Skip to content
Education Law · Fee Regulation

Fees for Professional Courses Must Be Fixed for the Entire Course Before Admission: Supreme Court Bars Midstream Hike, Directs High Courts to Ensure Efficient Fee Fixation Committees

Fee Fixation CommitteeAICTE RegulationsSelf-financing CollegesNEP 2020B.Tech FeesWest Bengal

In Dr. B.C. Roy Engineering College & Anr. v. State of West Bengal & Ors., 2026 INSC 1120, the Supreme Court held that the fee payable for professional courses such as engineering, medicine and pharmacy in self-financing institutions must be notified for the entire course before a student takes admission, and may be varied during the course only in exceptional situations such as an unforeseen increase in expenditure. Students of the 2023–27 B.Tech batch, admitted before West Bengal raised the fee ceiling on 16 October 2023, therefore cannot be charged the revised fee. While upholding the Calcutta High Court’s directions on refund, the Court rejected its reasoning on retrospectivity and estoppel and placed the onus squarely on fee fixation committees and the State to act on time.

Key Takeaways

  • Fee fixation involves balancing students’ need for certainty with institutions’ need for adequate resources.
  • Fee fixation committees set up under TMA Pai, Islamic Academy and P.A. Inamdar are virtually regulatory bodies and must function with efficiency, expertise and integrity.
  • Authorities must notify the fee for the entire course before admission; midstream variation is allowed only in exceptional cases such as unforeseen cost increases.
  • High Courts must use judicial review to ensure these committees perform effectively.
  • The West Bengal notification of 16 October 2023 applies only to students admitted on or after that date; excess fees collected from earlier students must be refunded or adjusted.
  • The Supreme Court disagreed with the High Court that the hike gave the notification retrospective effect, and with its use of equity and estoppel based on the college brochure.
  • The State and committee were faulted for a seven-year gap in fee revision (2016–17 to 2023).

Case Details at a Glance

Case titleDr. B.C. Roy Engineering College & Anr. v. State of West Bengal & Ors., with connected appeals
Citation2026 INSC 1120 (Reportable)
Case numbersCivil Appeals arising from SLP (C) Nos. 13237, 13690–13691, 16753, 14913–14914, 15617–15618 and 16677 of 2026
BenchJustice P.S. Narasimha and Justice Alok Aradhe
Date of judgment14 October 2026
Impugned judgmentCalcutta High Court Division Bench, 23 March 2026 (Tanushri Mondal v. State of West Bengal)
NotificationNo. 466-Edn(T)/10M-04/2004 (Part IV) dated 16.10.2023
ResultAppeals partly allowed; High Court’s final directions affirmed

Facts of the Case

Students admitted in September 2023 to the B.Tech 2023–27 batch of Dr. B.C. Roy Engineering College, a self-financing college affiliated to Maulana Abul Kalam Azad University of Technology, joined on a published fee structure of roughly Rs 40,000 to Rs 44,000 per semester in tuition for the first year. The prospectus stated that the fee structure was subject to change as per Government decision. About six weeks after admissions closed, the West Bengal Higher Education Department issued a notification on 16 October 2023 raising the maximum annual tuition fee for private self-financing engineering, pharmacy and architecture colleges to Rs 1,10,000, with effect from the 2023–24 academic year. The college adopted the revised fee on 15 December 2023, after the first semester.

A Single Judge dismissed the students’ writ petitions, relying on the prospectus clause. The Division Bench reversed this, read down the notification to apply only to students admitted on or after 16 October 2023, and directed refund or adjustment of excess fees. The college and the Association of Professional Academic Institutes appealed.

Timeline of Proceedings

  • 30.04.2023WBJEE 2023 conducted.
  • Sept 2023Students admitted to B.Tech 2023–27.
  • 16.10.2023State notification raises fee ceiling to Rs 1,10,000 per year.
  • 15.12.2023College adopts revised fee.
  • 15.01.2026Single Judge dismisses students’ writ petitions.
  • 23.03.2026Division Bench rules for students.
  • 14.10.2026Supreme Court affirms result on different reasoning.

Issues Before the Supreme Court

  1. Can the fee payable for a professional course in a self-financing institution be changed midstream?
  2. What role should fee fixation committees and High Courts play in ensuring certainty?

