Skip to content
Constitutional Law · Election Commission

Divided Bench Sends Challenge to Election Commissioners Appointment Act 2023 Towards a Constitution Bench, Urges a Permanent 5-Judge Bench

CEC Act 2023Section 7Article 324Article 145(3)Anoop BaranwalConstitution Bench

In Dr. Jaya Thakur v. Union of India, 2026 INSC 1040, a two-Judge Bench hearing challenges to the Chief Election Commissioner and other Election Commissioners (Appointment, Conditions of Service and Term of Office) Act, 2023 disagreed on one preliminary question: should the case go to a Constitution Bench? Justice Dipankar Datta rejected the Union’s request for a reference. In his view the law in Anoop Baranwal was settled and only needed to be applied. Justice Satish Chandra Sharma held that the challenge to Sections 7, 6 and 8 raises a substantial question of constitutional interpretation that must go to a Constitution Bench under Article 145(3). In a joint order, both judges sent the papers to the Chief Justice to consider constituting a Constitution Bench. They also asked him to explore setting up a permanent 5-Judge Bench for constitutional questions.

Key Takeaways

  • Section 7 of the 2023 Act provides a Selection Committee of the Prime Minister, the Leader of Opposition and a Union Cabinet Minister nominated by the Prime Minister. It is the main provision under challenge.
  • Sections 6 (Search Committee headed by the Law Minister) and 8(2) (Selection Committee may consider persons outside the panel) are also challenged.
  • The Attorney General and Solicitor General asked for a reference partway through the hearing. The petitioners called this a delaying tactic.
  • Justice Datta held that free and fair elections and insulating the ECI from exclusive executive control are settled law, so only their application remained.
  • Justice Sharma held that the challenge raises a question not decided before and that Anoop Baranwal was an interim arrangement.
  • Rather than refer the disagreement to three Judges, the Bench placed the matter before the Chief Justice directly and flagged references that have stayed pending for years.

Case Details at a Glance

Case titleDr. Jaya Thakur & Ors. v. Union of India & Anr., with connected petitions by Gopal Singh, Naman Shrestha, Association for Democratic Reforms, PUCL and Lok Prahari
Citation2026 INSC 1040 (Reportable)
Case numberWrit Petition (Civil) No. 14 of 2024 and connected matters
BenchJustice Dipankar Datta and Justice Satish Chandra Sharma
Date23 September 2026
NatureSeparate opinions on reference; joint order
Advocates who arguedFor the Union of India: Mr. R. Venkataramani, Attorney General for India; Mr. Tushar Mehta, Solicitor General of India
For the petitioners: Mr. Vijay Hansaria, Senior Advocate; Mr. Sanjay Parikh, Senior Advocate; Mr. Gopal Sankaranarayanan, Senior Advocate; Mr. Shadan Farasat, Senior Advocate; Mr. Prashant Bhushan, Advocate; Mr. Kaleeshwaram Raj, Advocate
ResultPapers placed before the Chief Justice of India for a Constitution Bench

The Challenge and the Hearing

Individuals and registered societies filed petitions under Article 32 arguing that the 2023 Act violates Article 14 read with Article 324. Their case was that it weakens the independence of the Election Commission by giving the executive a majority on the Selection Committee, after Anoop Baranwal v. Union of India, (2023) 6 SCC 161, had put the Chief Justice of India on the panel until Parliament legislated. The hearing ran from 6 May 2026 over several days, ending on 30 July 2026.

The Attorney General first opposed the petitions on merits. During his arguments he moved to asking that the matter be referred to a Bench of at least five Judges under Article 145(3). The Solicitor General supported this. The petitioners objected that the request was not in the counter affidavit and was not raised at the start.

Provisions Under Challenge

SectionWhat it provides
Section 7(1)CEC and ECs appointed by the President on the recommendation of a Selection Committee: Prime Minister (Chairperson), Leader of Opposition in the Lok Sabha, and a Union Cabinet Minister nominated by the Prime Minister
Section 7(2)Appointment not invalid merely because of a vacancy or defect in the Selection Committee
Section 6Search Committee headed by the Law Minister with two Secretary-level members prepares a panel of five names
Section 8(2)Selection Committee may consider persons outside the Search Committee’s panel

Justice Datta: No Reference Needed

Justice Datta began with the principle that India has a government of laws, not of men. He held that the independence of the ECI plainly forms part of the basic structure. The real question was whether existing case law leaves the constitutional standard unclear. In his view it does not. Precedent already holds that free and fair elections are a basic feature and that appointments must be insulated from exclusive executive control. What remains is applying settled principles to the 2023 Act. Presenting an existing principle in a new legislative setting does not justify a reference. He therefore rejected the request and directed that the petitions be listed for hearing on merits, subject to the Chief Justice’s orders. He made clear that he expressed no view on the merits.

Justice Sharma: Constitution Bench Required

Justice Sharma held that the challenge to Sections 7, 6 and 8 raises a substantial question of law on interpreting the Constitution that has not been decided before, so it must be decided by a Constitution Bench. Anoop Baranwal had made only an interim arrangement until Parliament legislated. Whether the new law passes the test of free and fair elections had to be examined independently. He rejected the argument that a reference would let the Union reopen Anoop Baranwal. He would have placed the petitions before the Chief Justice under Article 145(3) and Order 38 of the Supreme Court Rules.

Final Decision

Joint order. Normally a difference of opinion goes to a three-Judge Bench. Here the disagreement itself is about whether five Judges should hear the case, so a three-Judge decision would only add delay. The papers are placed before the Chief Justice of India to consider constituting a Constitution Bench to decide the validity of Section 7 and the other provisions of the 2023 Act.

Analysis and What Happens Next

The joint order frankly acknowledges delay in deciding references. It notes that Anoop Baranwal took eight years from filing to decision, and that the nine-Judge reference in State of U.P. v. Jai Bir Singh, 2026 INSC 897, was pending for about 24 years in all. It calls such delay a source of institutional embarrassment and asks the Chief Justice to consider a permanent five-Judge Bench for pure constitutional questions.

  • Status of the law: the 2023 Act has not been stayed or decided on merits by this order. The merits remain open.
  • Next step: it is for the Chief Justice to decide whether, and when, to constitute a Constitution Bench.
  • Practice point: a request for a reference made late in a hearing, and not raised in the pleadings, can still be considered, but it may divide the Bench.

Frequently Asked Questions

What did the Supreme Court decide in Jaya Thakur on 23 September 2026?

It did not decide the validity of the 2023 Act. The two judges differed on whether a Constitution Bench should hear it, and the papers were placed before the Chief Justice.

Which provisions of the 2023 Act are challenged?

Section 7 on the Selection Committee, Section 6 on the Search Committee and Section 8(2), which allows candidates outside the panel to be considered.

Why did Justice Datta refuse a reference?

He held that free and fair elections and protecting the ECI from exclusive executive control are settled law, so the Bench only had to apply it.

Why did Justice Sharma favour a reference?

He found a substantial, undecided question of constitutional interpretation, noting that Anoop Baranwal was only an interim arrangement.

What did the Bench say about pending references?

It called long delays in deciding references an institutional concern and asked the Chief Justice to consider a permanent five-Judge Bench.

This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Readers should refer to the certified copy of the judgment and consult a qualified professional before acting. See our Editorial Policy and Disclaimer.