Abatement of Appeal: Supreme Court Upholds Substitution of Legal Representatives Despite 501-Day Delay, Based on Later Knowledge, With Costs
In Bishen Prasad Tiwari v. Sheela Devi, 2026 INSC 760, an application to set aside abatement and substitute the legal heirs of a deceased appellant was filed 501 days late without a separate application under Section 5 of the Limitation Act. The Supreme Court, stressing that procedure is the handmaiden of justice but cannot be ignored, disagreed with the High Court’s reasoning. However, it found that the heirs came to know of the need much later, after the second appeal was disposed of in 2016, and acted within about two months, so it upheld the directions on its own reasoning with costs.
Key Takeaways
- Section 5 of the Limitation Act applies to applications under Order XXII Rule 9(2) by virtue of Rule 9(3).
- Procedure is the handmaiden of justice but cannot be ignored altogether.
- Delay may be condoned where knowledge of the need to substitute arose later and was not controverted.
- Courts must give proper reasons when condoning long delays.
- Costs of Rs 25,000 were imposed as a condition.
Case Details at a Glance
| Case title | Bishen Prasad Tiwari v. Sheela Devi |
|---|---|
| Citation | 2026 INSC 760 (Reportable) |
| Case number | Civil Appeal arising out of SLP (C) No. 28454 of 2024 |
| Bench | Justice J.B. Pardiwala and Justice K. Vinod Chandran |
| Authored by | Order of the Bench |
| Date of judgment | 17 July 2026 |
| Impugned order | High Court judgment directing substitution of legal representatives and restoration of the first appeal |
| Law involved | Order XXII Rules 3 and 9, CPC; Section 5, Limitation Act, 1963; setting aside abatement |
| Counsel who argued | Sri Mahabir, Advocate, for the appellant; Ms. Soumya Chakraborti, Senior Advocate, for the respondent |
| Result | Appeal disposed of; substitution and restoration upheld on different reasoning with Rs 25,000 costs |
Facts of the Case
A first appellant died and his legal representatives applied to set aside abatement and be substituted after 501 days, without a separate condonation application.
The second appeal was disposed of on 13.06.2016 directing the parties to approach the appellate court, which they did on 23.08.2016.
Timeline of Proceedings
- 2015Earlier knowledge disputed.
- 13.06.2016Second appeal disposed of.
- 23.08.2016LRs approach appellate court.
- 17.07.2026Supreme Court upholds substitution.
Issues Before the Supreme Court
- Was the delay in setting aside abatement rightly condoned?
Arguments and Counsel
Appellant (Sri Mahabir)
No Section 5 application was filed and the delay was unexplained.
Respondent (Ms. Soumya Chakraborti, Sr. Adv.)
The heirs acted promptly once they knew; substantial justice required substitution.
Supreme Court’s Ruling
1. Reasoning disapproved
High Court dealt with the matter casually.
2. Later knowledge
Heirs acted within about two months of knowledge.
3. Costs
Rs 25,000 as condition.
Final Decision
Appeal disposed of. The operative directions restoring the appeal and impleading the legal representatives of the deceased first appellant were upheld on the Supreme Court’s reasoning, subject to payment of Rs 25,000 costs. Copies to all High Courts.
Precedents Relied On
| Case | Principle applied |
|---|---|
| Order XXII Rule 9(3), CPC | Applicability of Section 5 Limitation Act |
Analysis and Practical Points
Parties should file formal condonation applications with abatement petitions; courts will still examine knowledge-based explanations.
- Legal representatives: Apply promptly with a Section 5 application.
- Courts: Record reasons for condoning delay.
- Opponents: Contest the knowledge claim with evidence.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does Section 5 Limitation Act apply to setting aside abatement?
Yes, under Order XXII Rule 9(3), as noted in 2026 INSC 760.
Why was the 501-day delay accepted?
Knowledge arose later and was not controverted.
Were costs imposed?
Yes, Rs 25,000.
This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Readers should refer to the certified copy of the judgment and consult a qualified professional before acting. See our Editorial Policy and Disclaimer.
