Skip to content
Criminal Law · Sentencing

Whole-Life Sentences: Supreme Court Upholds Life Imprisonment for the Remainder of Natural Life Without Remission and Limits Review of Presidential Clemency

Life ImprisonmentWithout RemissionSriharanArticle 72ClemencyArticle 32

In Ramasrey v. State of Uttar Pradesh, 2026 INSC 764, four groups of convicts serving life imprisonment for the remainder of their natural lives, some without remission, challenged those sentences as unconstitutional. Some had been sentenced to death and had their sentences commuted by High Courts; others received the whole-life term from the President on mercy petitions. Relying on the Constitution Bench in Union of India v. V. Sriharan, the Supreme Court held that such sentences are valid, called the challenge before a two-Judge Bench a misuse of process, and reiterated the narrow grounds for judicial review of presidential clemency.

Key Takeaways

  • Life imprisonment ordinarily means imprisonment for the remainder of natural life (Sections 45 and 53 IPC).
  • Constitutional courts may impose a special category of sentence beyond 14 or 20 years and exclude remission, as upheld in Sriharan.
  • Where a sentence does not expressly exclude remission, the State’s power under Section 432 CrPC remains.
  • Presidential clemency orders under Article 72 are reviewable only on limited grounds such as mala fides or non-application of mind.
  • Convicts who have not used remission remedies cannot invoke Article 32 directly.
  • Executive policies cannot take away remission altogether, as noted in Joseph v. State of Kerala, but courts may do so in rare cases.

Case Details at a Glance

Case titleRamasrey @ Fakkad v. State of Uttar Pradesh (with Writ Petition (Crl.) Nos. 42 of 2024, 69 of 2025 and 198 of 2025)
Citation2026 INSC 764 (Reportable)
Case numberWrit Petition (Criminal) No. 553 of 2023 and connected petitions
BenchJustice Sanjay Karol and Justice Augustine George Masih
Authored byJustice Sanjay Karol
Date of judgment29 July 2026
Impugned orderSentences of imprisonment for the remainder of natural life imposed by High Courts or substituted by the President on mercy petitions
Law involvedArticles 32 and 72, Constitution of India; Sections 45, 53 and 302 IPC; Sections 432 and 433A CrPC; Union of India v. V. Sriharan
Counsel who arguedMr. Rishi Malhotra, Senior Advocate, for the petitioners; Mr. S.V. Raju and Mr. Raja S. Thakare, Additional Solicitors General, for the respondents; Mr. R. Venkataramani, Attorney General for India, at the Court’s request
ResultAll four writ petitions under Article 32 dismissed

Facts of the Case

Ramasrey was sentenced to death for kidnapping for ransom and murder; the Allahabad High Court substituted imprisonment for the remainder of natural life. Chander Kant Jha’s death sentence was commuted by the Delhi High Court to life without remission.

Atbir Singh and three Punjab convicts had death sentences upheld by the Supreme Court, but the President accepted their mercy petitions and substituted life for the remainder of natural life without remission or parole. All four sought to strike down these sentences.

Timeline of Proceedings

  • 1991 and 1996Offences in the Punjab and Delhi cases.
  • 15.11.2012President commutes Atbir Singh’s death sentence.
  • 2023 to 2025Writ petitions filed under Article 32.
  • 16.10.2025Attorney General’s assistance sought.
  • 29.07.2026Writ petitions dismissed.

Issues Before the Supreme Court

  1. Is a sentence of imprisonment for the remainder of natural life without remission constitutional?
  2. Can presidential clemency orders be judicially reviewed and the commuted sentence modified?

Arguments and Counsel

Petitioners (Mr. Rishi Malhotra, Senior Advocate)

Section 302 IPC provides only death or life imprisonment; whole-life terms without remission were added by Parliament only for sexual offences and defeat statutory remission rights under Section 432 CrPC.

Union and States (ASGs S.V. Raju and Raja S. Thakare) and Attorney General

Sriharan upheld such sentences; clemency orders are reviewable only on narrow grounds; the petitions were not maintainable.

Supreme Court’s Ruling

1. Sriharan binding

A Constitution Bench has held whole-life sentences valid; raising the point again before a two-Judge Bench is a misuse of process.

2. Remission rights

Where remission is not expressly excluded, Section 432 applies; excluding remission in rare grave cases is not unconstitutional.

3. Clemency review

No ground of judicial review against the President’s orders was shown in the two clemency cases.

4. Alternative remedies

Petitioners who had not sought remission could not invoke Article 32.

Final Decision

Writ petitions dismissed. All four writ petitions were dismissed. Two petitioners had not even applied for remission; in the other two, the President’s commutation orders disclosed no ground for judicial review.

Precedents Relied On

CasePrinciple applied
Union of India v. V. Sriharan, (2016) 7 SCC 1Courts may impose fixed-term or whole-life sentences beyond remission
Swamy Shraddananda (2) v. State of Karnataka, (2008) 13 SCC 767Special category of sentence in substitution of death
Joseph v. State of Kerala (2023)Executive cannot take away remission by instruction

Analysis and Practical Points

The judgment confirms that whole-life sentences without remission, whether imposed by courts or by the President, are constitutionally sound. Convicts should pursue remission or clemency through proper channels; Article 32 petitions repeating settled questions risk dismissal.

  • Convicts and families: Apply for remission or clemency where the sentence permits; Article 32 is not a substitute.
  • Defence lawyers: Challenge clemency orders only on established grounds such as mala fides or irrelevant considerations.
  • Prison authorities: Distinguish sentences that expressly exclude remission from ordinary life sentences.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is life imprisonment for the remainder of natural life valid?

Yes. In 2026 INSC 764 the Court reaffirmed Sriharan and upheld such sentences.

Can a court exclude remission?

Yes, in rare cases in substitution of the death penalty, as recognised in Sriharan and Swamy Shraddananda.

Can presidential clemency orders be challenged?

Only on narrow judicial review grounds; none were shown here.

This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Readers should refer to the certified copy of the judgment and consult a qualified professional before acting. See our Editorial Policy and Disclaimer.