Findings That Ignore Decisive Documents Are an Error of Law: Supreme Court Upholds High Court’s Certiorari Against Co-operative Society Plot Award
In Prakash Narain Sharma v. Burmah Shell Co-operative Housing Society, 2026 INSC 927, the Supreme Court upheld a Delhi High Court judgment that set aside concurrent orders of the Registrar (acting as arbitrator) and the Delhi Co-operative Tribunal directing the society to allot a plot to a claimant’s heir. The Registrar had presumed the original claimant remained a member all his life and brushed aside evidence that he had resigned, without considering it. The Court reaffirmed that writ courts exercising certiorari do not reappreciate evidence. However, a finding reached by ignoring relevant material, or based on no evidence or conjecture, is an error of law that can be corrected.
Key Takeaways
- Certiorari is supervisory, not appellate. Writ courts do not reweigh evidence.
- But a finding that ignores material evidence, or is based on no evidence or conjecture, is perverse and is an error of law (Bikartan Das).
- The Registrar presumed continued membership without examining the documents on resignation. The Tribunal affirmed this in a six-paragraph order.
- The relevant documents could lead to only one conclusion: the claimant was never admitted as a member.
- The High Court could also consider equity, since four earlier claimants were waiting for plots.
- As there was no membership, the Court did not need to decide whether a plot was available.
Case Details at a Glance
| Case title | Shri Prakash Narain Sharma (Dead) through LR v. M/s Burmah Shell Co-operative Housing Society (Regd) & Ors. |
|---|---|
| Citation | 2026 INSC 927 (Reportable) |
| Case numbers | Civil Appeal Nos. 10693-10694 of 2026 |
| Bench | Justice Ujjal Bhuyan and Justice Atul S. Chandurkar |
| Authored by | Justice Atul S. Chandurkar |
| Date of judgment | 31 August 2026 |
| Impugned | Delhi High Court, 6 October 2010 |
| Advocates who argued | For the appellant: Mr. Jitendra Mohan Sharma, Senior Advocate For the respondent Society: Mr. Ashim Vachher, Senior Advocate |
| Result | Appeals dismissed; no costs |
Background
The original claimant said he was a member wrongly denied a plot. An ex parte award in his favour was set aside by the Supreme Court in 2002, which sent the matter back. On 7 October 2003 the Registrar, as arbitrator, held that he had been a member and directed a plot for his legal heir on payment of the land cost. The Tribunal dismissed the society’s appeal in 2004. In 2010 the High Court allowed the society’s writ petition, finding that relevant material on the claimant’s voluntary resignation had been ignored.
Scope of Certiorari
Relying on Syed Yakoob, Perry and Co. and Bikartan Das, the Court explained that while errors of fact are generally not corrected in certiorari, overlooking material evidence, or a finding unsupported by the overwhelming weight of evidence, is an error of law. The Registrar’s statement that the claimant “has to be presumed” to have remained a member until his death showed exactly this flaw.
Final Decision
Appeals dismissed. The High Court was justified in exercising certiorari jurisdiction. The original claimant was never admitted as a member, so no question of allotting a plot arises.
Analysis and Practical Points
- Litigants before tribunals: make sure key documents are specifically placed on record and argued. Ignoring them can be challenged in writ.
- Co-operative societies: keep clear records of resignations and readmissions.
- Writ practice: frame the challenge as perversity or ignoring material evidence, not as a plea to reappreciate evidence.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can a High Court interfere with findings of fact in a writ of certiorari?
Only if the finding is perverse, based on no evidence, or reached by ignoring material evidence.
Why was the plot award set aside?
The Registrar presumed membership and ignored documents showing the claimant had resigned and was never admitted.
Did the Court decide whether a plot was available?
No. Since there was no membership, that question did not arise.
Which law governed the dispute?
The Delhi Co-operative Societies Act, 1972, with arbitration under Section 61 and appeal under Section 76.
This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Readers should refer to the certified copy of the judgment and consult a qualified professional before acting. See our Editorial Policy and Disclaimer.
