Skip to content
Judicial Accountability · Natural Justice

Supreme Court Expunges High Court Strictures Against District Judge Over Typographical Errors: No Adverse Remarks Without Hearing, High Courts Must Guide the District Judiciary

In In Re: XXX, A Judicial Officer in the District Judge Cadre of Rajasthan Judicial Services, 2026 INSC 1188, the Supreme Court set aside strictures recorded by a Single Judge of the Rajasthan High Court against a POCSO Special Judge, including remarks that she had used ‘cut, copy and paste’, that the judgment was written by her stenographer, and that such an officer was not entitled to remain in service, along with directions to send her for training and to place the order in her ACR. The errors arose because two separate trials from the same FIR (one of a juvenile tried as an adult, one of an adult co-accused) were decided the same day and evidence details overlapped. The Court held that the remarks were passed on the judicial side without giving the officer a chance to explain, in breach of natural justice, and that castigating a judge for inadvertent errors that did not affect the outcome was avoidable.

Key Takeaways

  • High Courts should ordinarily refrain from passing strictures against judicial officers while deciding cases on the judicial side.
  • Criticism of an erroneous order is different from adverse comment on the personal conduct or calibre of the officer.
  • Adverse remarks without first giving the officer an opportunity to explain violate audi alteram partem and cannot stand.
  • Concerns about an officer’s work should go to the Chief Justice or administrative judge through a remark slip, where the officer can explain (Shuvendu Saha, 2026).
  • Such remarks can destroy careers and have a chilling effect on the district judiciary; Article 227 is meant to guide and nurture it.
  • Inadvertent typographical errors that do not affect the outcome do not justify castigation.

Case Details at a Glance

Case titleIn Re: XXX, A Judicial Officer in the District Judge Cadre of Rajasthan Judicial Services (name masked)
Citation2026 INSC 1188 (Reportable)
Case numberCriminal Appeal of 2026 arising out of SLP (Crl.) No. 13501 of 2025
BenchJustice Sandeep Mehta and Justice Devendra Kumar Upadhyaya
Authored byJustice Sandeep Mehta
Date of judgment2 November 2026
Impugned orderRajasthan High Court (Single Judge) order dated 01.05.2025 in suspension of sentence application in S.B. Criminal Appeal No. 426 of 2024
ResultAppeal allowed; remarks in paras 9, 10 and 11 and directions in paras 17 and 18 expunged

Facts of the Case

An FIR of 2019 at Police Station Malsisar, District Jhunjhunu, alleged gang rape of a minor under Section 376-D IPC and the POCSO Act against the victim’s father, a 16-year-old child in conflict with law (CNCL) and another. The Juvenile Justice Board found the CNCL fit to be tried as an adult and transferred his case to the POCSO Special Court. Because Section 23 of the JJ Act, 2015 bars a joint trial of a child and an adult, two separate trials were held.

On 20 January 2024 the appellant, as Special Judge, delivered separate judgments convicting both accused and sentencing each to 20 years’ rigorous imprisonment. Some evidence extracts and witness numbers from one trial were inadvertently carried into the other judgment.

While rejecting the CNCL’s application for suspension of sentence on 1 May 2025, the High Court remarked that the judge had used ‘cut, copy and paste’, that the judgment was in all probability written by a stenographer or clerk, and that a judge who does not dictate the whole judgment is ‘not entitled to remain in service of Judiciary’. It directed that she be trained at the Judicial Academy and that the order be placed in her ACR for 2024. The officer explained before the Supreme Court that the evidence in both trials was intertwined, that the court’s sole stenographer was on leave so part of the judgment was dictated to a clerk, and that the errors were bona fide typing errors that did not affect the result.

Timeline of Proceedings

  • 2019FIR registered at PS Malsisar, Jhunjhunu.
  • 20.01.2024Separate judgments convicting the adult and the juvenile accused.
  • 01.05.2025High Court rejects suspension of sentence and records strictures.
  • 02.11.2026Supreme Court expunges strictures and ACR direction.

Issues Before the Supreme Court

  1. Were the High Court’s strictures against the judicial officer justified?
  2. Could such remarks be made on the judicial side without giving the officer a hearing?

Supreme Court’s Ruling

1. Strictures were uncalled for and in breach of natural justice

The remarks were recorded on the judicial side without any opportunity to the officer to show cause or explain. They therefore suffered from non-adherence to the principles of natural justice.

2. Article 227 calls for guidance, not castigation

The High Court’s power of superintendence under Article 227 is meant to guide, strengthen and nurture the district judiciary. The High Court should have acted with greater magnanimity as guardian of district judges. Castigating an officer for inadvertent typographical errors that did not affect the outcome was avoidable.

3. The settled approach

Relying on Kaushal Singh v. State of Rajasthan (2025), In Re: ‘K’, A Judicial Officer, (2001) 3 SCC 54 and Sonu Agnihotri v. Chandra Shekhar (2024), the Court reiterated the distinction between criticising an erroneous order and commenting on an officer’s conduct. Concerns about conduct should be taken to the Chief Justice on the administrative side. Following Shuvendu Saha v. State of West Bengal, 2026 INSC 367, observations on the quality of a judgment may be recorded in a remark slip placed before the administrative judge or the Chief Justice.

4. Effect on careers and the district judiciary

Such remarks may destroy a judicial officer’s career and chill the entire district judiciary. The Court refused to accept that the officer had been derelict in her duty.

“To castigate a Judicial Officer for inadvertent typographical errors in a judgment, which did not, in any manner, affect the outcome of the case was avoidable.” – Supreme Court, 2026 INSC 1188, para 21

Result

The strictures in paragraphs 9, 10 and 11 of the High Court’s order dated 1 May 2025, and the directions in paragraphs 17 and 18 for training and placement in the officer’s ACR, were expunged and set aside. The appeal was allowed and a copy sent to the Registrar General for placing before the Chief Justice of the Rajasthan High Court.

Analysis and Practical Points

This judgment adds to a growing line of Supreme Court rulings protecting trial judges from harsh remarks in appellate orders. It also recognises the practical pressures in POCSO courts: strict timelines, limited staff and parallel trials required by the JJ Act.

  • High Courts: use the remark slip or administrative route for concerns about judgment quality, and hear the officer first.
  • Judicial officers: where two separate trials arise from one FIR, take particular care with evidence summaries and witness numbering; but if strictures are passed without hearing, an appeal for expunction lies.
  • Litigants: clerical overlaps in a judgment do not by themselves vitiate a conviction if they do not affect the result.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can a High Court pass strictures against a trial judge in a judicial order?

The Supreme Court in 2026 INSC 1188 said High Courts should ordinarily refrain from doing so on the judicial side, and any concern should go to the Chief Justice on the administrative side where the officer can explain.

Must a judicial officer be heard before adverse remarks are made?

Yes. Remarks recorded without giving the officer an opportunity to show cause breach the principle of audi alteram partem and were expunged.

What is a remark slip?

It is a note recording observations on the quality of a judgment or proceedings, placed before the administrative judge or the Chief Justice for follow-up on the administrative side, as recognised in Shuvendu Saha v. State of West Bengal.

Why were two separate judgments delivered in one FIR?

Section 23 of the Juvenile Justice Act, 2015 bars a joint trial of a child in conflict with law and an adult, so separate trials and judgments were mandatory.

This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Readers should refer to the certified copy of the judgment and consult a qualified professional before acting. See our Editorial Policy and Disclaimer.