Skip to content
Religious Endowments · Property

State Is Custodian, Not Owner, of Temple Property: Supreme Court Declares Gift of Temple Inam Land to Tamil Nadu Government Void, Enhances Rent and Imposes Costs

TN HR and CE Act 1959Section 41Inam LandTemple PropertyRegistration Act Section 22-AFair Rent

In K. Ramalingam & Ors. v. Government of Tamil Nadu & Ors., 2026 INSC 1144, the Supreme Court declared void a 2017 gift deed by which a temporary trustee of the Nagapalayam Mariamman-Ponnachiamman Temple in Kodumudi, Erode district, gifted 1 acre 10 cents of the temple’s inam land to the Tamil Nadu Government for a Taluk office. The Court held the gift void under Section 41(1) of the Tamil Nadu Hindu Religious and Charitable Endowments Act, 1959 and its registration of no effect under Section 22-A of the Registration Act. Since the Taluk office had already been built with public funds, the Court allowed the State to continue as lessee, but more than doubled the rent to Rs 31,000 per month from March 2019, ordered payment of arrears, and imposed costs of Rs 1 lakh on the State for defending the transaction for years.

Key Takeaways

  • The State acts as custodian and regulator of temple properties under the 1959 Act, not their owner.
  • A gift or settlement of temple inam land is null and void under Section 41(1); registration cannot validate what another statute declares void.
  • Even under Section 34, a gift without the Commissioner’s sanction and Government approval would be void.
  • Trustees, permanent or temporary, must act with the prudence of an ordinary man under Sections 27 and 28; a gratuitous transfer can never meet that standard.
  • The Government’s lease continues, but rent is fixed at Rs 31,000 per month from 08.03.2019, to be revised every three years under Section 34-A.
  • The State must pay arrears within three months and Rs 1 lakh costs to the temple within eight weeks.
  • General directions require strict compliance with Sections 34, 34-A and 41 before any alienation or lease of temple property.

Case Details at a Glance

Case titleK. Ramalingam and Others v. Government of Tamil Nadu and Others
Citation2026 INSC 1144 (Reportable)
Case numberCivil Appeals arising from SLP (C) Nos. 20051–20052 of 2019
BenchJustice P.S. Narasimha and Justice Alok Aradhe
Authored byJustice Alok Aradhe
Date of judgment16 October 2026
Impugned orderMadras High Court, 19 March 2019, in W.P. No. 7075 of 2019
Property1 acre 10 cents, S. Nos. 36/4, 36/5 and 41/2, Kodumudi Village, Erode (inam land under Inam Title Deed No. 388)
ResultAppeals allowed; gift deed void; rent enhanced; costs on State

Facts of the Case

On 30 August 2017, the Tehsildar certified a person as trustee of the temple for registering a deed, and on the same day that temporary trustee executed a gift deed in favour of the Government of Tamil Nadu for constructing a Taluk office. A writ petition by villagers was withdrawn, and the hereditary trustee’s writ petition was dismissed by the Madras High Court in March 2019 on the reasoning that Section 34 of the 1959 Act does not mention gifts and that title raised disputed facts. Devotees of the temple obtained permission to file special leave petitions.

For years the State defended the gift, mutated the land as “Sarkar Poramboke” and built the Taluk office. Only after the Supreme Court, on 21 February 2022, required the Secretary in charge of Endowments to state on affidavit whether a trustee can gift temple property did the State concede that the land was inam land of the temple, that Section 41 prohibits its gift, and that the Revenue Department would hold it as a lessee at a fair rent of Rs 13,235 per month.

Timeline of Proceedings

  • 30.08.2017Gift deed executed and registered in favour of the State.
  • 08.03.2019Land handed over for construction of Taluk office.
  • 19.03.2019Madras High Court dismisses hereditary trustee’s writ petition.
  • 19.08.2019Devotees permitted to file SLPs.
  • 23.03.2022State files affidavit conceding the land belongs to the temple.
  • 16.10.2026Supreme Court declares gift void.

Issues Before the Supreme Court

  1. Can a temporary trustee gift temple inam land to the State Government?
  2. What is the effect of registration of such a gift?
  3. What relief should follow when a public building has already been constructed on the land?

