Skip to content
Consumer Law · Medical Negligence

Consumer Protection Act Section 58(3): NCDRC Third Member Who Decided the Appeal on a Broadly Framed Reference Did Not Commit an Illegality Warranting Article 227 Interference

In Askari Hussain v. Dinesh Kumar, 2026 INSC 929, the Supreme Court considered what a third member of the National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission must do when the two members of a Bench differ in a medical negligence appeal. The referring members did not state their points of difference under Section 58(3) of the Consumer Protection Act, 2019, but framed five questions going to the root of the evidence. The third member answered them, agreed with one member and decided the appeal, awarding Rs 93 lakh. The Allahabad High Court quashed that as excess of jurisdiction. The Supreme Court held that, given the faulty reference, the third member’s common-sense approach was not an illegality warranting interference under Article 227.

Key Takeaways

  • Ordinarily, a referee Bench answers the questions referred and returns the matter to the referring Bench for decision (Kesho Nath Khurana).
  • A referee Bench may answer subsidiary questions that logically and unavoidably arise, adopting a common-sense approach (Salil Sabhlok).
  • Section 58(3) of the Consumer Protection Act, 2019 requires the referring members to state the point or points on which they differ.
  • Where the referring Bench instead framed broad questions requiring a full appraisal of evidence, the third member deciding the appeal was not a jurisdictional error.
  • The objection to the scope of the reference was technical and did not justify Article 227 interference at that distance of time.
  • The High Court must now examine the Article 227 petition on merits, which it had not done.

Case Details at a Glance

Case titleAskari Hussain and Others v. Dinesh Kumar and Others
Citation2026 INSC 929 (Reportable)
Case numberCivil Appeal No. 11988 of 2026 (arising out of SLP (C) No. 19685 of 2025)
BenchJustice Dipankar Datta and Justice Sheel Nagu
Authored byJustice Dipankar Datta
Date of judgment24 August 2026
Impugned orderAllahabad High Court (Single Judge) order dated 11.12.2024 in Matters under Article 227 No. 901 of 2024
Law involvedSection 58(3), Consumer Protection Act, 2019; Article 227 of the Constitution; reference to larger or third Bench
Counsel who arguedLearned counsel for the appellants (complainants); Learned counsel for the respondents; Names of counsel are not recorded in the judgment
ResultAppeal allowed; Article 227 petition remanded to the High Court for decision on merits

Facts of the Case

The complainants won a medical negligence complaint before the U.P. State Commission in 2012, which awarded Rs 95 lakh with 15% interest. In appeal before the NCDRC, the presiding member allowed the appeal and dismissed the complaint, while the other member reduced the award to Rs 93 lakh and interest.

The matter was referred to a third member under Section 58(3). The referring members framed five questions, including whether the doctor’s link to the hospital and the patient’s admission were proved. On 9 January 2024 the third member agreed with the companion member, apportioned Rs 93 lakh among the complainants with interest, and disposed of the appeals.

The doctor challenged this under Article 227. A Single Judge of the Allahabad High Court quashed the third member’s order for exceeding the reference and directed a fresh opinion limited to the questions.

Timeline of Proceedings

  • 04.12.2012State Commission awards Rs 95 lakh with 15% interest.
  • 19.03.2021NCDRC members deliver differing opinions.
  • 09.01.2024Third member concurs with companion member and decides the appeals.
  • 11.12.2024Allahabad High Court quashes the third member’s order.
  • 24.08.2026Supreme Court sets aside the High Court order and remands.

Issues Before the Supreme Court

  1. On a reference under Section 58(3) of the Consumer Protection Act, must the third member only answer the points referred and return the case, or may he decide the appeal?
  2. Did the third member commit an illegality warranting interference under Article 227?

Arguments and Counsel

Appellants (complainants)

The third member had answered the questions on merits and the majority view was clear, so the High Court should not have quashed his order on a technicality.

Respondent (doctor)

Relying on Kesho Nath Khurana and Bansi Dhar, the third member exceeded his jurisdiction by deciding the appeal instead of returning his answers to the referring Bench.

Supreme Court’s Ruling

1. General rule on references

Drawing on Kesho Nath Khurana, Kerala State Science and Technology Museum, T.A. Hameed, Saquib Abdul Hameed Nachan and Salil Sabhlok, the Court held that a referee Bench should normally return its answers to the referring Bench, but may answer subsidiary questions that logically arise.

2. Section 58(3) and the faltering reference

Section 58(3) requires the members to state the points of difference. Here they did not; they framed five questions inseparable from the evidence. The third member necessarily surveyed the entire material.

3. Common-sense approach, no illegality

Deciding the appeal on the basis of the majority opinion reflected the common-sense approach recognised in Salil Sabhlok. It did not amount to an illegality warranting Article 227 interference.

4. Remand for decision on merits

The High Court had not examined the merits of the third member’s answers. The Article 227 petition must now be decided on merits, with all issues open.

“The objection as to scope of the reference, in our view, is technical.” – Supreme Court, 2026 INSC 929, para 18

Result

The High Court’s order was set aside and the Article 227 application remanded for fresh decision on merits, with all issues left open. The High Court is to decide it early, and the NCDRC is not to proceed further meanwhile.

Analysis and Practical Points

The judgment is useful for consumer fora and for any tribunal with a split-Bench reference mechanism. It also notes that the CPC has no provision like Section 392 CrPC or Section 433 BNSS, so references in civil matters are governed by precedent. The practical lesson is for referring Benches: frame the actual points of difference as the statute requires, so the third member’s role remains confined.

  • Consumer litigants: If a split NCDRC Bench refers the case broadly, the third member’s decision of the whole appeal may be upheld; challenge the merits, not just the procedure.
  • Commission members: When differing, state the precise points of difference under Section 58(3) rather than framing open-ended questions.
  • High Courts: In Article 227 challenges to NCDRC orders, examine whether the procedural deviation caused real prejudice before quashing.

Frequently Asked Questions

What happens when NCDRC members differ in opinion?

Under Section 58(3) of the Consumer Protection Act, 2019, they state the points of difference and refer them to the President, who hears them or refers them to other members; the points are decided by majority.

Can the third member decide the whole appeal?

Ordinarily he should answer the referred points and return the case. But in 2026 INSC 929, where the reference was framed broadly, his deciding the appeal was held not to be an illegality.

What did the Supreme Court direct?

It remanded the Article 227 petition to the Allahabad High Court to be decided on merits, and said the NCDRC should not proceed meanwhile.

This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Readers should refer to the certified copy of the judgment and consult a qualified professional before acting. See our Editorial Policy and Disclaimer.