Skip to content
Service Law · Recruitment

Supreme Court Upholds Written Exam Added Midway in Nagaland Excise Constable Recruitment

In T. Akon Phom and others v. State of Nagaland and others, 2026 INSC 1211, the Supreme Court dismissed an appeal by unsuccessful candidates who challenged the introduction of a written examination, by corrigendum, after the advertisement for 46 Excise Constable posts had been issued. With 11,521 applications and 2,297 candidates clearing the physical test, the Court held that an objective Class VIII-level written test was a fair shortlisting tool and fell within ‘competitive examination/selection’ under the Nagaland Excise Service (Revised) Rules, 1999.

Key Takeaways

  • A written test based on the already-prescribed qualification standard is a ‘competitive examination/selection’ under Rule 5(i)(a) of the 1999 Rules; no consultation with the Commission under Rule 5(ii) was needed.
  • Where Rules do not prescribe a detailed method, the recruiting authority has discretion to devise selection and shortlisting procedures.
  • The advertisement itself empowered the Departmental Recruitment Board to issue corrigenda (Clause 15) and decide disputes finally (Clause 16).
  • An objective written test is fairer than relying heavily on a subjective viva-voce.
  • Candidates who took part in the process with knowledge of the change, and showed no prejudice, could not later call it arbitrary.
  • An unnotified 2016 departmental memorandum on physical standards did not bind the recruitment.

Case Details at a Glance

Case titleT. Akon Phom and others v. State of Nagaland and others
Citation2026 INSC 1211 (Reportable)
Case numberCivil Appeal No. 14203 of 2026 (arising out of SLP (C) No. 22477 of 2026)
CourtSupreme Court of India, Civil Appellate Jurisdiction
BenchJustice Prashant Kumar Mishra and Justice Shree Chandrashekhar
Authored byJustice Prashant Kumar Mishra
Date of judgment16 November 2026
RulesNagaland Excise Service (Revised) Rules, 1999 – Rules 5(i)(a), 5(ii), 7(1); Schedules II and III
Impugned orderGauhati High Court (Kohima Bench), Division Bench judgment dated 23.06.2026 in Writ Appeal No. 39/2025
ResultAppeal dismissed

Background

The Department of Excise and Prohibition, Government of Nagaland, advertised 40 posts of Excise Constable on 07.04.2025 for indigenous inhabitants of Nagaland, with Class VIII as the minimum qualification. Six more posts were added on 14.05.2025, making 46. Clause 4 of the advertisement described a two-stage process: a physical test and a suitability test/viva-voce.

On 04.06.2025, the Departmental Recruitment Board issued a corrigendum adding a written examination – 100 marks, multiple choice, Class VIII standard, no negative marking. The physical test was held in July 2025 and the written test on 09.08.2025.

The scale was striking: 11,521 applications for 46 posts, 5,985 candidates at the physical test, and 2,297 who qualified for the next stage.

Proceedings in the High Court

The single judge allowed the candidates’ writ petition on 16.10.2025. He held that while the Government could prescribe a method where the Rules were silent, it had to be stated in the original advertisement and could not be introduced midway. The corrigendum and the physical test were quashed.

The Division Bench permitted the process to continue pending appeal and, on 23.06.2026, allowed the State’s appeal. The select list of 46 candidates was notified on 29.06.2026, and all selected candidates had accepted by 08.07.2026, before the Supreme Court issued notice and granted stay on 07.07.2026.

Supreme Court’s Ruling

The process complied with the 1999 Rules

Rule 5(i)(a) provides for direct recruitment by ‘competitive examination/selection’, Rule 7(1) for a Selection Board, and Schedules II and III prescribe direct recruitment and the Class VIII qualification. A written test on the Class VIII syllabus fell squarely within competitive examination/selection. Rule 5(ii), which requires consultation with the Commission for a different method, was not attracted at all.

The 2016 Memorandum did not hold the field

The candidates relied on a Memorandum dated 19.07.2016 on physical and medical standards. The Court agreed with the Division Bench that it was neither confirmed by the Selection Board nor notified by the Government, had not been strictly followed in past recruitments, and at most prescribed minimum physical standards.

The Board was empowered to issue the corrigendum

The single judge himself had found the Departmental Recruitment Board validly constituted under Rule 7. Clause 15 of the advertisement allowed it to rectify omissions through notifications and addenda, and Clause 16 made its decisions on disputes final.

Objective test, no prejudice

The Court rejected the argument that the written test was arbitrary because it carried 100 marks against 12 for the viva-voce.

“...an objective written examination... provides a means of assessing candidates on a common basis...” – Supreme Court, 2026 INSC 1211, para 15

The corrigendum was widely publicised in local newspapers, all candidates who passed the physical test faced the same requirement, and the appellants – ten of whom took the written test – showed no discrimination or prejudice. The appeal was dismissed.

Analysis: The ‘Rules of the Game’ Argument

Candidates often argue that the selection criteria cannot be changed once the recruitment process has begun. This judgment shows the limits of that argument. The Court looked at three things: whether the statutory Rules permitted the method; whether the advertisement reserved power to modify the process; and whether the change was applied equally and openly, without prejudice to any candidate.

Because the written test did not raise the eligibility bar (it was set at the same Class VIII standard) and served as a shortlisting device in a massively oversubscribed recruitment, it did not alter the essential terms. The ruling is of practical value to State recruiting bodies facing huge applicant numbers, and a caution for candidates who participate in a changed process and challenge it only after failing.

The State also complained that the appellants did not disclose that the select list had been issued and did not implead the selected candidates. The Court did not need to decide that objection, having dismissed the appeal on merits.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can a written examination be introduced after the recruitment advertisement?

In 2026 INSC 1211 the Supreme Court upheld such a change where the Rules allowed competitive selection, the advertisement permitted corrigenda, the test matched the existing qualification standard, and it applied equally to all candidates.

Did the written test need consultation with the Commission?

No. The Court held it was a competitive examination/selection under Rule 5(i)(a), so Rule 5(ii) on adopting a different method was not attracted.

Can candidates who took part in the selection later challenge it?

The Court noted that the appellants participated knowing of the revised procedure and could not show any prejudice, which weighed against their challenge.

Is a written test fairer than a viva-voce?

The Court observed that an objective written test assesses candidates on a common basis and avoids disproportionate reliance on the subjective assessment of an interview.

This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Readers should refer to the certified copy of the judgment and consult a qualified professional before acting. See our Editorial Policy and Disclaimer.