Insider Trading: Supreme Court Holds Motive and Use of Proceeds Irrelevant Under the 2015 PIT Regulations, Restores SEBI Order Against Tara Jewels Promoters
In SEBI v. Rajeev Vasant Sheth, 2026 INSC 826, the Supreme Court held that under the SEBI (Prohibition of Insider Trading) Regulations, 2015, once a person is shown to have traded while holding unpublished price sensitive information, the reasons for trading and the use of the proceeds are irrelevant. The managing director of Tara Jewels and his two daughters sold large holdings before the company announced a quarterly loss of Rs 166.80 crore, avoiding losses of about Rs 1.38 crore. The Securities Appellate Tribunal accepted that the sales were to save the company from NPA classification; the Supreme Court reversed it, distinguishing Abhijit Rajan as decided under the 1992 Regulations.
Key Takeaways
- Under the note to Regulation 4(1) of the PIT Regulations 2015, trades by a person holding UPSI are presumed motivated by it.
- The purpose of the trade and the application of proceeds, such as funding the company, are not relevant defences.
- The defences in the proviso to Regulation 4(1) are not exhaustive, but other defences must be of the same nature; ejusdem generis does not apply as such.
- SEBI v. Abhijit Rajan turned on the 1992 Regulations, which had no such note.
- The legitimate corporate purpose defence in Rakesh Agrawal is not open under the 2015 Regulations.
- Absence of profit or small price movement does not negate insider trading.
Case Details at a Glance
| Case title | Securities and Exchange Board of India v. Rajeev Vasant Sheth and Others |
|---|---|
| Citation | 2026 INSC 826 (Reportable) |
| Case number | Civil Appeal No. 4905 of 2022 |
| Bench | Justice Sanjay Karol and Justice N. Kotiswar Singh |
| Authored by | Justice Sanjay Karol |
| Date of judgment | 11 August 2026 |
| Impugned order | Securities Appellate Tribunal, Mumbai order dated 19.04.2022 in Appeal No. 536 of 2021 |
| Law involved | Section 12A(d) and (e), 15G, 15HB and 11B, SEBI Act, 1992; Regulations 3(1), 4(1) and 9(1), SEBI (Prohibition of Insider Trading) Regulations, 2015 |
| Counsel who argued | Learned Senior Counsel and counsel for SEBI; Learned Senior Counsel and counsel for the respondents; Names of counsel are not recorded in the judgment |
| Result | Appeal allowed; WTM order restored including disgorgement; Section 15G penalty on Respondent No. 1 reduced from Rs 25 lakh to Rs 10 lakh |
Facts of the Case
Tara Jewels Ltd., listed on BSE and NSE, reported a loss of Rs 166.80 crore for the quarter ending September 2017 against Rs 6.62 crore in the previous quarter. During the UPSI period from 2 October to 29 November 2017, its chairman and managing director sold over 30 lakh shares and later further shares, and his two daughters, promoters, sold their entire holdings.
SEBI’s Whole Time Member found insider trading, restrained the respondents from the market, directed disgorgement and imposed penalties. SAT set this aside, accepting that the sales were to prevent the company becoming an NPA and noting little price difference after disclosure.
Timeline of Proceedings
- 02.10.2017 to 29.11.2017UPSI period; shares sold.
- 04.09.2020Impounding order cum show cause notice.
- 24.05.2021WTM order finding insider trading.
- 19.04.2022SAT sets aside WTM order.
- 11.08.2026Supreme Court restores WTM order with reduced penalty.
Issues Before the Supreme Court
- Can the purpose for which insiders sold shares, such as funding the company, be a defence under the 2015 PIT Regulations?
- Does SEBI v. Abhijit Rajan apply?
Arguments and Counsel
SEBI
The respondents fell within none of the defences under Regulation 4(1), even read ejusdem generis; SAT erred.
Respondents
The case was covered by Abhijit Rajan, as the proceeds were used for the company’s purposes, and the respondents gained nothing.
Supreme Court’s Ruling
1. Presumption under the note
Possession of UPSI and trading during that period were admitted. The note to Regulation 4(1) makes the purpose of trades and the use of proceeds irrelevant; less or no profit is of no consequence.
2. Nature of defences
The word “including” shows the defences are not exhaustive, but any other defence must be of the same or similar nature.
3. Abhijit Rajan distinguished
That case arose under the 1992 Regulations, which lacked the note, and involved a sale before a price rise.
4. Penalty
Disgorgement and Code of Conduct penalties were restored; the Section 15G penalty on the managing director was reduced to the Rs 10 lakh minimum.
“In that view of the matter, less or no profit, is of no consequence.” – Supreme Court, 2026 INSC 826, para 11
Result
The SAT order was set aside and the SEBI Whole Time Member’s findings of insider trading restored, along with disgorgement of losses avoided of about Rs 1.38 crore and the Code of Conduct penalties. The Section 15G penalty on the managing director was reduced from Rs 25 lakh to Rs 10 lakh, payable within three months.
Analysis and Practical Points
This is a significant ruling for listed company promoters. It closes the door on motive-based defences such as rescuing the company, previously accepted by SAT in Rakesh Agrawal and by the Supreme Court in Abhijit Rajan under the 1992 framework. Insiders who need to sell must rely on the specific proviso defences, such as pre-approved trading plans under Regulation 5.
- Promoters and directors: Avoid trading during UPSI periods even for company purposes; use trading plans under Regulation 5.
- Compliance officers: Enforce trading window closures strictly; Code of Conduct breaches attract separate penalties.
- Litigants before SAT: Defences based on corporate purpose under the 1992 regime do not carry over to the 2015 Regulations.
Frequently Asked Questions
What did the Supreme Court hold in SEBI v Rajeev Vasant Sheth?
In 2026 INSC 826 it held that under the 2015 PIT Regulations the motive for trading and use of proceeds are irrelevant once trading while in possession of UPSI is shown.
Is Abhijit Rajan still good law?
It was distinguished as decided under the 1992 Regulations, which had no note excluding motive.
What penalty was finally imposed?
Disgorgement of losses avoided was restored, and the Section 15G penalty on the managing director was reduced to Rs 10 lakh.
This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Readers should refer to the certified copy of the judgment and consult a qualified professional before acting. See our Editorial Policy and Disclaimer.
