Supreme Court: Son Has No Right by Birth in Property His Father Inherited From the Grandfather Under Section 8 of the Hindu Succession Act
In J. Rajesh v. M. Kumaran, 2026 INSC 1208, the Supreme Court held that property which devolves on a son from his father under Section 8 of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956 is the son’s absolute property and not joint family property in relation to his own children. A grandson, born after the succession opened and while his father was alive, therefore had no right by birth to claim half the share his father received in a 1994 family partition decree and later sold. The Court dismissed the grandson’s appeal and upheld the Madras High Court.
Key Takeaways
- On intestate succession under Section 8, Class I heirs (son, daughter, widow, mother, etc.) take simultaneously to the exclusion of all others; a son’s son is not a Class I heir while his father is alive.
- Following CWT v. Chander Sen, property inherited by a son under Section 8 is not HUF property in his hands vis-à-vis his own son.
- Once the grandfather’s estate was partitioned by a compromise decree, each heir became exclusive owner of his share, holding as tenants in common, not joint tenants.
- Unamended Section 6 (survivorship) and Section 29-A of the Tamil Nadu amendment did not help, since the grandson was not a surviving coparcener when the grandfather died.
- The father could validly sell his share; the grandson’s suit, filed without challenging the partition decree or sale deeds, failed.
Case Details at a Glance
| Case title | J. Rajesh (Minor) through mother and natural guardian J. Gomathi v. M. Kumaran (Dead) through LRs. and others |
|---|---|
| Citation | 2026 INSC 1208 (Reportable) |
| Case number | Civil Appeal No. 7020 of 2012 |
| Bench | Justice Augustine George Masih and Justice Sunita Agarwal |
| Authored by | Justice Sunita Agarwal |
| Date of judgment | 6 November 2026 |
| Provisions | Sections 4, 6 and 8, Hindu Succession Act, 1956; Section 29-A, Hindu Succession (Tamil Nadu Amendment) Act, 1989 |
| Impugned order | Madras High Court judgment dated 11.08.2010 |
| Property | 1,811 sq. ft. land in Chennai |
| Result | Appeal dismissed |
Background
The suit land, 1,811 sq. ft. in Chennai, came from the appellant’s grandfather, N. Ramakrishnan. In 1993, the grandfather’s daughter filed a partition suit among his heirs. It ended in a compromise decree on 03.02.1994, under which the appellant’s father got this plot. The appellant was born on 06.01.1994 – after the suit was filed but before the decree.
In April 1997, the father sold the plot to two purchasers. Later in 1997, the appellant, then a minor acting through his mother, sued for partition and possession of half the plot, claiming it was ancestral property in which he had a right by birth. He did not challenge the 1994 compromise decree or the sale deeds. The father stayed ex parte throughout and died in 2024.
The trial court granted a preliminary decree. The first appellate court and the Madras High Court reversed it, holding that the father held the property absolutely.
Arguments
Appellant: Relying on Section 29-A of the Tamil Nadu amendment, Rohit Chauhan v. Surinder Singh and Arshnoor Singh v. Harpal Kaur, he argued that he became a coparcener by birth before the partition decree; that ancestral property allotted on partition remains coparcenary property in relation to the allottee’s son; and that the father could not sell without legal necessity.
Purchasers: This was a case of succession under Section 8, where a grandson is excluded by Class I heirs. They relied on Chander Sen, Vimalben Ajitbhai Patel and Radha Bai v. Ram Narayan, and called the suit collusive.
Supreme Court’s Ruling
Section 8 is a self-contained scheme
The grandfather’s heirs inherited as Class I heirs under Section 8. A son’s son is not listed in Class I (only the son of a predeceased son is), so he gets no right in his grandfather’s property while his father lives. The pre-1956 Hindu law right of a grandson in his grandfather’s property during his father’s lifetime was not saved by the Act.
No HUF in the father’s hands
Applying Chander Sen, the Court held that treating property inherited under Section 8 as HUF property of the son’s own branch would create two classes among Class I heirs – male heirs holding it as joint family property and female heirs who could not. The express words of Section 8 must prevail.
Partition made each heir exclusive owner
Under the 1994 compromise decree, each heir became exclusive owner of his or her share, as tenants in common. The coparcenary did not continue.
“...the appellant cannot become a coparcener as he was not a ‘surviving coparcener’ on the death of N. Ramakrishnan.” – Supreme Court, 2026 INSC 1208, para 39
Section 6 and Section 29-A not attracted
Succession opened on the grandfather’s death, which was before the appellant’s birth (the partition suit itself was filed in 1993). Neither the unamended Section 6 nor the Tamil Nadu Section 29-A applied.
The appeal was dismissed without costs.
Analysis: Ancestral Property After the Hindu Succession Act
Many people still assume that anything coming from a grandfather is ‘ancestral’ and that grandchildren have a birthright in it. This judgment reaffirms the position since Chander Sen: where a Hindu male dies intestate after 1956 and his property passes to his son under Section 8, the son holds it as his own. His children cannot sue for partition during his lifetime and cannot stop him from selling it.
The position is different where a coparcenary already existed and the property passed by survivorship, or where there is evidence of a continuing joint family. Those who rely on Arshnoor Singh must show that the property retained its coparcenary character – for example, because succession opened before 1956.
Practical points
- Buyers: property received by a seller under Section 8 or a partition among Class I heirs is his absolute property; check the date and mode of devolution.
- Family members: a challenge to a partition decree or sale must be pleaded and pursued; a bare claim of ‘ancestral’ character is not enough.
- Courts: fix the date of death of the propositus; it decides whether Section 6, Section 8 or the pre-1956 law applies.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does a grandson have a right by birth in his grandfather’s property?
Not where the grandfather died after 1956 and the property passed to the father under Section 8 of the Hindu Succession Act. In 2026 INSC 1208 the Supreme Court held it is the father’s absolute property.
Can a son file a partition suit against his living father for property inherited from the grandfather?
No, if the father inherited it as a Class I heir under Section 8. The son has no share during his father’s lifetime.
Can the father sell property he got in a family partition?
Yes. On partition among Class I heirs, each becomes exclusive owner of his share and can deal with it freely.
Does Section 29-A of the Tamil Nadu amendment change this?
Not here. The Court held that neither unamended Section 6 nor Section 29-A applied because the grandson was not a surviving coparcener when the grandfather died.
This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Readers should refer to the certified copy of the judgment and consult a qualified professional before acting. See our Editorial Policy and Disclaimer.
