Skip to content
Customs Law · Indirect Tax

Customs Duty on Pilfered Goods: Supreme Court Upholds Notification Approving Mumbai Port Trust as Custodian Under Section 45(1), Fastening Liability Under Section 45(3)

In Union of India v. Board of Trustees of the Port of Bombay, 2026 INSC 919, the Supreme Court held that the Commissioner of Customs validly approved Mumbai Port Trust as the custodian of imported goods in the notified customs area by a notification of 11 October 2000, making the Port Trust liable under Section 45(3) of the Customs Act to pay duty on goods pilfered from its custody. The Bombay High Court had struck down the notification, reasoning that since the Port Trust’s custody flowed from the Major Port Trusts Act, the saving clause in Section 45(1) excluded the Commissioner’s power. The Supreme Court disagreed, finding the two statutes cover different liabilities, but the Union conceded that demands for the pre-notification period could not stand.

Key Takeaways

  • Under Section 45(3) of the Customs Act, the custodian approved under Section 45(1) is liable for duty on imported goods pilfered from a customs area.
  • A Major Port Trust can be approved as custodian under Section 45(1), even though its custody of goods also arises under the Major Port Trusts Act.
  • Liability under Section 43 of the Major Port Trusts Act is a conditional bailee’s civil liability to the goods owner; Section 45(3) creates an absolute statutory duty liability to the Revenue.
  • The non obstante clause in Section 45(3) overrides the saving clause in Section 45(1) where pilferage is concerned.
  • Pilferage is treated distinctly from loss or destruction (Sections 13 and 23 of the Customs Act).
  • No Section 45(3) liability can arise for pilferage before the custodian’s approval; such demands fail.

Case Details at a Glance

Case titleUnion of India and Others v. The Board of Trustees of the Port of Bombay
Citation2026 INSC 919 (Reportable)
Case numberCivil Appeal No. 4477 of 2010
BenchJustice B.V. Nagarathna and Justice Manmohan
Authored byJustice B.V. Nagarathna
Date of judgment25 August 2026
Impugned orderBombay High Court Division Bench order dated 28.07.2009 in Writ Petition No. 1278 of 2003
Law involvedSections 13, 23 and 45, Customs Act, 1962; Sections 42 and 43, Major Port Trusts Act, 1963; Notification and Public Notice dated 11.10.2000
Counsel who arguedMr. V. Chandrashekara Bharati, Advocate, for the Union of India and customs authorities; Mr. Rakesh Khanna, Senior Advocate, for the respondent Port Trust
ResultAppeal disposed of; notification dated 11.10.2000 held valid; pre-notification demands remain quashed

Facts of the Case

Customs issued show cause-cum-demand notices in 1996, 1997 and 2000 to the Port Trust under Section 45(3) for duty on goods pilfered from its custody between 1996 and 2000. The demands were confirmed and the appeals before the Commissioner (Appeals) dismissed in 2002.

In the meantime, on 11 October 2000 the Commissioner of Customs (Import) issued a notification and public notice declaring the Mumbai Port Trust as custodian of the notified area under Section 45(1). The Port Trust challenged the appellate order and the notification. On 28 July 2009 the Bombay High Court quashed both, holding that Section 45(1) did not permit approval of a body whose custody was already governed by another law.

Timeline of Proceedings

  • 26.05.1995Section 45(3) inserted in the Customs Act.
  • 1996-2000Pilferage demands raised against the Port Trust.
  • 11.10.2000Notification approving Mumbai Port Trust as custodian.
  • 30.07.2002Commissioner (Appeals) confirms demands.
  • 28.07.2009Bombay High Court quashes demands and notification.
  • 25.08.2026Supreme Court upholds the notification.

Issues Before the Supreme Court

  1. Was the Commissioner competent under Section 45(1) of the Customs Act to approve the Mumbai Port Trust as custodian, given that its custody flows from the Major Port Trusts Act?
  2. Can liability under Section 45(3) be fastened on the Port Trust for pilferage?

Arguments and Counsel

Union of India (Mr. V. Chandrashekara Bharati)

The saving words in Section 45(1) do not bar approval merely because another statute also places goods in that person’s custody. Once approved, the custodian bears duty liability for pilferage. The notification was a valid exercise of express power. The Union fairly conceded that pre-notification demands could not stand.

Port Trust (Mr. Rakesh Khanna, Senior Advocate)

Custody flows from the Major Port Trusts Act, so the Commissioner had no power to approve the Port Trust under Section 45(1), and Section 45(3) cannot independently create liability. In any case, the notification could not apply to earlier pilferage.

Supreme Court’s Ruling

1. Purpose of Section 45(3)

Section 13 absolves the importer of duty on pilfered goods. To prevent loss of revenue, Parliament inserted Section 45(3) in 1995 to fasten duty liability on the approved custodian, notwithstanding any other law.

2. Two different liabilities

Section 43 of the Major Port Trusts Act governs the Board’s conditional civil liability as bailee towards the owner; Section 45(3) imposes an independent and absolute liability to pay duty to the Revenue. There is no conflict between them.

3. Non obstante clause prevails

The saving clause in Section 45(1) would ordinarily let another law prevail if it created a corresponding liability. Since the Major Port Trusts Act creates no tax liability for pilferage, the non obstante clause in Section 45(3) operates.

4. Custodian’s duties

Section 45(2) obliges every custodian, under any law, to keep records and prevent unauthorised removal. Pilferage results from breach of these duties, justifying liability.

5. Notification valid; past demands fail

The 11 October 2000 notification was valid. As the Union conceded, pilferage before that date could not attract Section 45(3) liability.

“The source, nature and object of the two liabilities are, clearly, distinct.” – Supreme Court, 2026 INSC 919, para 6.20

Result

The notification dated 11 October 2000 approving Mumbai Port Trust as custodian under Section 45(1) was held valid and the High Court judgment quashing it was set aside. The quashing of the four demand notices for pilferage before 11 October 2000 was not interfered with, as the Union conceded no Section 45(3) liability could arise without prior approval. No costs.

Analysis and Practical Points

The ruling has significant implications for major ports and other statutory custodians of imported cargo. Once approved under Section 45(1), they bear duty liability for pilferage regardless of their separate bailee obligations under port legislation. The concession on pre-notification demands also confirms that approval is a necessary pre-condition for Section 45(3) liability. Under the Major Port Authorities Act, 2021, which replaced the 1963 Act, the same analysis should apply.

  • Ports and custodians: Strengthen record-keeping and security under Section 45(2); duty on pilfered goods will fall on the approved custodian.
  • Customs authorities: Ensure a valid approval under Section 45(1) exists for the relevant period before raising Section 45(3) demands.
  • Importers: Section 13 continues to absolve importers of duty on goods pilfered before clearance, unless restored to them.

Frequently Asked Questions

Who pays customs duty on goods pilfered from a port before clearance?

The custodian approved under Section 45(1) of the Customs Act, under Section 45(3). The importer is absolved by Section 13 unless the goods are restored.

Can a Major Port Trust be approved as customs custodian?

Yes. In 2026 INSC 919 the Supreme Court upheld the 2000 notification approving Mumbai Port Trust as custodian.

Does the Major Port Trusts Act exclude Section 45(3) liability?

No. Its liability is a conditional civil one to the goods owner, while Section 45(3) creates a separate duty liability to the Revenue.

Were the 1996 to 2000 demands upheld?

No. They related to pilferage before the approval and the Union conceded they could not stand.

This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Readers should refer to the certified copy of the judgment and consult a qualified professional before acting. See our Editorial Policy and Disclaimer.