Skip to content
Civil Procedure · Evidence

Recall of Witnesses: Supreme Court Holds Order XVIII Rule 17 CPC Cannot Be Used to Reopen Closed Evidence and Fill Gaps in a Party’s Case

Order XVIII Rule 17 CPCRecall of WitnessReopening EvidenceOrder VII Rule 14Filling LacunaeCivil Procedure

In K. Bharathamma v. Bandaru Sakku Bai, 2026 INSC 795, plaintiffs in a 2010 title suit over house plots in Ghatkesar, Telangana, sought to recall their main witness and file new documents on house numbers after their evidence had closed and final arguments were halfway through. They had already admitted in 2018 that the houses collapsed in 2016 rains. The Supreme Court held that Order XVIII Rule 17 CPC is meant for the court to clarify doubts, not to let a party cure lacunae or recall a witness for cross-examination, and that the theory of no prejudice cannot justify reopening evidence.

Key Takeaways

  • Order XVIII Rule 17 CPC permits recall of a witness mainly to clarify doubts, not to fill gaps in a party’s evidence.
  • The provision does not empower recall of a witness for cross-examination by a party (Balkrishna Shivappa Shetty, endorsed).
  • That no prejudice will be caused is not a ground to invoke Rule 17.
  • Applications to reopen evidence filed after closure and midway through final arguments may be dismissed as delay tactics.
  • A prayer to produce documents under Order VII Rule 14, intertwined with an invalid recall request, falls with it.

Case Details at a Glance

Case titleK. Bharathamma v. Bandaru Sakku Bai and Others
Citation2026 INSC 795 (Reportable)
Case numberCivil Appeals arising out of SLP (C) Nos. 2744-2746 of 2024
BenchJustice S.V.N. Bhatti and Justice N.V. Anjaria
Authored byJustice N.V. Anjaria
Date of judgment4 August 2026
Impugned orderTelangana High Court common order dated 15.09.2023 in Civil Revision Petition Nos. 458, 496 and 621 of 2023
Law involvedOrder XVIII Rule 17, Order VII Rule 14 and Section 151, Code of Civil Procedure, 1908
Counsel who arguedMr. C. Mukund, Advocate, with Mr. Bijoy Kumar Jain, Advocate-on-Record, for the appellant; Mr. Mehmood Umar Faruqui, Advocate-on-Record, for the respondents
ResultAppeals allowed; High Court order and directions to recall PW-1 and reopen evidence set aside

Facts of the Case

The plaintiffs sued in 2010 for a declaration of ownership of three house properties and to annul the appellant’s 1987 sale deeds over two plots. The appellant relied on registered sale deeds and a 1990 injunction decree in her favour. In 2018 an application for an Advocate Commissioner was closed after the plaintiffs admitted the houses had collapsed in 2016.

After the plaintiffs’ evidence closed, with four witnesses and 35 exhibits, and final arguments had begun, they applied to recall PW-1, reopen evidence and file documents on house numbers. The trial court allowed this in December 2022, and the High Court modified the orders with timelines and costs of Rs 20,000.

Timeline of Proceedings

  • 1987Appellant buys plots by registered sale deeds.
  • 21.11.1990Injunction decree in appellant’s favour.
  • 2010Plaintiffs file title suit.
  • 16.02.2018Commissioner application closed on admission that houses collapsed.
  • 08.12.2022Trial court allows recall and reopening.
  • 15.09.2023High Court modifies and upholds orders.
  • 04.08.2026Supreme Court sets aside orders.

Issues Before the Supreme Court

  1. Could the plaintiffs recall PW-1 and reopen their evidence under Order XVIII Rule 17 CPC after closure of evidence?

Arguments and Counsel

Appellant (Mr. C. Mukund)

The applications were filed at the stage of final arguments to fill gaps exposed in cross-examination and delay the suit; Rule 17 does not permit this.

Respondents (Mr. Mehmood Umar Faruqui)

The documents on house numbers were necessary for a just decision and no prejudice would be caused to the defendant.

Supreme Court’s Ruling

1. Futile exercise

Given the admission that the houses collapsed in 2016, recalling PW-1 for house numbers served no purpose and was a delaying tactic.

2. Limits of Rule 17

Directions to complete cross-examination of PW-1 were beyond Order XVIII Rule 17, which does not permit recall for cross-examination.

3. No filling of lacunae

The plaintiffs sought to fill gaps in evidence already closed, which is impermissible; no prejudice is not a valid ground.

4. Document prayer

The Order VII Rule 14 prayer was interwoven with the recall request and fell with it.

“The theory of no prejudice cannot be conveniently applied to justify invocation of the provision of Order XVIII Rule 17, CPC.” – Supreme Court, 2026 INSC 795, para 7.5

Final Decision

Appeals allowed. The Telangana High Court’s common order of 15 September 2023, which directed recall of PW-1, reopening of the plaintiffs’ evidence and marking of further documents, was set aside.

Precedents Relied On

CasePrinciple applied
Balkrishna Shivappa Shetty v. Mahesh Nenshi Bhakta, AIR 2003 Bom 293Rule 17 does not permit recall for cross-examination by a party
Vadiraj Naggappa Vernekar v. Sharadchandra Prabhakar Gogate, (2009) 4 SCC 410Rule 17 is for clarifying doubts, not filling lacunae

Analysis and Practical Points

The judgment reinforces discipline in civil trials. Parties should lead complete evidence the first time; late recall applications at the argument stage will be viewed as tactics to delay and repair weaknesses exposed in cross-examination.

  • Plaintiffs: File all documents with the plaint or before evidence closes; Rule 17 is not a second chance.
  • Defendants: Oppose late recall applications that seek to cure admissions or gaps.
  • Trial courts: Do not allow recall merely because no prejudice will result.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is Order XVIII Rule 17 CPC?

It allows the court to recall and examine a witness at any stage, mainly to clarify doubts.

Can a party recall its witness to fill gaps in evidence?

No. The Supreme Court held in 2026 INSC 795 that the provision cannot be used to cure lacunae.

Is absence of prejudice enough to allow recall?

No. The no prejudice theory cannot justify invoking Rule 17.

This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Readers should refer to the certified copy of the judgment and consult a qualified professional before acting. See our Editorial Policy and Disclaimer.