Skip to content
Criminal Law · UAPA

Court Cannot Declare an Investigation Complete: Supreme Court Upholds Second UAPA Extension and Reverses Default Bail Granted by Bombay High Court

UAPA Section 43DDefault BailSection 167(2)Extension of TimeSanctionATS

In State of Maharashtra v. Momin Moiuddin Gulam Hasan, 2026 INSC 1021, the Supreme Court reversed default bail granted by the Bombay High Court to an accused in a UAPA case investigated by the Mumbai ATS. The High Court had held a second extension of 15 days to file the charge sheet illegal. It reasoned that the investigation was effectively complete and the time was really sought to obtain sanction. The Supreme Court held that the ATS needed time to analyse forensic data from seized phones and computers and money flows in bank accounts, which is part of investigation. Investigation is the police’s exclusive domain, and a court cannot declare it complete.

Key Takeaways

  • Section 43D of the UAPA modifies Section 167(2) CrPC, allowing the 90-day period to be extended up to 180 days on the Public Prosecutor’s report.
  • The Special Court may grant more than one extension within the 180-day ceiling.
  • Analysing data retrieved by forensic laboratories and tracing money flows is part of investigation and cannot be postponed until after the charge sheet.
  • A complete charge sheet is not a formality. Sanction under Section 45(2) UAPA depends on the material gathered in the investigation.
  • The High Court went off course in treating the extension as one sought only for sanction.
  • The surviving respondent must surrender within 30 days and may apply for regular bail. The co-accused died in April 2026.

Case Details at a Glance

Case titleThe State of Maharashtra & Anr. v. Momin Moiuddin Gulam Hasan @ Moin Mistri & Anr.
Citation2026 INSC 1021 (Reportable)
Case numberCriminal Appeal arising out of SLP (Crl.) No. 12932 of 2024
BenchJustice Prashant Kumar Mishra and Justice Shree Chandrashekhar
Authored byJustice Shree Chandrashekhar
Date of judgment21 September 2026
Impugned judgmentBombay High Court, Criminal Appeal No. 214 of 2023, 15 July 2024
ResultDefault bail set aside; respondent to surrender within 30 days

Facts and Timeline

  1. 21 September 2022FIR at ATS Police Station, Mumbai under Sections 120B, 121A, 153A IPC and Section 13(1)(b) UAPA.
  2. 22 September 2022The respondents are arrested; police custody extended until 8 October 2022, then judicial custody.
  3. 20 December 2022The 90-day period ends; on the Public Prosecutor’s application of 13 December, the Special Judge extends time by 30 days.
  4. 18 January 2023A second application seeks 15 more days; it is allowed. A default bail plea filed the same day is rejected as premature.
  5. 20 January 2023Second default bail application (Exhibit 44) dismissed.
  6. 15 July 2024High Court holds the second extension illegal and grants default bail.
  7. 21 September 2026Supreme Court reverses.

What the High Court Held

The High Court read the second extension application as seeking time to obtain sanction for prosecution, as if the investigation were complete and a charge sheet ready. On that view, the extension was not justified, an indefeasible right to default bail had accrued, and the respondents were entitled to release.

Why the Supreme Court Reversed

Relying on King Emperor v. Khawaja Nazir Ahmad and State of Bihar v. J.A.C. Saldanha, the Court held that investigation is the exclusive domain of the police. It is not for courts to decide when it should end, except in exceptional cases or where the law bars it. The police’s duty ends when a final report is filed under Section 173(2), subject to further investigation under Section 173(8).

The prosecution had specifically said it needed time to analyse data from phones, computers and other devices, and money flows in bank accounts, to link the accused to terrorist activity. That analysis is investigation and cannot be done after the charge sheet. A complete charge sheet is also essential because sanction under Section 45(2) UAPA depends on the material collected, considered by an independent authority. The Court said it was imaginary to think the investigation was complete. The High Court’s discussion of sanction was beside the point.

Final Decision

State’s appeal allowed. The Bombay High Court judgment of 15 July 2024 is set aside. The Special Judge’s order of 18 January 2023 granting the second extension is upheld, and the default bail application (Exhibit 44) is dismissed. Respondent No. 1 must surrender within 30 days and may seek regular bail.

Analysis and Practical Points

  • Prosecutors: extension reports should set out the specific pending investigative steps, such as forensic analysis and financial trails, not just the need for sanction.
  • Defence: challenge extensions sought only for administrative steps. Where real investigation is pending, default bail arguments are weak.
  • Multiple extensions: the 180-day ceiling under UAPA can be reached through successive extensions, if each is justified.
  • After the BNSS: the same principles apply to Section 187 BNSS read with Section 43D UAPA.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the maximum time to file a charge sheet under UAPA?

Ninety days, which the court may extend up to 180 days on the Public Prosecutor’s report under Section 43D(2) UAPA.

Can a court grant more than one extension under UAPA?

Yes. The Supreme Court upheld a second extension of 15 days after an earlier 30-day extension, within the 180-day ceiling.

Is forensic data analysis part of investigation?

Yes. The Court held that analysing seized electronic data and money flows is investigation and cannot wait until after the charge sheet.

Can a court declare an investigation complete?

No. Investigation is the exclusive domain of the police, and courts cannot decide when it should stop, save in exceptional cases.

This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Readers should refer to the certified copy of the judgment and consult a qualified professional before acting. See our Editorial Policy and Disclaimer.