Daughter’s Suit to Set Aside 1974 Gift Deed to Father Barred by Limitation: Supreme Court Says Stopping Gifts in 1995 Gave No Fresh Cause of Action
In D. Kalidasreddy v. Chennamma (K. Bharathi), 2026 INSC 1209, the Supreme Court set aside concurrent decrees of three courts in Andhra Pradesh and dismissed a daughter’s 1997 suit to cancel a gift deed she executed in favour of her father in December 1974, shortly before her marriage. She alleged undue influence and that her father had promised not to remarry and to safeguard the property, but later remarried and, from 1995, stopped sharing produce with her. The courts below held limitation ran from 1995. The Supreme Court held that the suit was governed by Article 59 of the Limitation Act (three years from knowledge), not Article 65, as an undue-influence gift is voidable; she knew the nature of the deed and came out of her father’s influence on marriage in 1975; the absolute gift created no trust; and a later breach of promise is not fraud.
Key Takeaways
- A gift procured by undue influence is voidable, not void; a suit to set it aside is governed by Article 59 (three years), not Article 65.
- Limitation runs from when the plaintiff knew the true nature of the instrument, not from when she escaped the influence (Ningawwa v. Byrappa).
- An absolute gift with no obligations on the donee creates no trust, so Section 10 of the Limitation Act does not apply.
- Fraud must have a nexus with conduct before the transaction; a later breach of promise is not fraud (Reliance Salt v. Cosmos Enterprises).
- A father stopping gifts to his daughter does not create a fresh cause of action to set aside a 1974 gift.
- Possession cannot be granted unless the voidable gift is first set aside within limitation.
Case Details at a Glance
| Case title | D. Kalidasreddy & Anr. v. Chennamma (K. Bharathi) |
|---|---|
| Citation | 2026 INSC 1209 (Reportable) |
| Case number | Civil Appeal arising out of SLP (C) No. 19254 of 2026 |
| Bench | Justice Manoj Misra and Justice Manmohan |
| Date of order | 29 October 2026 |
| Suit | O.S. No. 359 of 1997, filed 30.08.1997, to set aside gift deed dated 19.12.1974 |
| Impugned judgment | Andhra Pradesh High Court judgment dated 08.04.2026 in S.A. No. 611 of 2006 |
| Result | Appeal allowed; suit dismissed as time-barred |
Facts of the Case
The plaintiff inherited the suit properties from her mother along with her sisters, who later gifted their shares to her in 1974. While still in her father’s care and before her marriage in February 1975, she gifted the properties to him by a deed of 19 December 1974. She claimed this was done under his influence, on assurances that he would stay unmarried and protect the property. He secretly remarried. She said that until 1995 he remained affectionate and shared produce and gifts, but then shifted towards his second family and planned to sell the property. She sent notice in February 1997 and sued in August 1997.
The trial court found undue influence and held the suit within time from 1995. The first appellate court, noting the father did not testify, and the High Court in second appeal, affirmed. The father’s successors appealed.
Timeline of Proceedings
- 19.12.1974Gift deed executed by daughter in favour of father.
- February 1975Daughter marries.
- 1995Father allegedly stops sharing produce.
- 30.08.1997Suit filed.
- 08.04.2026High Court dismisses second appeal.
- 29.10.2026Supreme Court dismisses the suit as time-barred.
Issues Before the Supreme Court
- Which Article of the Limitation Act governs a suit to set aside a gift for undue influence?
- When does limitation start, and was the 1997 suit within time?
Supreme Court’s Ruling
1. No trust was created
The gift deed conveyed the property absolutely, out of love and affection, with no obligation on the donee to safeguard it or share income. No trust arose, so Section 10 of the Limitation Act did not help.
2. Article 59, not Article 65
Even on the plaint case, the gift was voidable, not void. Unless set aside, possession cannot be granted. The suit is therefore governed by Article 59: three years from when the facts entitling cancellation first became known.
3. Limitation expired long before 1997
The plaint itself showed she was conscious of her father’s influence when executing the deed, and the courts below found she understood the transaction. Under Ningawwa, time runs from knowledge of the instrument’s nature; in any event she left his influence on marriage in 1975.
4. No fraud
There was no specific pleading of suppression at the time of the gift. A later breach of an alleged promise not to remarry is not fraud, and stopping gifts in 1995 created no cause of action.
“Hence, in our view, the courts below committed manifest error in holding that the period of limitation for instituting the suit to rescind the Gift would commence from the date when the defendant stopped sharing the profits.” – Supreme Court, 2026 INSC 1209, para 21
Result
The appeal was allowed, the decrees of all three courts set aside, and the plaintiff’s suit dismissed as barred by limitation.
Analysis and Practical Points
The judgment shows that concurrent findings of undue influence do not survive if the suit is out of time, and limitation is a question the Supreme Court will examine afresh.
- Persons challenging gifts or sale deeds: sue within three years of knowing the nature of the document; later estrangement does not restart time.
- Pleadings: plead specific facts of fraud at the time of the transaction; later breaches of promise do not qualify.
- Defendants: raise limitation at every stage; it can defeat the suit even after findings on merits.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the limitation period to set aside a gift deed?
Three years under Article 59 of the Limitation Act, from when the facts entitling the plaintiff to have it set aside first became known. In 2026 INSC 1209 the Supreme Court applied Article 59.
Does Article 65 apply to a suit for possession after a gift?
Not where the gift is voidable, for example for undue influence. It must first be set aside within Article 59's period.
When does limitation start in undue influence cases?
From when the person knew the true nature of the instrument, not from when the influence ended, following Ningawwa v. Byrappa.
Is breaking a promise made at the time of a gift fraud?
Not by itself. Fraud must relate to conduct before the transaction; a later breach of promise does not vitiate it.
This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Readers should refer to the certified copy of the judgment and consult a qualified professional before acting. See our Editorial Policy and Disclaimer.
