Skip to content
Criminal Law · Discharge

Soured Relationship Cannot Retrospectively Become Rape: Supreme Court Discharges Man After Woman Knew of His Earlier Marriage Yet Cohabited for Seven Years

In Santhosh Kumar N.P. v. State, Kadirur Police, 2026 INSC 1179, a Bench of Justice B.V. Nagarathna and Justice R. Mahadevan discharged a man facing trial in Kerala for rape, cheating, deceitful marriage and bigamy under Sections 376, 420, 493, 494 and 495 IPC. The complainant alleged that he posed as a bachelor, married her at a temple in Mysuru in 1996 and lived with her until 2003. The Court found that she had learnt of his existing marriage and two children from his brother within six months, yet continued the relationship for seven years. Consent given with that knowledge was not consent under a misconception of fact; there was no valid marriage, no deceit about it, and no delivery of property for cheating. Warning against a ‘worrying trend’ of converting failed relationships into criminal cases, the Court set aside the orders of the trial court and Kerala High Court refusing discharge.

Key Takeaways

  • Consent to a sexual relationship is not vitiated under Section 376 where the woman knew of the man’s subsisting marriage and continued the relationship.
  • Regret after a relationship ends cannot retrospectively convert past consensual intimacy into rape.
  • Section 493 IPC requires deceit inducing a belief of lawful marriage and cohabitation on that belief; knowledge of the earlier marriage defeats it.
  • Sections 494 and 495 need a second marriage in law; a temple ritual without proof of the essential ceremonies does not prima facie establish one.
  • Cheating under Section 420 requires inducement to deliver property or deal with a valuable security; deceit alone is not enough.
  • Discharge must be granted where the material, taken at face value, does not make out the offence (Prafulla Kumar Samal, Sajjan Kumar).

Case Details at a Glance

Case titleSanthosh Kumar N.P. v. State, Station House Officer, Kadirur Police, Tellicherry & Anr.
Citation2026 INSC 1179 (Reportable)
Case numberCriminal Appeals arising out of SLP (Crl.) Nos. 10173-10174 of 2025
BenchJustice B.V. Nagarathna and Justice R. Mahadevan
Authored byJustice B.V. Nagarathna
Date of judgment30 October 2026
Offences allegedSections 376, 420, 493, 494 and 495 IPC
Impugned orderKerala High Court order dated 21.05.2025
ResultAppeals allowed; appellant discharged

Facts of the Case

The complainant, a divorcee, alleged that the appellant represented himself as a bachelor, married her at a temple in Mysuru in 1996 and lived with her as husband and wife until 2003. In 2008 she filed domestic violence proceedings, during which he disclosed his earlier marriage; those proceedings were dismissed for lack of proof of marriage.

A first private complaint for rape, cheating and bigamy was dismissed for non-prosecution in 2011. A second, similar complaint was referred to police under Section 156(3) CrPC and an FIR registered. The trial court refused discharge in 2015, and the Kerala High Court dismissed his revision in 2025.

Timeline of Proceedings

  • 1996Alleged temple marriage at Mysuru; cohabitation begins.
  • 1996Complainant learns of earlier marriage from appellant’s brother.
  • 2003Relationship ends.
  • 2008Domestic violence complaint filed; later dismissed.
  • 04.04.2011First private complaint dismissed for non-prosecution.
  • 2011Second complaint leads to FIR at Kadirur.
  • 09.01.2015Trial court refuses discharge.
  • 21.05.2025Kerala High Court dismisses revision.
  • 30.10.2026Supreme Court discharges appellant.

Issues Before the Supreme Court

  1. Was consent to the relationship vitiated by misconception of fact about marriage?
  2. Were the ingredients of Sections 420, 493, 494 and 495 IPC prima facie made out?

Supreme Court’s Ruling

1. Rape: no misconception of fact

The complainant admitted learning of the earlier marriage within months. It was untenable that she continued to believe herself his legal wife for seven years. A relationship turning acrimonious cannot convert earlier consent into rape; that would put the cart before the horse.

2. A worrying trend

The Court distinguished consent built entirely on deceit from regret over past consent after a relationship ends. Treating the latter as rape would deny the man any right to withdraw from a relationship. Rape must be reserved for genuine cases of absent consent.

3. Deceitful marriage and bigamy

There was no prima facie valid marriage: the complainant could not name the temple, and there was no proof of essential ceremonies. IVF documents and joint accounts showed a long relationship, not a marriage. Knowing of the earlier marriage, she could not have cohabited believing herself lawfully married.

4. Cheating

No property was delivered and no valuable security made or altered, so Section 420 was not attracted.

“Criminal law cannot be used as munitions to settle personal scores, exact revenge or coerce an individual to act in any particular way.” – Supreme Court, 2026 INSC 1179, para 60

Result

The orders of the trial court and the High Court were set aside, the discharge application allowed, and the appellant discharged of all offences.

Analysis and Practical Points

The ruling continues the Supreme Court’s line against prosecuting long consensual relationships as rape on a false promise of marriage, and extends it to bigamy and deceitful marriage charges.

  • Defence: seek discharge early, using the complainant’s own statements about when she knew the true facts and how long the relationship continued.
  • Complainants: genuine cases of concealed marriage remain protected, but the deceit must be shown by evidence, not moral presumption.
  • Courts: discharge cannot be refused merely because some material exists; the material must, taken at face value, disclose the ingredients.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is a relationship that ends after promise of marriage automatically rape?

No. In 2026 INSC 1179 the Supreme Court held that regret after a consensual relationship ends does not convert past consent into rape.

Does knowledge of the man's earlier marriage matter?

Yes. If the woman knew of the subsisting marriage and continued the relationship, consent is not under a misconception of fact.

What must be proved for Section 493 IPC?

Deceit causing a woman not lawfully married to believe she is his lawful wife, and cohabitation on that belief.

When must a court discharge an accused?

When the material, taken at face value, does not disclose the ingredients of the offence or raise grave suspicion against the accused.

This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Readers should refer to the certified copy of the judgment and consult a qualified professional before acting. See our Editorial Policy and Disclaimer.