Skip to content
Criminal Procedure · Disclosure

Inspect Now, Demand Specific Documents at Trial: Supreme Court Sets a Practical Route for Accused Seeking CBI’s Unrelied Documents

Section 91 CrPCUnrelied DocumentsSarla GuptaDebendra Nath PadhiInspectionFair Trial

In CBI v. Anil Dixit, 2026 INSC 1064, the Supreme Court addressed a common dispute at the stage of framing charges: an accused asks under Section 91 CrPC for documents the CBI seized but does not rely on. Rather than choose between Debendra Nath Padhi and Sarla Gupta, the Court started from the premise that the accused is entitled to the documents with the prosecution in order to shape his defence. It then set a practical procedure. The accused may inspect the voluminous unrelied material and identify specific documents in a signed note. The CBI must keep those ready and produce them at trial when the relevant witness is examined. Documents the CBI does not have can be obtained through RTI or defence witnesses.

Key Takeaways

  • The accused is entitled to documents with the prosecution to shape the defence. The real question is at what stage, and it depends on the specific documents.
  • Seizure memos must be supplied, and the CBI had supplied them.
  • Case diaries and source information were not pressed, and the accused gave an affidavit that he did not seek them.
  • Voluminous unrelied documents: allow inspection and record the specific documents in a writing signed by both sides, to be produced at trial.
  • Documents not with the CBI, such as minutes, videography or technical bids it never collected, cannot be ordered from it. The accused may obtain them through RTI or witnesses.
  • The orders under challenge were set aside so that the trial could proceed quickly.

Case Details at a Glance

Case titleCentral Bureau of Investigation v. Anil Dixit
Citation2026 INSC 1064 (Reportable)
Case numberCriminal Appeal No. 4618 of 2026 (@ SLP (Crl.) No. 17158 of 2026)
BenchJustice J.B. Pardiwala and Justice K. Vinod Chandran
Date of order25 September 2026
Trial courtSpecial Judge No. 1, CBI, Ranchi (orders of 21 September 2019 and 18 July 2022)
Advocates who arguedFor the appellant-CBI: Sri Suryaprakash V. Raju, Additional Solicitor General
For the respondent-accused: Sri Arvind Kumar Gupta, Senior Advocate
ResultOrders set aside; trial to proceed under the directions given

Facts of the Case

The case arises from CBI case RC No. 12A/2014-R at Ranchi, concerning the selection of architects and building designs. At the charge stage, the accused applied under Section 91 for ten categories of material. These included seizure memos, CBI registers, the source information report, all seized but unrelied documents, minutes of several Building Committee meetings, videography of evaluation meetings, technical bids and the appointment files of two architect firms named in the FIR but not charge-sheeted. The Special Judge allowed the application, and later orders and the High Court upheld that. The CBI challenged the direction to produce unrelied documents at this stage.

Padhi and Sarla Gupta

State of Orissa v. Debendra Nath Padhi, (2005) 1 SCC 568, said the accused’s right to seek orders under Section 91 ordinarily arises only at the defence stage. Sarla Gupta v. Directorate of Enforcement, (2025) 7 SCC 626, read Padhi as being about the “record of the case” under Section 227. It held that the accused is entitled to a list of unrelied documents at the charge stage but ordinarily not to copies. The Bench chose not to decide between the two and adopted a practical, document-by-document approach.

Item-Wise Directions

Documents soughtDirection
(a) Seizure memosAlready produced
(b)-(d) CBI registers and source informationNot pressed; not to be disclosed
(e) All seized but unrelied documentsInspection; specific documents identified in signed writing, kept ready and produced at trial when the relevant witness is examined
(f) Building Committee minutes other than the 11thIf found among seized records, can be sought at trial; if not with the CBI, the accused may obtain them by RTI or through a witness
(g)-(i) Videography, 21 January 2012 minutes, technical bidNot with the CBI; cannot be ordered from it
(j) Files of architect firms not charge-sheetedNot available with the CBI as material that would exculpate the accused; not ordered

Final Decision

Appeal disposed of. The orders of the Special Court and the High Court are set aside, and the trial court is to proceed in line with these directions so that the trial is not delayed.

Analysis and Practical Points

  • Defence counsel: ask for inspection of unrelied material early, and record the specific documents you want in a jointly signed note filed in court.
  • Prosecuting agencies: allow inspection of voluminous seized material and keep the identified files ready for trial. Refusing outright invites further litigation.
  • Documents never collected: courts will not order an agency to produce what it does not have. The defence must use other routes.
  • Open question: the tension between Padhi and Sarla Gupta remains unresolved, but this order offers a workable route in the meantime.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can an accused get documents the CBI seized but does not rely on?

Yes. The Court allowed inspection and production of specifically identified documents at the trial stage when the relevant witness is examined.

At what stage can Section 91 CrPC be used by the accused?

The Court did not settle the Padhi versus Sarla Gupta debate but held the stage depends on the specific documents; voluminous unrelied material can be inspected and produced at trial.

Must the CBI disclose source information?

The accused gave up that request, and the Court treated source information and internal registers as not liable to disclosure here.

What if the document is not with the CBI?

The accused may obtain it through the Right to Information Act or by examining a suitable defence witness.

This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Readers should refer to the certified copy of the judgment and consult a qualified professional before acting. See our Editorial Policy and Disclaimer.