and Sets Aside High Court’s Adverse Remarks Against Trial Judge
In Lakshmi v. Gopi, 2026 INSC 709, a daughter challenged a registered will of 1999 by which her mother Thankam left property to her siblings. The Principal Sub Court, Thrissur decided the suit in 2019, and the Kerala High Court in first appeal reversed it while passing adverse remarks against the trial judge. The Supreme Court held that the first appellate court, as the final court of fact under Section 96 CPC, had to reappreciate the entire evidence, including suspicious circumstances around the will, and that serious remarks against judicial officers should not be made lightly. It restored the appeal for fresh hearing.
Key Takeaways
- The first appellate court is the final court of fact and must independently reappreciate evidence.
- Registration of a will does not by itself dispel suspicious circumstances.
- Non-examination of material witnesses to a will must be explained.
- Adverse remarks on the competence of judicial officers must not be passed lightly (K.G. Shanti, E. Koyakunju).
- The first appeal was restored with all contentions open.
Case Details at a Glance
| Case title | Lakshmi v. Gopi and Others |
|---|---|
| Citation | 2026 INSC 709 (Reportable) |
| Case number | Civil Appeal arising out of SLP (C) No. 9510 of 2023 |
| Bench | Justice Sanjay Karol and Justice Vipul M. Pancholi |
| Authored by | Justice Sanjay Karol |
| Date of judgment | 15 July 2026 |
| Impugned order | Kerala High Court judgment dated 30.11.2022 in RFA No. 298 of 2019 |
| Law involved | Section 96 CPC; proof of wills; suspicious circumstances; adverse remarks against judicial officers |
| Counsel who argued | Learned counsel for the appellant; Learned counsel for the respondents; Names of counsel are not recorded in the judgment |
| Result | Appeal allowed; High Court judgment and direction against trial judge set aside; first appeal restored |
Facts of the Case
Thankam died on 27.08.2011. The defendants relied on a registered will dated 22.03.1999 bequeathing her property to four of her children. The plaintiff, unaware of it, sued in O.S. No. 156 of 2015.
The trial court decided on 18.02.2019; the High Court reversed on 30.11.2022 and directed action concerning the trial judge.
Timeline of Proceedings
- 22.03.1999Will registered.
- 27.08.2011Testatrix dies.
- 18.02.2019Trial court decree.
- 30.11.2022High Court reverses.
- 15.07.2026Supreme Court restores appeal.
Issues Before the Supreme Court
- Was the first appeal decided in accordance with Section 96 CPC?
- Were the remarks against the trial judge justified?
Arguments and Counsel
Appellant
The High Court did not reappreciate evidence and wrongly criticised the trial judge.
Respondents
The will was registered and duly proved.
Supreme Court’s Ruling
1. Section 96 duty
Independent reappreciation of evidence was required.
2. Remarks set aside
Adverse direction against the trial judge quashed.
3. Restored
First appeal to be heard afresh.
Final Decision
Appeal allowed. The High Court judgment and its direction against the Principal Sub Judge, Thrissur were set aside. RFA No. 298 of 2019 was restored for fresh hearing with all contentions open.
Precedents Relied On
| Case | Principle applied |
|---|---|
| K.G. Shanti v. United India Insurance Co., (2021) 5 SCC 511 | Restraint in adverse remarks |
| S.K. Viswambaran v. E. Koyakunju, (1987) 2 SCC 109 | Remarks on judicial officers |
Analysis and Practical Points
The ruling protects trial judges from unwarranted strictures and reminds first appellate courts of their full fact-finding duty.
- Litigants: Insist on full reappreciation in first appeals.
- High Courts: Use restraint in remarks on subordinate judges.
- Propounders of wills: Examine all material witnesses.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the role of a first appellate court?
It is the final court of fact and must reappreciate evidence, per 2026 INSC 709.
Were the remarks against the trial judge sustained?
No, they were set aside.
What happens next?
The High Court will hear the first appeal afresh.
This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Readers should refer to the certified copy of the judgment and consult a qualified professional before acting. See our Editorial Policy and Disclaimer.