Two legitimate interests

The Court identified two interests to be balanced: the interest of students and parents in a reasonable fee and certainty about its amount and timing, and the interest of self-financing institutions in securing adequate resources to build infrastructure and provide quality education. Following TMA Pai Foundation and P.A. Inamdar, fee fixation committees must be given institutional status, and because they perform a public function, their actions are subject to review.

AICTE Regulations and NEP 2020

Reading Regulations 7(1), 7(4) and 7(5) of the AICTE Regulations, 1994, the Court noted that fees can be revised only on the committee’s recommendation, with a minimum gap of three years, based on estimated expenditure drawn from at least two years of audited accounts and projections for three years. Paragraphs 18.13 and 18.14 of the National Education Policy 2020 reinforce transparent fee-setting and expressly oppose arbitrary increases during a student’s enrolment.

Certainty through efficient regulation

Relying on Lifecare Innovations v. Union of India, the Court held that constitutional courts must first ensure that regulatory bodies can perform their functions effectively. Committees should assess costs, anticipate foreseeable increases over the course, and ensure decisions are taken before admissions begin, so that a student entering a four or five-year course knows the financial commitment at the threshold. A narrowly defined mechanism for extraordinary, unforeseeable cost increases may be provided, but it must remain an exception.

On the facts, fees in West Bengal were last revised in 2016–17. The committee and the State failed to complete the revision in time for the 2023–27 batch, and the problem could have been avoided had the notification been issued before the session began.

Where the High Court went wrong

Although it affirmed the Division Bench’s final directions, the Supreme Court disagreed with two parts of its reasoning: that applying the revised fee to the 2023–27 batch would give the notification retrospective effect, and that the college was bound by equity and estoppel because of its admission brochure. To that extent, the High Court judgment was set aside.

Final Decision

Appeals partly allowed. The Court directed that (i) fee fixation committees, having a statutory foundation and public purpose, must be institutionalised, with High Courts ensuring their efficiency, expertise and integrity; (ii) authorities must notify the fee for the entire course before admission, with variation permissible only in exceptional instances such as unforeseen increases in expenditure; and (iii) the High Court’s final directions on the 16 October 2023 notification are affirmed, and the college must comply. No order as to costs.

Precedents Relied On

CasePrinciple applied
TMA Pai Foundation v. State of Karnataka, (2002) 8 SCC 481Autonomy of private institutions with regulation of fees
P.A. Inamdar v. State of Maharashtra, (2005) 6 SCC 537Fee regulatory committees
Lifecare Innovations Pvt. Ltd. v. Union of India, 2025 SCC OnLine SC 436Judicial review to ensure regulators function effectively

Analysis and Practical Points

The judgment shifts the debate from whether fees can rise to how and when they must be fixed:

  • Students and parents: the fee notified at admission should hold for the whole course; midstream hikes can be challenged unless justified by genuinely unforeseen costs.
  • Colleges: a prospectus clause allowing changes “as per Government decision” will not by itself justify charging existing batches a revised fee.
  • States and committees: fee revisions must be completed before counselling; delays will be scrutinised by High Courts.
  • Refunds: colleges that collected the enhanced fee from students admitted before 16 October 2023 must refund or adjust it.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can colleges increase fees in the middle of a course?

Ordinarily no. The Supreme Court held the fee must be notified for the entire course before admission, and may be varied midstream only in exceptional cases such as an unforeseen increase in expenditure.

Which students benefit from this ruling in West Bengal?

Students admitted to self-financing professional colleges before 16 October 2023 cannot be charged the revised fee; excess amounts must be refunded or adjusted.

What is a fee fixation committee?

It is a body set up following the Supreme Court’s decisions in Islamic Academy and P.A. Inamdar to determine reasonable fees for private professional institutions.

Does a prospectus clause allowing fee changes help colleges?

The Supreme Court did not rest its decision on estoppel, but held that certainty requires fees for the whole course to be fixed in advance, so such a clause does not permit routine midstream increases.

What does NEP 2020 say about fee increases?

Paragraph 18.14 of NEP 2020 states there shall be no arbitrary increases in fees or charges during the period of a student’s enrolment.

This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Readers should refer to the certified copy of the judgment and consult a qualified professional before acting. See our Editorial Policy and Disclaimer.