Skip to content
Education Law · Regulators

Regulators Must Be Allowed to Regulate: Supreme Court Upholds NCTE Power to Require Performance Appraisal Reports From Teacher Education Institutes

NCTEPerformance AppraisalTeacher EducationSection 12(k)Regulatory PowerArticle 21A

In NCTE v. Association of NCTE Approved Colleges Trust, 2026 INSC 953, the Supreme Court set aside a Delhi High Court Division Bench judgment that had struck down NCTE’s public notice of 22 September 2019. The notice required teacher education institutes (TEIs) to upload an annual Performance Appraisal Report (PAR) on a portal and pay a fee. The High Court had found that the proforma was not approved by the Council and that the function under Section 12(k) had not been delegated to the Member Secretary. The Supreme Court held that calling for PARs and charging a process fee are incidental and ancillary to NCTE’s regulatory role, and that courts should not take a technical or pedantic view of regulators’ actions. Constitutional courts also have a positive duty to ensure regulators use their powers effectively and accountably.

Key Takeaways

  • Article 21A and Section 23 of the RTE Act make NCTE the academic authority that sets teacher qualifications, so teacher education is central to the right to education.
  • Section 12(k) requires NCTE to evolve a suitable performance appraisal system for TEIs.
  • Calling for PARs to build a management information system is incidental to regulation, especially after annual renewal of recognition became contentious.
  • The fee charged is a process fee, which a regulator may also levy as an ancillary power.
  • Accountability has three parts: responsibility, answerability and enforceability (Vijay Rajmohan).
  • The Court decided the issue even though later procedural defects were fixed, to give clarity on regulators’ powers.

Case Details at a Glance

Case titleThe National Council for Teachers Education v. Association of NCTE Approved Colleges Trust & Ors.
Citation2026 INSC 953 (Reportable)
Case numberCivil Appeal arising out of SLP (C) No. 11756 of 2023
BenchJustice Pamidighantam Sri Narasimha and Justice Alok Aradhe
Date of judgment3 September 2026
ImpugnedDelhi High Court Division Bench, 13 March 2023, LPA No. 190 of 2021
ResultAppeal allowed; public notice upheld

Background

In its 46th meeting (2017), NCTE approved annual renewal of recognition, which proved difficult in practice. In its 48th meeting on 5 February 2019, the General Body approved PAR-linked monitoring through a proforma to be developed by NCTE. The Member Secretary’s public notice of 22 September 2019 asked institutions to upload PARs and pay a fee. A Single Judge upheld the notice, but the Division Bench set it aside for lack of approval of the proforma and of delegation under Section 27.

Regulatory Power and Accountability

The Court held that the Division Bench’s reading weakened NCTE’s regulatory jurisdiction. A regulator must be able to require information from those it regulates, and courts must ensure regulators exercise their powers efficiently and accountably, not only that they stay within them.

Final Decision

Appeal allowed. The Delhi High Court judgment of 13 March 2023 is set aside. The public notice is legal and valid, and the Council and Executive Committee may require TEIs to upload Performance Appraisal Reports.

Analysis and Practical Points

  • Teacher education institutes: treat PAR filing as a binding obligation tied to continued recognition.
  • Regulators: the ruling supports information-gathering and process fees as ancillary powers, but decisions should still follow internal approval procedures.
  • Litigants: technical objections to regulatory notices are less likely to succeed where the power is clearly incidental to the statute’s purpose.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can NCTE require teacher education institutes to file performance appraisal reports?

Yes. The Supreme Court held it is incidental to NCTE’s regulatory functions, including Section 12(k).

Can NCTE charge a fee for PAR filing?

Yes. The Court treated it as a process fee, an ancillary regulatory power.

Why had the High Court struck down the notice?

It found the proforma was not approved by the Council and the function was not delegated to the Member Secretary.

What did the Court say about regulators generally?

Courts should not take a pedantic view and must ensure regulators exercise powers effectively and accountably.

This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Readers should refer to the certified copy of the judgment and consult a qualified professional before acting. See our Editorial Policy and Disclaimer.