Gift void under Section 41 and Section 34

The State’s own affidavit treated the land as inam land, governed by Section 41, which declares gifts and settlements of such land null and void; Section 34(5) excludes inam lands from Section 34. The Court held that registration under the Registration Act cannot cure an alienation that the governing statute declares void, especially as Section 22-A of the Registration Act, as applicable in Tamil Nadu, bars such registration. Even on the alternative view that Section 34 applied, no sanction of the Commissioner after publication and objections, and no prior Government approval, was obtained, so the gift would still be void.

Limits on a trustee’s authority

Sections 27 and 28 require every trustee to administer the institution’s property as carefully as a man of ordinary prudence would manage his own. A gift, being a transfer without consideration, can never meet that standard and confers no benefit on the temple. A Revenue functionary’s acceptance of temple land as a gift, however laudable the public purpose, offends the object of the 1959 Act.

A temple property is held for the deity and not for gratuitous disposal by whoever happens to hold the office of trustee, however well-intentioned.– Supreme Court, 2026 INSC 1144

Conduct of the State

The Court recorded that, even though the HR and CE Department had earlier stated on affidavit that the property belonged to the deity, the Revenue Department mutated the land, built on it and defended the gift before the High Court and the Supreme Court, including in a 2019 counter affidavit claiming absolute vesting. The State changed its stand only after the Court’s 2022 order. For over four years, temple property was treated as Government property on the strength of a deed the State itself later admitted had no legal sanction.

How the fair rent was fixed

Applying the Fair Rent Committee’s formula and G.O.(MS) No. 200 dated 2 November 2018 (valuing land made over to Government at 225 percent of guideline or market value, whichever is higher), the Court took the market value of adjoining land at Rs 167 per sq. ft., applied 225 percent (Rs 375.75 per sq. ft.) to 47,916 sq. ft. to arrive at Rs 1,80,04,437, added the depreciated building value of Rs 1,24,33,603, and applied 0.1 percent to the total of Rs 3,04,38,040. The resulting Rs 30,438 was rounded up to Rs 31,000 per month.

Final Decision

Appeals allowed. The High Court order is set aside. The Court declared that (i) the land is inam property vested in the temple; (ii) the gift deed dated 30.08.2017 is null and void under Section 41(1), and its registration, contrary to Section 22-A of the Registration Act, has no legal effect; (iii) the Government’s lease will not be annulled and, if expired, shall be renewed, but rent stands enhanced to Rs 31,000 per month from 08.03.2019, to be re-fixed every three years under Section 34-A and never below that amount, with the terms decided by the temple trust; (iv) arrears must be paid within three months; (v) the State must pay Rs 1,00,000 as costs to the temple within eight weeks; and (vi) authorities must strictly follow Sections 34, 34-A and 41 in future.

Precedents Relied On

CasePrinciple applied
Edukanti Kistamma v. S. Venkatareddy, (2010) 1 SCC 756Protection of endowment property
A.A. Gopalakrishnan v. Cochin Devaswom Board, (2007) 7 SCC 482Duty of courts and trustees to protect temple properties

Analysis and Practical Points

The judgment is a strong statement of fiduciary limits on governments and trustees managing religious endowments:

  • Governments: public purpose does not justify acquiring temple land by gift; acquisition or lease must follow the statute, with fair value to the institution.
  • Trustees: temporary or hereditary trustees cannot gift endowment property; doing so exposes the transaction to being declared void.
  • Registrars: Section 22-A of the Registration Act (Tamil Nadu) bars registration of such void alienations.
  • Devotees: the case confirms that devotees can pursue protection of temple property even when the trustee does not.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can a temple trustee gift temple land to the Government?

No. The Supreme Court held that a gift of temple inam land is void under Section 41(1) of the Tamil Nadu HR and CE Act, and a trustee’s duty of prudence rules out gratuitous transfers.

Does registration make such a gift valid?

No. Registration cannot validate what the governing statute declares void, and Section 22-A of the Registration Act as applicable in Tamil Nadu bars such registration.

Did the Government have to vacate the land?

No. Because a Taluk office was already built with public funds, the Court continued the lease but enhanced rent to Rs 31,000 per month from 8 March 2019.

Why were costs imposed on the State?

The State accepted the gift and defended it for years before conceding in 2022 that it was invalid, despite being the statutory custodian of temple property.

How often will the rent be revised?

Every three years under Section 34-A of the 1959 Act, and never below Rs 31,000 per month.

This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Readers should refer to the certified copy of the judgment and consult a qualified professional before acting. See our Editorial Policy and Disclaimer.